In the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, the force value of Sun Ce, known as the Little Overlord, has not been clearly defined, which is entirely due to sun Ce's early death and no intersection with the famous generals of the Three Kingdoms at its peak. What is his level of strength? How does it compare to Guan Yu? Dear readers, let's analyze it together with Xiaobian!
In the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, a profile description of Sun Ce's military value
Cao Cao once commented on Sun Ce that "lions are difficult to fight with! Cao Cao he Xuren is also known for being good at knowing people, and Ma Chao, who has a very high force value, was also evaluated by Cao Cao as "horses do not die, and I have no burial place!" Although it is also a very high evaluation, but a lion, a horse, the advantages and disadvantages of the judgment, although it can not be judged that Sun Ce's force value is higher than Ma Chao, but at least it shows that Sun Ce's bravery does not lose To Ma Chao. Although Cao Cao was not a first-class military general, Cao Cao, who had single-handedly assassinated Dong Zhuo, was not a weak scholar, and at least he still had a vision.
Cao Cao
Xu Gong once commented on Sun Ce in his informant letter to Cao Cao, saying: "Sun Ce Xiao Yong, similar to Xiang Yuan", xu Gong is who, is Sun Ce's old lair Wu County's taishou, can do Sun Ce's hometown parent official, it can be seen that Xu Gong is definitely Sun Ce very familiar with, trusted people, so Xu Gong's evaluation should be extremely accurate. And to compare Sun Ce with Xiang Yu, who is "the god of feathers, the courage of the ancients", can be seen in Sun Ce's martial courage. The biggest feature of Xiang Yu's martial arts is "power to lift the top", and similar to Sun Ce, sun Ce can also be seen to be extremely powerful.
There are five direct descriptions of Sun Ce's force value
One is when Ping Liu Xuan was in the middle of the day, he was forced to die in Mi and drank to death Fan Neng.
"Mi and Strategize are not in harmony, and they are lightly stretched out by The Ce and captured." Fan Neng hurried over to sneak attack, "That gun just reached the heart of Ce Hou, and Ce Nai shouted loudly, and the sound was like a huge thunder." Fan Neng was horrified, turned upside down and crashed off the horse, breaking his head and dying."
The second was the Battle of Shenting Ridge, a hundred rounds of draws with Tai Shi Ci.
"Two horses intersect, and the battle is fifty, regardless of victory or defeat" "Ci Du returned to the horse and fought again, and then to the fifty." When a shot is thrown, Ci flashes and grabs the gun; Ci also throws a shot, and Ce also flashes and grabs the gun." "Ce choked the short halberd on Tai Shi Ci's back, and Ci also choked on the hood on Ce Ci's head." The strategy will stab Ci, and ci will cover the pocket."
Too Shi Ci
The three places were to attack Wu County and kill Yan You.
"The sword of public opinion stood up, and the flying sword slashed it, and fell down in response."
Everywhere was a meeting with Wang Lang, who stabbed Zhou Ting to death.
"Zhou listened to the dancing knife to meet him, was stabbed to death by a shot, and the rest of the people fell"
In the fifth place, Sun Ce was hunting in the Dantu West Mountain, and was assassinated by Xu Gong's three-door guests.
"A man took a bow and an arrow and shot it, right in the middle of Sun Ce's cheek." Sun Ce took out the arrow in pain and shot the archer to death. The other two raised their guns and poked indiscriminately, and the battle did not retreat, so Sun Ce had to block with a bow and refused to leave. "Sun Ce was shot several times in the body, bleeding profusely and was seriously injured."
Sun Ce's direct record analysis:
One, three, and four descriptions can be grouped into one, whether it is Yu Mi, Fan Neng, Yan You, or Zhou Ting, they all belong to the unpopular martial generals, and Sun Ce's capture is like probing for things, and it is impossible to see its true level, and can only roughly judge that Sun Ce belongs to the first-class military generals.
Sun Ce's hunting and assassination section is that Sun Ce was attacked and seriously injured (with an arrow in the cheek) when he was defenseless, so he was inferior to the other two doormen, which is like a strong man who died at the hands of a child in his sleep, which cannot be used to degrade Sun Ce's level of force, this section does not have much reference value, can only show that Sun Ce has a rough branch in his personality.
The only thing that can really reflect the value of Sun Ce's strength is the section of the battle against Tai Shi Ci, Sun Ce and Tai Shi Ci fought for more than a hundred rounds, basically drawn, but at the beginning, the purpose of the two sides was different, Tai Shi Ci's purpose was to capture Sun Ce alive, so at the beginning he would give his full strength, and Sun Ce had the advantage of his own side (Sun Ce had twelve servants and were all brave generals with names and surnames, while Tai Shi Ci had only one person, and was precarious), and at first he looked down on each other, so with the nature of the game, he did not give his full strength. After being tempted, it was found that Tai Shi Ci was a master and had a heart of love for talent, so in the absence of a dead hand, the two sides were drawn, and it could be seen that Sun Ce should be slightly better.
From the perspective of the ages of both sides, Tai Shi Ci is 31 years old, which is the peak age of life. Sun Ce was only about 20 at the time, far from reaching the peak of force. Therefore, in terms of potential, Sun Ce should also be better than Tai Shi Ci.
Because Sun Ce and Guan Yu have no direct record of confrontation, we compare who is higher and who is lower from the two aspects of indirect comparison and direct comparison.
Sun Ce and Guan Yu indirectly compared
The reference we chose was Zhang Liao, who had dealt with Tai Shi Ci. First, let's look at the record of Tai Shi Ci's war with Zhang Liao.
In the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, Tai Shi Ci and Zhang Liao are described as "seventy or eighty generals fighting each other, regardless of victory or defeat." Although it is written that there is no difference between victory and defeat, but there is a sentence behind it, "Tai Shi Ci saw that someone behind him fell off a horse, abandoned Zhang Liao, and looked forward to the return of the front." "Dare to look behind when you are single-handed, if you can't overpower the other side, who can do it?" Moreover, the situation at that time was that Le Jin and Li Dian were about to seize Sun Quan, and it was reasonable to say that Zhang Liao should also stop Tai Shi Ci when he fought for his old life, and Zhang Liao could not stop Tai Shi Ci, which showed that Tai Shi Ci's force value was better than Zhang Liao.'s
Zhang Liao
The force value of Zhang Liao, who can stop crying at night, is obviously underestimated, as the head of the five sons of Cao Cao's account, he is generally used as a commander, and personal force has become Zhang Liao's auxiliary skill.
Guan Yu once said to Zhang Fei that Zhang Liao's martial arts are not below you and me", moreover, Guan Yu has always looked down on people, and Huang Zhong, who is also a general of the Five Tigers, was rated by Guan Yu as "Huangkou Lao'er, dare to be listed with me?" The eldest husband will not be with the old man after all? ”。 Ma Chao was called "a newly surrendered person who has not made any meritorious achievements", while Zhang Liao can call Guan Yu a brother and a brother, and Guan Yu also attaches great importance to Zhang Liao's face, so that the arrogant Guan Yu can make this evaluation and intersect with sincerity, which shows that Zhang Liao's strength is limited, even if it is not as good as Guan Yu.
Therefore, Sun Ce, who was a little better than Tai Shi Ci, should be able to beat Zhang Liao, who was slightly inferior to Tai Shi Ci, so Sun Ce definitely had a fighting power against Guan Yu, who was slightly higher than Zhang Liao.
Sun Ce and Guan Yu were directly compared
Guan Yu's record is not described in detail here, in short, it is a round of surprise attack to cut Yan Liang, three rounds to chase down Wen Ugly, eighty rounds to win Xu Huang, a hundred rounds to draw Huang Zhong and Pound.
Guan yu
We make a direct comparison from three aspects: momentum, equipment, and martial arts characteristics:
Momentum:
The military general single-handedly picks the first momentum, and in the case of neither side can escape, the momentum is very important.
Guan Yu is good at reading Spring and Autumn, not just a simple martial artist, so his stability is more than enough, lack of sharpness, compared to Sun Ce's young martial courage, he should be slightly inferior in momentum. Moreover, Jiangdong Jiye was a pioneer of Sun Ce, shot by bullet, and as a hegemon, its momentum was unparalleled.
Therefore, as soon as Sun Ce met Guan Yu, he did not say a word and preemptively attacked. At the beginning, there will be a situation in which Sun Ce is the main attacker and Guan Yu is defending.
equip:
Guan Yu has a red rabbit horse and a green dragon and a crescent moon knife. Needless to say, the Red Rabbit Horse, "Traveling Thousands of Miles a Day, Eight Hundred At Night", is definitely a first-class good colt BMW, and the Green Dragon Moon Knife is also tailored for Guan Yu with a thousand pounds of iron, although it is not a peerless divine soldier, but it is not a shoddily made rough soldier. Although the Romance of the Three Kingdoms is not described in detail, Sun Ce is not a hegemon, and the resources in his hands are by no means comparable to Guan Yu, even if the horses are not as good as the red rabbit, but the overlord gun in his hand is a sharp gun forged by a famous craftsman through nine days and nine nights, and the quality is definitely more than the green dragon knife produced by Guan Yu's small workshop.
Red Rabbit Horse
So in terms of equipment, both sides are half a pound and eight two.
Martial Arts Features:
Sun Ce made a gun, Guan Yu used a knife, the gun was three feet eight inches long, weighed sixty-two pounds, the knife was nine feet five inches long, and the sink was eighty-two pounds.
The gun is one of the most difficult weapons to practice among the eighteen weapons, and there is a saying in martial arts: "Moon knife, annual stick, long practice gun". The characteristics of the knife are that it is powerful and heavy, but it is obviously lacking in skill, except for one move to drag the knife, other moves are lackluster.
Therefore, Guan Yu is an absolute strength type martial general, and Sun Ce is biased towards a skillful martial general, but judging from the battle between Sun Ce and Tai Shi Ci, Sun Ce's strength is not low, otherwise he would not be called "Little Overlord" and "similar to Xiang Yuan". However, from the perspective of the weight of the weapon, Sun Ce's strength should be lower than Guan Yu's.
Pure strength warriors like Guan Yu encounter those who are inferior in strength and skill, such as Che Guan, Guan Hai, Bian Xi, etc., kill like chopping melons and cutting vegetables, and encounter those with equal strength and skill, such as Pound De and Huang Zhong, who will not be able to fight for a long time. If Guan Yu could not play the advantage of the red rabbit horse like Yan Liangwen ugly, and end the battle in a short period of time, once he fell into a protracted battle, Guan Yu would be unable to catch him and be dragged to death by the younger Sun Ce.
Guan Yu chopped yan liang
So in summary, you can imagine the situation of the two-engine war:
As soon as the two sides came into contact, Sun Ce would not say a word, stabbed the gun, first seized the opportunity, Guan Yu would fall into the defense of the high and low gears, plus the overlord gun itself was an offensive weapon, so at the beginning Sun Ce would suppress Guan Yu.
After one or twenty rounds, Guan Yu will gradually move back to the disadvantage with the red rabbit horse fast, as well as deeper combat experience, when Guan Yu's momentum reaches its peak, Sun Ce will be very unlucky, the big knife will fly to Sun Ce like a snowflake, Sun Ce only has the strength to fight, because the big knife move is relatively simple, nothing more than chopping these few moves, Sun Ce in the face of such a simple but swift move can only be a hard frame, then it is a very test of the quality of weapons on both sides, Sun Ce with the divine soldier in his hand should be enough to persist for fifty or sixty rounds, When Guan Yu is exhausted, the situation will be reversed again.
Guan Yu vs Sun Ce
When the two sides have fought to a hundred rounds, Guan Yu, who is in a disadvantage, will make the last move - drag to the meter. Guan Yu was defeated and retreated, at this time Sun Ce, who had the upper hand, was already impatient, and with Sun Ce's frizzy personality, he would follow closely behind, at this time Guan Yu would drag it to the meter, the probability of success would be more than 90 percent, with the weight of Guan Yu's Green Dragon Crescent Moon Knife plus Guan Yu's divine power, Sun Ce would be deadly even if he was wearing treasure armor.
Therefore, the final result is that Sun Ce cannot defeat Guan Yu, and just as Sun Ce died of a character with thick branches and leaves, Sun Ce died at the hands of Guan Yu, not because his skills are inferior, but because his personality determines his success or failure!