Originally, it was thought that there would be room for relaxation in Fok Yingdong's long-house property dispute case, but Huo Lina, the second daughter of one of the plaintiffs earlier, once said after appearing in court that she hoped to settle, and the main defendant Huo Zhenhuan also responded that she hoped to be able to settle. However, on the fifth day of the trial, the lawyer on behalf of Huo Zhenhuan bluntly said in court that his sister, brother and sister were full of hostility towards him, so he was not obliged to fulfill the responsibility of disclosing information, especially when there was no relationship of trust between the two parties. It seems that this bureau cannot be broken for a while and a half, and the two sides have no relationship of trust, nor can they sit down calmly and talk, and can only rely on the court to try.
The source of the Fok Yingdong family property dispute case is that some family members believe that the division of property is unfair, and it can also be said that they are basically jealous of Huo Zhenhuan, because Huo Zhenhuan was the successor that Huo Yingdong had approved at that time, in charge of the Huo family's property. Huo Yingdong has five children, including three sons and two daughters, although Huo Zhenting is the eldest son, but Huo Yingdong is not optimistic about him, so Huo Zhenting is only responsible for developing the Huo family's business in sports in the future, in contrast, he is more important to the second son Huo Zhenhuan, which is why the Nansha project that caused the family rights and interests dispute will be responsible for Huo Zhenhuan.
The biggest reason why the members of Fok Ying Tung's longhouse can still set off a property dispute case 16 years after Fok Ying Tung's death is that Fok Ying Tung did not divide the property after his death. Huo Yingdong made a will in 1978, the will stipulates that after Huo Yingdong's death 20 years after the death of the family members can divide the property, as for how to divide after 20 years, in fact, he has long been listed in the will, taking the long house as an example, of which Huo Zhenhuan can get 30 million yuan from the inheritance, Huo Zhenting and Huo Zhenyu can get 20 million yuan, and Huo Liping and Huo Lina can each get 5 million yuan. In addition, family members can get living expenses from the family trust fund every month, Huo Zhenhuan can get 100,000 yuan per month, Huo Zhenting and Huo Zhenyu can get 50,000 yuan per month, and Huo Lina and Huo Liping can each get 10,000 yuan.
Judging from the distribution of the inheritance in Fok Yingdong's will, it is clear that he favored the second son, Huo Zhenhuan. If only men and women are different, it will not cause so much controversy, but not only are there differences between men and women, but there are also differences in the treatment among sons, so this has triggered the dissatisfaction of Huo Zhenyu, the third son of Changfang. In fact, in 2011, Huo Zhenyu had already questioned the distribution of Huo Yingdong's estate, when he cooperated with Huo Lina and Huo Liping to apply to take away the identity of the executor of Huo Zhenhuan's estate, and even asked for the liquidation of Huo Yingdong's estate, which once set off a storm of property disputes, and later relied on the intervention of the outside world, the Huo family signed a settlement agreement in 2021, and at that time, 2.5 billion Hong Kong dollars had been distributed to 16 members of the Huo family. But in fact, Huo Zhenyu's dissatisfaction with Huo Zhenhuan has not diminished, and he also asked in 2012 to appoint independent accountants to investigate the value of the estate.
Huo Zhenhuan
Huo Zhenyu's dissatisfaction with Huo Zhenhuan is based on Huo Yingdong's preference for Huo Zhenhuan, Huo Zhenhuan has obtained Huo Yingdong's weight, has been assisting his father in taking care of business, many important industries are handled by Huo Zhenhuan, so Huo Zhenyu believes that Huo Zhenhuan must have made a lot of benefits from it, so he will persevere in appealing, so there is today's one-yuan repurchase of Nansha 7 billion yuan rights and interests dispute. To say that Huo Zhenhuan did not know the location of these disputes, he must know that Huo Zhenhuan's lawyer said that in order to maintain family harmony and his father's reputation, Huo Zhenhuan had agreed to share the 1.6 billion yuan in a fund and the shares of a family company jointly held with his father with family members, which was the greatest sincerity he gave.
Huo Zhenyu
As for Fok Yingdong's legacy and the Nansha project, Huo Zhenhuan had no benefit from it, but where did the family members headed by Huo Zhenyu believe it? Looking back, regarding the Nansha project, Huo Zhenhuan's lawyer revealed that Huo Zhenyu once described the project as a "pig skull" in the meeting, that is to say, it was impossible to achieve, so he opposed investing in the Nansha project. Later, after Huo Zhenyu met with the former chief executive to understand the project, he learned that the original project was a golden mountain, which led to the later coveting of this project.
Mr. Huo's lawyer
Huo Zhenhuan's insistence on the Nansha project is not in the amount of benefits, but in the realization of a real estate dream of his father. This is the gap between the two sides in the perception of the Nansha project, which also makes the case publicly heard, the presiding judge will point out in court that the case is sentimental, pointing out that the long house woman is only filing a lawsuit for personal interests, Huo Liping and Huo Zhenyu only pay attention to the economic interests of the Nansha development project, and Huo Zhenhuan just wants to realize his father's real estate dream.
Since there is no sense of trust between the plaintiff and the defendant, it is impossible to settle out of court, and before Huo Lina was interviewed, she said that she wanted to settle, I am afraid it was only a temporary feeling, and Huo Zhenhuan's response was also a superficial effort. In fact, now huo Zhenhuan let the lawyer on the fifth day of the trial say that the sister, brother and sister are full of hostility towards themselves, so on the basis of no trust between the two sides, they refuse to disclose any relevant information, nor are they obliged to disclose any information, and this bureau may be difficult to reconcile.
PS: The pictures are all from the Internet