The 7 billion yuan property dispute case of the second generation of the Fok Ying Tung family has been officially heard. Because this is a case of a property dispute between the giants, it also happened in the Fok Yingdong family, so it has attracted much attention. What the outside world is more curious about is what the attitude of the second generation of members of the long house who have caused infighting is what their attitudes are, and then in the past few days of trial, the media has been crouching outside the courtroom, hoping to have the opportunity to visit the huo family members who appeared in court.
The only members of the Huo family who appeared in court on these two days were the main defendant Huo Zhenhuan and one of the plaintiffs, Huo Lina, who were brothers and sisters of the same father and mother, and because of the conflict of interests, they went to court. On the first day of the trial, Huo Lina and Huo Zhenhuan once refused to visit the media, but after the second day, when Huo Lina was asked by the media whether she still wanted to continue to sue, she originally did not want to respond, and then after thinking about it, she said that she had always wanted to reconcile, and then boarded the car and left. When the main defendant Huo Zhenhuan left, he was told that Huo Lina said that he wanted to reconcile, and he finally said that he had always wanted to reconcile. Since both sides want to reconcile, it is puzzling why the family did not sit down and talk about the matter well.
First of all, let's talk about the source of this property dispute case of Huo Yingdong's family, the dispute over the rights and interests of this property dispute occurred in Huo's parents' room, of course, it also involves the interests of the second and third rooms of the Huo family, but the interests of the second and third rooms are not large, and the members of the two wives' rooms are relatively low-key, and they will not be involved if they are not necessary. Speaking of which, in 2011, Fok Chun-woo, the third son of Fok's parents, entered the Hong Kong High Court as the executor of the estate, demanding the removal of two other executors of Fok Ying-tung's estate, including Fok Zhenhuan, who believed that Fok Chun-wan had taken the estate as private and did not follow Fok Ying-tung's inheritance distribution system, and demanded that he hand over the estate.
Fok Ying Tung made his last will on May 20, 1978, and it was not changed until his death in 2006. The will emphasizes that in the 20 years after his death, the family members can not distribute the remaining inheritance, can only receive a fixed monthly living expenses, the amount of living expenses can be adjusted as appropriate, so the Huo family members have been implementing the system of public ownership of property over the years, most of the members Ruijin live in houses are not under private names. Therefore, Huo Zhenyu proposed that Huo Zhenhuan hand over the inheritance was not reasonable, and Huo Zhenhuan refuted Huo Zhenyu at that time. Later, relying on the intervention of Tung Chee-hwa and Liang Aishi to mediate, all members of the Huo family, including members of the second and third rooms, reached a settlement in August 2012.
Unexpectedly, after ten years, the Huo family property dispute case has once again become the focus. The plaintiff in this property dispute case is still Huo Zhenyu, the third son of Changfang, in fact, he has filed a lawsuit with the court in 2015 over Huo Zhenhuan's concealment of the 7 billion yuan worth of interests in the development of Nansha, and at that time he had already obtained approval to appeal and restart the lawsuit for property, and this round of property dispute was finally put on the agenda in 2022. What is different from ten years ago is that this time, in addition to Huo Zhenhuan, the plaintiff also has Huo Lina and Huo Lilian, the two daughters of Huo Yingdong's longhouse, and the defendant in addition to Huo Zhenhuan, there is also a defendant Huo Zhenting, which means that Huo Zhenting's parents are now divided into two factions, one is headed by Huo Zhenyu and the other is headed by Huo Zhenhuan.
The property struggle case has always been a social focus, not to mention that it also occurred in such a prestigious Fok Yingdong family. Telling the real rich family property dispute case is basically a joke to the outside world, and the members of the Huo family are not unaware, but why do they make things so big and why not close the door and the family has a business to discuss and solve the matter? In the end, it is still a matter of equity, after all, it involves 7 billion. Huo Zhenyu believes that Huo Zhenhuan has the intention to conceal that he can buy back the interests of the 7 billion yuan project in Nansha for 1 yuan, and only after the timeliness has passed, it will be made public, and Huo Zhenhuan has become the biggest beneficiary, which is deception, so he filed a lawsuit. Huo Lina and Huo Lilian also believe that Huo Zhenhuan was deceived and joined Huo Zhenyu's camp, and now the five people on both sides have each sent a representative lawyer to refute the matter.
The family ugliness should not have been publicized, and as a result, it became the focus of the whole city, and the faces of the descendants of the Huo family could not hang on, and they were all brothers and sisters of the same father and mother, and they had to make trouble, and they also had to go to court, which was really cold. The property dispute case was tried for several days, and the first to go to court were Huo Lina and Huo Zhenhuan, who had testified in court for several days, and in court, Huo Zhenhuan's lawyer pointed out that Huo Zhenhuan was the only person who learned that he could buy back the 7 billion yuan project in Nansha for one yuan, but the other party did not disclose it until the family meeting was held in November 2011, which was concealment. Huo Zhenhuan said that the repurchase was meaningless to Fok Yingdong, so it was not disclosed.
The two sides argued in court, but when the court was adjourned, they both expressed their willingness to reconcile. Hollina walked out of the courtroom during the adjournment and initially refused to visit, but when asked if she wanted to go on and whether she wanted to settle, she affirmed that of course she wanted to settle. When Huo Zhenhuan stepped out of the courtroom and was told that Huo Lina had proposed a wish to reconcile, Huo Zhenhuan also said that of course he wanted to reconcile. When asked if there would be a turn in this matter, and whether the family wanted to get together before the New Year, Huo Zhenhuan did not think about it and said that he had always longed, which showed that he did not want to make such a scene.
However, whether the two sides can make a turn and whether they can settle privately is really not something that Can be achieved by Huo Lina or Huo Zhenhuan with a single statement, and if they can, they will not go to court, after all, it involves each other's interests, and in addition, the real plaintiff Huo Zhenyu's willingness to settle is the key. At present, Huo Zhenyu does not need to appear in court for the time being, his appearance in court is set for January 18, and whether there can be a turnaround can only wait and see.
PS: The pictures are all from the Internet