Friends always ask me about Li Shaohong's new version of "Dream of the Red Chamber" and the 87th edition of "Dream of the Red Chamber". To tell the truth, I am not good at film critics, and I also have respect for the performing arts, but I don't understand it. However, I have been asked a lot, and I will say a little bit of my own opinion, why the new version of "Dream of the Red Chamber" directed by Li Shaohong will cause more bad reviews, while the eighty-seven version of "Dream of the Red Chamber" is regarded as a classic.
The 1987 edition of "Dream of the Red Chamber" is a product of the times. In that era when entertainment and literature were relatively less colorful. A group of creators who love "Dream of the Red Chamber" have spent years carefully crafting works, and once presented, they are unprecedented.
Although before the 87th edition of "Dream of the Red Chamber", there were already several versions of Zhuyu in front. For example, the opera master Wang Wenjuan, who is now being talked about, has a version of "Dream of the Red Chamber".
However, the opera version is, after all, a stage expression, separated from life. No matter how classic it is, it is not as "life- There are always people who compare Wang Wenjuan's Lin Daiyu with Chen Xiaoxu's Lin Daiyu. To tell the truth, Guan Gongzhan Qin Qiong was not comparable at all.
Wang Wenjuan's Lin Daiyu is a stage role, and Lin Daiyu in life cannot be like that. If it is in the heart of opera lovers, it must be the most classic.
Chen Xiaoxu's Lin Daiyu is a literary character living, and if Lin Daiyu is alive, it is probably similar to it - including Lin Daiyu in later versions of TV series. The characters in life make Chen Xiaoxu's Lin Daiyu more deeply rooted in the hearts of the people.
The 1987 version of "Dream of the Red Chamber" wins in the artistic life of presenting most of the scenes of the original "Dream of the Red Chamber", and each actor is as close as possible to the essence of the original characters. Many red scholars escorted. Even if the Jia family is real life, it is also restored as much as possible. This is the insurmountable value of the eighty-seven version.
Of course, many of the plot settings of the eighty-seven edition of "Dream of the Red Chamber" and the adaptation after the eighty times are quite different from the reading comprehension of junji Yakan's red chamber, and are not evaluated.
The first victory of the 87th edition of "Dream of the Red Chamber" is in the shape. And Li Shaohong's new version of "Dream of the Red Chamber" was destroyed in style.
Although the shape of the 1987 version of "Dream of the Red Chamber" cannot get rid of the influence of opera costumes, it is more lifelike and easier to be accepted by the audience.
As soon as the new version of "Dream of the Red Chamber" came out, it triggered an uproar in public opinion. The "copper coin head" on the opera stage made people think of Xu Ke's movie "Green Snake" for the first time. However, the 120-minute volume of the movie is used for dozens of episodes of the TV series, which cannot help but make people scream and unacceptable.
The use of "copper coin head" made the new version of "Dream of the Red Chamber" win in the field of public opinion, but it completely failed in audience acceptance. Countless people refuse to watch it just because of the "copper coin head", and even give bad reviews. Li Shaohong's adventure was not worth it.
The audience's perception is very pure, and they do not accept Lin Daiyu, who is topped with a copper coin, and the new version of "Dream of the Red Chamber" has failed.
Before "Dream of the Red Chamber", Li Shaohong filmed the popular "Daming Palace Words" and "Orange Red". If those people also bear the "copper coin head", they will undoubtedly lose.
Li Shaohong's biggest problem is that she is too persistent about "dramatic" performance. The failure of "Dream of the Red Chamber" is the price of her persistence.
Seeing this, someone may say that you didn't say the plot, the characters and the character performances. I don't think it's necessary to say.
Whether it is technology, scenes, costumes, plot restoration and character performance modernization, the new version of "Dream of the Red Chamber" will win the 87th edition of "Dream of the Red Chamber". Insufficient in the soundtrack and styling of the failure. As for the acting and character restoration, it is a matter of opinion.
The actors of "Dream of the Red Chamber" selected by Li Shaohong occupy almost half of the current entertainment industry, which is also a rare success.
Times are different, and even classics are out of place. Classics also need to be constantly challenged, and because of the classics, they can no longer perform because of choking on food. Therefore, the new version of "Dream of the Red Chamber" is no problem.
In summary, the old version is not so perfect, and the new version is not so bad. The main problem is that the "copper coin head" shape spicy eyes to dissuade the audience. The audience does not recognize the shape of the woman in "Dream of the Red Chamber" with a copper coin head, like an attacker, Qingwen and other handsome women, there is no big problem.
If it wasn't "copper money head" at the beginning, maybe the reputation would not be so bad. This is like a modern beauty in a wrap dress, traveling to ancient times, will inevitably be scolded for "bad customs" and refuse to accept.
The shape of the opera stage is only suitable for "Dream of the Red Chamber" on the stage. Li Shaohong insists on dramatizing "Dream of the Red Chamber", which is doomed to not be accepted, and it is her responsibility for failure.
Wen | Junji Yakan Red Chamber
Welcome to click to follow, like the collection, the article is continuously updated daily