Water Margin
As one of the four classical Masterpieces of China, the wonderful plot of "Water Margin" has been centered on "One Hundred Singles and Eight Generals" for hundreds of years, which has aroused the attention and love of many Chinese people. Today, as the first issue of "Liangshan Po on Martial Arts", we opened a hot topic - the duel between a member of the Eight Horsemen of Liangshan Po and a member of Xiao Biao: Xu Ning vs Sun Li
Xu Ning
Sun Li
Then next, we will give answers from four aspects: summary of battle achievements, quality of battle achievements, positioning of martial arts, and detailed summary:
I. Summary of Achievements:
Xu Ning:
1. Dongping Province vs. DongPing 50 rounds
2. Lost to Aliki in thirty rounds during the Conquest of Liao
3. Kill Tianshan Yong in twenty rounds during the Conquest of Liao:
4. Kill Lü Shixiang in twenty rounds when zhengfang lashi:
5. Draw with Wu Fu in the 30 rounds of Zheng Fangla:
Sun Li:
1. Zhujiazhuang 50 rounds of raw stone show (fake fight)
2. Thirty rounds of draws:
3. Kill Kou Zhenyuan during the Liao Conquest:
4. The scope of the battle of Zhengfang La has the upper hand
5. Thirty rounds of conscription to draw Zhen Cheng
6. Zheng Fangla killed Zhang Wei after the destruction of Suzhou City
7. Capture Lei Jiong alive when Zheng Fangla attacked Yuling Pass
8. Zheng Fangla, together with Lin Chong, Huang Xin, and Er Zou, joined forces to kill Wang Yin:
Second, the quality of battle achievements:
In terms of performance, Sun Li is better than Xu Ning. But in this link, we analyze the quality of the two warriors' records, and this time only list the records with comparative and reference value to illustrate.
Golden Gunner Xu Ning
Xu Ning's only "high gold content" record is that the two guns of the great war will dong ping more than fifty times without winning or losing. The double-gun general Dong Ping was one of the five tiger generals of Liangshan Po, and when he debuted as a defender of Dongchang Province, he fought against Liang Shan Po, easily defeating Han Tao, the Yusheng general of Liangshan Po, forcing Song Jiang to hurry up in time for Xu Ning to replace Han Tao to meet Dong Ping. The two fought for more than fifty rounds without winning or losing, although it is mentioned in the book that Song Jiang feared Xu Ning's loss, but it did not show any signs of Xu Ning's defeat or inferiority. Just as the Qingzhou City of Perak Fire Qin Ming fought with two whips Hu Yanzhuo for forty or fifty rounds, Murong Prefect feared that Hu Yanzhuo would lose his voice and collect troops, but Hu Yanzhuo claimed that he could defeat Qin Ming if he continued to fight. This example shows that "fear of loss" does not mean inferiority, as long as it is not the author's narrator who clearly points out that there are signs of defeat on one side. Although Dong Ping appeared late, he also reflected his martial arts prowess. After fifty rounds of battle with Xu Ning, he could rampage into the Liangshan Po Army and fight for a long time, and later he also had a record of killing the enemy. Therefore, Dong Ping has the strength of the Five Tigers in both position and strength, xu Ning can play with the top masters of the Five Tigers for more than fifty rounds, although Dong Ping defeated Han Tao in the front relatively lost a certain amount of physical strength, but also reflects Xu Ning's strong strength. As for Xu Ning's other achievements, including the only defeat against Archie, the opponents have no other contrasting records, so they cannot be referred to. It also proves that the liao general Aliqi's strength is too perverted and can override the five tiger generals. Therefore, because of Xu Ning's "black history", we cannot insist that it is weaker than Sun Li, who has no defeat
Sick Lieutenant Chi Sun Li
There are two "high gold content" achievements about Sun Li, the first is the Battle of Liangshan Po and Hu Yanzhuo; the second is Zheng Fangla's killing of Zhang Wei.
(1) Sun Li's great battle Hu Yanzhuo:
We said a long time ago in this battle, Song Jiang put down five battles, the first thunderbolt fire Qin Ming took the lead, only twenty rounds let Hu Yanzhuo's deputy general Yusheng win Han Tao, the second leopard head Lin Chong and Hu Yanzhuo fought for more than fifty rounds, the third team Ofi Li Guanghuarong first defeated the Tianmu general Peng Xuan with twenty rounds, and then fought with Hu Yanzhuo three to three. In the fourth formation, the third lady of the Qing Dynasty first fought against Peng Xuan with Tianmu for more than twenty times, and after being defeated, she took advantage of the opportunity to capture Peng Xuan alive with a noose. Hu Yan was forced to burn with anger, but he still couldn't take down the Third Lady for more than ten rounds. Chi SunLi, the fifth sick lieutenant, used a single whip to fight Against Hu Yanzhuo's double whip, and fought for more than thirty times without winning or losing. This battle needs to be carefully analyzed, starting from three aspects: the factors of the battle, the purpose of the battle, and the outcome of the battle. Needless to say about the battle factors, the two people Hu Yanzhuo first fought with Lin Chong for fifty rounds, Hua Rong and Peng Xuan fought for twenty rounds in the middle, and then fought against Hua Rong for three rounds. Later, he watched the three ladies capture Peng Xuan in twenty rounds, and it can be said that the single confrontation between Hu Yanzhuo and Hua Rong was ignored, and in terms of the number of rounds, Hu Yanzhuo fought first for fifty rounds, and rested for forty rounds in the middle. Later, he fought against the third lady for more than ten rounds. Therefore, Sun Li is facing the relative consumption of physical strength, and the degree of physical exertion is about 10% to 20%. This battle can be regarded as an unfair battle for Sun Li to wait for work, but Sun Li can still fight with such a top master for thirty rounds without winning or losing, which can be seen that Sun Li's strength is not bad. As for Sun Li's single whip against Hu Yanzhuo's double whip, it is not the basis for Sun Li to be at a "disadvantage", why does Sun Li not use a single whip with a golden gun. It is more likely that the battle between the whips gives Sun Li a better advantage, because in the face of Hu Yanzhuo, who is holding a double whip, Sun Li may suffer losses simply by fighting with a golden gun, and it is more difficult to use the gun whip to fight together, so he can only use the same kind of weapon to fight. The purpose of the battle can be seen from the later plot, Song Jiang took advantage of Sun Li's great battle to yanzhuo, afraid of Han Tao's killing, so he first ordered Liangshan Po's soldiers and horses to cover up the past. It can be concluded that Sun Li was trying to drag Hu Yanzhuo and let the Song Jiang soldiers and horses take the opportunity to fight and collide, so as to achieve the purpose of defeating Hu Yanzhuo's soldiers and horses. And Hu Yanzhuo was also to capture or defeat the Liangshan Po thief Kou alive, so both Hu Yanzhuo and Sun Li had no room for mercy, and this big war can be said to be a fight for their lives. As for the outcome of the battle, the two fought for more than thirty rounds because of the interruption of the soldier and horse fighting, which did not show that the two sides were defeated. Referring to the double whip Hu Yanzhuo, although he is one of the five tiger generals of Liangshan Po, he does not have a good record of quick victory against martial generals who are relatively low in martial arts, and it will take more than ten rounds to win against Li Zhong, a tiger fighting general at Xiao Biao's level, and more than twenty rounds to defeat and capture alive against the maotou star Kong Ming, and it will take six or seven rounds to defeat zhou Tong, a small bully who is not in the flow of battle. Therefore, Sun Li was able to draw thirty rounds with the physically exhausted Hu Yanzhuo, and the gold content was not high. It can only prove that Sun Li has the strength of the Eight Horsemen, if he continues to fight, Sun Li may be inferior or defeated, or fight against Hu Yanzhuo in full state, sun Li's upper limit may only be thirty or forty rounds. Compared with Xu Ning's record of fifty rounds against Dong Ping, Sun Li was obviously incomparable.
(2) Sun Lizheng Fangla killed Zhang Wei:
Let's do another brief analysis. This Zhang Wei was the Eight Horsemen under the command of Fang Mao, the three kings of the Southern Kingdom, who fought with Qin Ming for more than thirty rounds without winning or losing, and was later killed by Sun Li when the city of Suzhou was broken. Therefore, some people think that Sun Li's achievements already have the strength of the Five Tiger Generals or surpass Qin Ming, and personally think that this is pure nonsense. Because this battle does not account for the number of rounds in the book, nor does it explain various factors, but simply tells sun Li's killing of Zhang Wei. The relevant example is that Lin Chong once fought with Zhu Long for thirty rounds without winning or losing, and later when Zhu Jiazhuang was attacked, Zhu Long was killed by the black whirlwind Li Kui, but it could not be proved that Li Kui was stronger than Lin Chong. For another example, the great knife Guan Sheng once fought with he Chongbao, the deputy commander of the Liao State, for thirty rounds to force his strength to leave undefeated, but when Liangshan Po broke the siege of Qingshiyu, He Chongbao was cut off by Huang Xin of Zhensanshan. It is also impossible to argue that Huang Xin's strength is stronger or equal to Guan Sheng.'s Therefore, although the gold content of this battle is high for Sun Li, it is still impossible to compare and refer to martial arts.
III. Positioning of Martial Arts:
In summary, based on the analysis of Xu Ning and Sun Li's achievements, we further infer the martial arts positioning of the two men
Golden Gunner Xu Ning:
Through the above analysis, the golden gunner Xu Ning can play against the top master Wuhu General (Double Gun General Dong Ping) for more than fifty rounds without winning or losing. The martial arts are slightly inferior to the Five Tigers will be under the same level, judging the martial arts positioning:
Sick Lieutenant Chi Sun Li:
Through the above analysis, The Sick Lieutenant Chi Sun Li can play against the top master Five Tiger Generals (Double Whip Hu YanZhuo) for thirty or forty rounds without winning or losing. The level of martial arts is weaker than that of the Five Tiger Generals and the Eight HorseMen, and the positioning of martial arts is judged:
IV. Summary of the Martial Commentary:
Regarding the martial arts competition between the golden gunner Xu Ning and the sick lieutenant Chi Sunli, we have carefully analyzed it. Obviously, Xu Ning's martial arts level was above Sun Li's. Sun Li, as one of the Xiao Biao generals of the Earth Fire Constellation and the Liangshan Po Horse Army, was able to compete with Xu Ning, the Tiangang Zheng in the forefront of the Eight HorseMen, and it could also be regarded as fighting for the light of the Earth Fire Star! After analyzing the level of martial arts through various methods, we will analyze the actual combat ability. We can assume that Xu Ning and Sun Li have a fight, that is, a fight between the top level of the Eight Horsemen and the middle level of the Eight Horsemen, and xu Ning may take forty or fifty rounds to defeat Sun Li. Moreover, Sun Li's golden gun and steel whip are all-powerful, and Xu Ning's attempt to defeat Sun Li is even more difficult. Therefore, there is a certain gap between Sun Li and Xu Ning in actual combat, but the gap is not large