On the evening of December 11, the 6th episode of "Director Please Advise" was broadcast. This episode broadcast two works, namely Bao Bell's "Don't Laugh" and Xiang Guoqiang's "Not Bad Money", the two works were broadcast after the word of mouth was diametrically opposite, Bao Bell was praised, but Xiang Guoqiang attracted one-sided bad reviews, this process has a lot of interesting points.
Bao Bell's reputation reversed, leaving film critics dumbfounded
The work brought by This issue of Bao Bell is adapted from the novel of the same name "No Laughter", which tells the story of a family that cannot laugh, as long as it laughs, it will immediately teleport, the first half of the laughter is more dense, and the final ending is very warm, Yang Haoyu and Zhu Zhixin's performance is very good.
After the work was broadcast, it was generally praised by the audience, and the final public attendance rate reached 97%, the professional attendance rate reached 68%, and the total number of votes was 228 votes, which was a very high result.
However, I can feel that Bao Bell, who has been criticized for being on stage, is actually quite nervous, especially this part of Li Chengru's comments, hearing Li Chengru give positive praise, the camera cut to Bao Bell, he grew a breath and relaxed a lot.
Yang Chao, the director of "Yangtze River Map", also praised the work as an "accurate and qualified genre comedy film", and the final vote also proved that this is indeed a funny and warm work.
In the "Start Shooting" program on another platform the day before, he even screened out the content of "My Adolescence" criticizing Bao Bell on the big screen, which shows that Bao Bell, who has been criticized for a long time, has made a turnaround battle through this show and the work of "Don't Laugh", of course, in addition to his accurate grasp of commercial genre films, it is also due to the good foundation of the original novel and the excellent performance of the actors.
But what is more interesting is that after the film critic Meng Zhong talked about his understanding of high and low levels, he sent a number of videos criticizing Bao Bell's film critic "Uncle Yuan" and came out to "provoke trouble", and he first asked Bao Bell what he thought of the word "senior" said by Meng Zhong.
Bao Bell should feel that this question is not easy to grasp, and also feel that the film critics are "setting up" themselves, he immediately said: "Why don't you ask Teacher Meng Zhong, what do you ask me to do?" Bao Bell's answer made "Uncle Yuan" dumbfounded for a while.
On the other side of the stage, there is already a suspected Voice of Chen Zhixi who can't stop laughing, when the camera cuts to Li Chengru, and he is clapping and applauding, such a scene does make the film critics a little embarrassed.
At this point, "Uncle Yuan" did not know what to say, so he tried to win Bao Bell over and said that it was a very beneficial issue for him. At this time, Bao Bell still asked back, saying: "Then you answer me first, if I answer wrong, it will not be beneficial to me?" At this time, the camera gave "Uncle Yuan", obviously seeing that the smile on his face was a little embarrassed, Wang Jing on the stage and the audience on the stage began to applaud, applauding Bao Bell's wit.
At this time, "Far Uncle" did not know how to round the field, had to say that there was no standard for advanced or not advanced, and let Bao Bell boldly answer. In fact, for this question, Bao Bell can not answer at all, but he still gave the other side, using the example of going to the restaurant, the answer is very decent, and the final landing point is very modest to say that he is not advanced enough, but also to continue to learn. It shows that Bao Bell is indeed very emotionally intelligent.
In fact, Bao Bell and "Far Uncle" this confrontation, the audience's attitude can obviously feel that it is on the side of Bao Bell, the program broadcast six episodes, each episode of the film critics' comments are actually difficult to convince the public, and even unfair, let people feel that it is a malicious bad review of the situation, Bao Bell's "Not Allowed to Laugh" is really good, but also successfully poked the audience laugh, worth such a high score.
Xiang Guoqiang was badly interested, and Hao Lei criticized the three people in a paragraph
The second work broadcast in this issue is Xiang Guoqiang's "Not Bad Money". Xiang Guoqiang chose to use the film and television circle as the creative material, the story tells a well-known director and actress in the car to do indecent things, by paparazzi and Chaoyang aunt tracking, and think that the car wash shop staff got the "evidence", with this information dislocation to stimulate laughter, but the film has not finished playing because the number of votes is less than 120 and stopped playing.
As commented by the guests on the spot, this work does have many problems, shaping the actress into a vase, relying on the body to appear is suspected of insulting the actress, the expression is vulgar and low-level, the narrative of the entire event is completely distorted, people cannot believe it, and the actor's performance has no credibility, perfunctory, and exaggerated.
Among them, Hao Lei's criticism is the most severe, she ridiculed three people in one paragraph, she first said "I don't know what they are acting", which is equivalent to not recognizing the performance of all actors. Then I questioned how it could be made so strong. He thought that as a director, he had no minimum requirements for the performance of the actor, and then mocked him for liking "showmanship".
Then Hao Lei turned sharply and asked Xiang Guoqiang, "Do you have any misunderstandings about actresses with acting skills?" ”
This sentence is obviously a criticism of tang Jingmei, the actor who plays a female star in the work, she does have exaggerated acting skills, ungrounded, and emotionless in it, and the fake crying scene makes people uncomfortable to watch.
Later, Hao Lei criticized that being able to sing does not mean being able to act, and said that this problem is already very serious, and this sentence is obviously about Wang Mian, who plays Xiao Li.
It should be considered that the lead actor Fan Ming is a highly respected actor and predecessor, so Hao Lei skipped him, there was no criticism, but in all fairness, Fan Ming did show a very exaggerated performance in this work.
Obviously one-sided bad reviews, but Xiang Guoqiang does not bow his head and does not admit defeat, on the one hand, he says that he does not care about reviews, on the other hand, he insists that his works are very "fierce" and can ferment in the secondary market.
Seeing that the contradiction between the two sides was becoming more and more intense, Fan Ming, who stood on the stage, also took the microphone to explain for the director, admitting that the work did have shortcomings, but the director's time was too tight to seriously emphasize the actor's performance. Fan Ming's attitude is very sincere, but what he said about the limited time of 3 days is actually not a reason, after all, everyone's works are filmed within the specified time, but most of the works are not so bad.
Producer Fang Li also came up with an attitude of admitting mistakes and being beaten, apologizing for himself and Xiang Guoqiang, which is the most correct way to deal with it in the show!
It is worth mentioning that although Xiang Guoqiang has always been hard-mouthed and insisted that her works will ferment in the secondary market and get surprising feedback, the truth is not as she hoped.
After the program was launched that night, Xiang Guoqiang shared the full version of "Not Bad Money" through social platforms, and as of press time, there were nearly 300 comments, and most of the audience was also critical.
Moreover, some people questioned him about what the "secondary market" was, and Xiang Guoqiang did not respond to these questions.
What is your evaluation of the works of Bao Bell and Xiang Guoqiang in this issue?