In the TV series "Jinggangshan", in order to fully explain Su Xianjun's reactionary nature, such a scene was arranged: Before the autumn harvest uprising, Long Da, the guard of The Mao Committee, was furious because of the disagreement with Su Xianjun, and Su Xianjun was furious.
So is this scene consistent with historical facts? The answer is: not at all. Let's first look at Longda, the historical prototype of Longda is the founding major general Long Kaifu. Long Kaifu, a native of Chaling, Hunan, during the Jinggangshan period, for a long time, Long Kaifu served as a guard for Member Mao, mainly responsible for keeping the books of Committee Member Mao.
However, Long Kaifu did not participate in the Autumn Harvest Uprising in Xianggan province, and he went to Jinggangshan with a battalion party representative Wanxi when the Autumn Harvest Uprising troops went to Jinggang Mountain first. At that time, Long Kaifu was only 19 years old, and because he was bullied by the village bullies, he killed him in anger, and as a result, he was wanted by the reactionaries. At this time, our autumn harvest rebel troops conquered the county seat of Chaling County, and Long Kaifu went to defect to the Red Army. At the recommendation of Wan Xixian, a party representative of the first battalion, Long Kaifu met with Member Mao at Maoping.
Committee member Mao admired Long Kaifu very much and stayed by his side as his own guard. At that time, there was no concept of a guard, and Long Kaifu's main duty was to keep books for Commissar Mao. Reading was an indispensable habit of Life for Commissar Mao, but Long Kaifu was illiterate. Committee member Mao personally wrote the words on a cigarette box paper one by one and taught Long Kaifu to read.
We can see that Long Kaifu joined the revolutionary army when he was in the county seat of Sandai Chaling County, and Su Xianjun at this time had long left the revolutionary ranks. Therefore, it is impossible for the two of them to have any intersection, and there is no way to talk about Su Xianjun's beating of Long Kaifu.
This is one reason, and another reason is that Su Xianjun could not beat and scold the soldiers at all. Su Xianjun's performance during the Autumn Harvest Uprising was very bad, and he first, together with Yu Shandu, blindly obeyed the erroneous policy of the central authorities and wanted to fight Changsha, causing a lot of unnecessary losses to the Autumn Harvest Uprising troops.
When the rebel troops arrived at Luxi in Pingxiang, Su Xianjun mistakenly regarded the enemy as his own man who had retreated from the first regiment and did not make any preparations for engagement, so that the third regiment of the rebel army was hit again, and the loss of soldiers was not to mention, and even the commander-in-chief of the rebel army, Lu Deming, was also sacrificed in this battle. At the time of the Sanwan reorganization, Su Xianjun's proposal to reorganize Mao's army was also contradictory in many ways, and together with Yu Shandu, he resisted the policy of marching into Jinggangshan in various ways, which made the implementation of Mao's plan to reorganize the contingent encounter considerable resistance.
It can be seen from this that Su Xianjun was completely a laggard in the autumn harvest uprising. However, Su Xianjun's dragging his feet during the Autumn Harvest Uprising does not mean that he is a grumpy person in his personal personality, nor does it mean that he is a soldier who does not learn and has no skills. Su Xianjun in real history is actually an intellectual.
Su Xianjun is a graduate of the third phase of the Whampoa Military Academy, and before he was admitted to the Whampoa Military Academy, he had a not low academic qualification and was essentially a cultural person. After the defeat of the Great Revolution, Su Xianjun was entrusted by the organization to go to the border of Xianggan and Gansu to develop peasant armed forces, and the achievements were also relatively remarkable, and he successfully pulled up a team of civilian troops, which was the prototype of the third regiment of the autumn harvest uprising in the future.
When the Nanchang Uprising was launched, Su Xianjun led his troops to Nanchang to prepare for the 20th Army organized into He Long to participate in the uprising, but the itinerary was missed, and the team was stationed in Xiushui. In Xiushui, Su Xianjun encountered another militia armed force, the leader of which was Yu Benmin. Yu Benmin, also an old revolutionary who joined the Party during the Great Revolution, was highly respected in the Party and was known as the Elder Ben.
The remnants of the people held a local armed force in their hands, and on the basis of this armed force, a civilian army was pulled up. After Su Xianjun and Yu Benmin met, the two sides did not reach an agreement on the joint army until they met another person: Yu Shandu.
Yu Shandu's identity at this time was the commander of the First Division of the Jiangxi Provincial Defense Army. The First Division of the Jiangxi Provincial Defense Army is actually a guard regiment. As regimental commander Lu Deming rushed to Wuhan, Yu Shandu led the guard regiment to temporarily perch at Zhu Peide's place and developed its strength under the banner of the Jiangxi Provincial Defense Army.
Su Xianjun and Yu Benmin each have their own qualifications, which is difficult to coordinate, but they are very obedient to Yu Shandu (Yu Shandu is also a Huangpu student, who is su Xianjun's senior, and Yu Shandu and Yu Benmin are both fellow villagers and their own families). In this way, Su Xianjun's department merged with The Yu Benmin Department and joined the Yu Shandu Department together, with Su Xianjun as the regimental commander and Yu Benmin as the deputy division commander.
Not long after, the leader of the autumn harvest uprising, Member Mao, dispatched by the central authorities, rushed to the border of Xianggan and Gansu, and Lu Deming, who had gone to Wuhan to report on his work, also arrived later. Committee member Mao, Lu Deming, Yu Shandu, Yu Benmin, Su Xianjun, all the main figures arrived, and the autumn harvest uprising was launched.
We can see that before the autumn harvest uprising was launched, Su Xianjun's overall performance was still good, and he was able to pull up a team to participate in the uprising himself, and take into account the overall situation and accept the adaptation of Yu Shandu, which still has a lot of positive significance for the smooth launch of the autumn harvest uprising in Xiangganbian.
Of course, Su Xianjun insisted on erroneous ideas everywhere during the autumn harvest uprising, and even left the ranks in the future and betrayed the revolution. After the rebellion against the revolution, Su Xianjun betrayed the party's secrets to the reactionaries, resulting in a very serious damage to the party organization in Hunan Province, and Su Xianjun's insignificant contribution to this is certainly insignificant compared to the huge damage he caused to the revolution.
Although Su Xianjun is a negative figure, we still have to say that his flogging of Mao's guards does not conform to historical facts or to Su Xianjun's character.
Author: Shake The Light.