Wuxia stories are made up, can be logical and smooth, the plot is self-justifying, even a complete story is very difficult, obviously Jin Yong's story is on the basis of completeness is still wonderful enough, this is the reason why his work can become a classic, but nevertheless, as long as it is made up, there will always be some small flaws, such as the "sword demon" lonely and defeated This role related plot, Jin Yong even sealed the pen did not unfold to say.
(Stills of Yang Guo and Xiaolongnu)
Alone and defeated has been mentioned in a total of three works, namely "Divine Eagle Hero", "Laughing Proud of the Jianghu" and "Deer Dingji", but in the three works, his story is only mentioned by others, he himself did not appear, who is his real identity? Who did he beat? In which era was he active? These questions are difficult to understand, but the inheritance of his sword technique can be explored, for example, Yang passed the sword tomb where he was alone and defeated, and he did not see things like the "Nine Swords of Solitude and Sword Spectrum", how did feng Qingyang in the future learn this trick?
First, Yang's adventures
After reading the first half of "Divine Eagle Hero", most people may wonder, what is the relationship between this story and the "Divine Eagle"? So then the divine eagle appeared, but the first appearance of the divine eagle is not so "god", it was almost killed by a giant python, fortunately Yang Guo rescued, only out of danger, and then Yang Guo broke his arm, and then defected to the god eagle, practicing the sword technique of seeking defeat alone.
What's in the sword tomb? First, it is a self-description of the life of loneliness and defeat carved on the stone wall.
(Stills of Lonely Defeat)
The original said: "After more than thirty years of crossing the rivers and lakes, killing all the enemies and defeating the heroes, the world has no resistance, there is no choice, but to live in a deep valley and take the eagle as a friend." alack! Life seeks an enemy and cannot get it, and it is embarrassing to be lonely. ”
Looking at this description, it is really domineering, and it has not been defeated by anyone for more than thirty years.
Then the swords in the sword tomb can also prove from the side that what he said is not false, from the sword to the soft sword to the heavy sword and even the wooden sword, the sword technique of seeking defeat alone has gradually improved, and finally even reached the realm of no sword winning over the sword, and it is not surprising that he can create such a delicate martial art as the lonely nine swords.
But wait, where is the sword spectrum of the Lone Nine Swords? From the beginning to the end, Yang Guo had never found such a sword book in that sword tomb, what he had always practiced was the Xuantie Sword Technique, so how did this sword technique skip yang guo's hands that yang had passed on to the future generations?
Second, Yang Guo created his own sword method
It is precisely because there is no "Lonely Nine Swords Sword Spectrum" in the world, and Feng Qingyang has learned that sword method, so some people think that the Lonely Nine Swords are actually the sword method created by Yang Guoji after the strengths of hundreds of families, after all, the later Yang Guo's martial arts erudition is indeed the condition of self-creation of divine skills, and his self-creation is the best proof, but there are also several doubts here that can refute this statement.
First, if Yang Guo created his own Nine Swords of Solitude, why not call it "Yang Guojiu Sword" or "Divine Eagle Nine Sword", but instead name this set of sword techniques in the name of Solitude and Defeat, paying tribute to the predecessors? It seems far-fetched.
Second, if this sword technique was created by Yang Guo, why did Feng Qingyang not mention Yang Guo's name at all later? Instead, do you know the story of solitude and defeat?
(Yang Guo stills)
For example, this introduction: "Lonely Nine Swords, there is no retreat!" The moves are all attacks, and the enemy has to defend, of course, he does not have to defend. The lonely and defeating predecessor who created this set of sword techniques is called 'Seeking Defeat', his old man's lifelong desire to seek defeat and cannot be obtained, this sword method is displayed, the world is invincible, and why should he keep it? If someone attacks his old man's home and defends himself with his sword, his old man will really be overjoyed and overjoyed. ”
If this move was created by Yang Guo, the "lonely and defeated" mentioned here should be replaced by "Yang Guo".
Third, Yang Guo had not used the Xuantie Heavy Sword in the later period, and even finally gave the Xuantie Sword to Guo Jing and his wife, how could he have created a set of sword techniques of his own in one fell swoop?
Obviously, the LoneLy Nine Swords were created by Lonely Nine Swords himself, and had nothing to do with Yang Guo, but this returned to the original question, how did the Lonely Nine Swords cross Yang Guo and pass directly to Feng Qingyang's hands?
(Stills of Feng Qingyang)
There is only one answer, lonely and defeated, not dead, until the future life, Feng Qingyang is his own inheritance, so he will know so much about his deeds.
Third, Wang Chongyang's experience
Yang Guo had such an emotion when he learned of the high-ranking person who was alone and seeking defeat, the original said: "The predecessors of the martial arts have never mentioned that the lonely seek defeat is his person, so he is at least a figure from sixty or seventy years ago. ”
This is just his speculation, what if he was alone in the era of "double eagles" and no longer called himself "lonely and defeated"? For example, change your identity and become a monk?
It is possible that Wang Chongyang was the world's first master, but the doujiu monk won in the process of fighting wine with him, on the surface, this is just a doujiu, but the chip is "borrowing the Nine Yin True Scriptures", if it were not for the fact that this doujiu monk's martial arts were far better than Wang Chongyang's, would Wang Chongyang have lent out the scriptures in such a hasty duel as doujiu? There is only one possibility, he is not the opponent of the fighting monk at all, but the entanglement of the fighting monk, can only decide the victory or defeat in the way of fighting wine, and lose such a decent game.
And that drunken monk is most likely a surviving lonely man who seeks defeat, and the character of solitude and defeat is to defeat the world's masters, but he will feel guilty for "injuring the righteous warrior by mistake", which shows that he will not give a dead hand to the righteous warrior, so he chose to fight with Wang Chongyang, which is consistent with his personal design.
But if the drunken monk is alone and seeks defeat, and new problems arise, can he live that long? It is really possible that in the "Eight Parts of the Heavenly Dragon", Tianshan Tong Yao said a sentence "People do not scatter their skills, which is so easy to die", the solitary and defeat martial arts are extremely high, the internal strength is deep, it is naturally not easy to die, he is most likely to have been active in the martial forest, but he has changed his identity.
Therefore, Feng Qingyang was able to learn the Nine Swords of Solitude, and there was only one possibility, that is, he directly encountered the solitude and defeat in his later years, and got the personal inheritance of solitude and defeat, so he would know the deeds of the lonely predecessors very well.