When Liu Bei was still confused, Sima Hui, the water mirror gentleman, once said: "Wolong and Fengyan can be safe in the world", but in 214, during Liu Bei's attack on Chengdu, Pang Tong died and Guan Yu stayed in Jingzhou, and since Guan Yu's death, Liu Bei launched the Battle of Yiling, which led to the rupture of Wu-Shu relations, and the Shu State also consumed all its vitality in the process of restoring the Central Plains during the Northern Expedition, becoming the first of the three kingdoms to perish. Then, before and after the founding of the Shu State, there were several things that had a greater or less impact on the Shu Han regime, and which of the following things had the greatest impact on the Shu Han regime?
A Liu Chan fainted
Under the influence of the TV series and novel Romance of the Three Kingdoms, Ah Dou's clumsy and cute image jumped out of the paper, especially after the surrender of the Western Jin Dynasty in 263, sima Zhao also tested Liu Chan's surrender. But it was Liu Chan's faint appearance that finally allowed this post-lord to live in the world.
Moreover, in terms of the time of his reign, although Sun Quan was 70 years old when he died, he only reigned for 23 years, and in the Cao Wei regime, Cao Pi and Cao Rui added up to only 30 years, and since Cao Fang and Cao Mao, the Cao Wei regime has already fallen into the hands of the Sima family, especially Cao Fang and Cao Mao are already like puppets, if there is no certain experience and quality of governance, perhaps Liu Chan will not reign for a full 40 years before finally surrendering.
2. Huang Hao's monopoly
In people's impressions, Liu Chan was a faint monarch, and the phrase "A Dou who can't be supported" has also become a true portrayal, especially Huang Hao, who not only prevented Jiang Wei from commanding the Northern Expedition, but also caused the later lord Liu Chanhuan to become a fat state and indulge in the game of promoting weaving all day. In fact, during Zhuge Liang's lifetime, Liu Chan obstructed his status as a lonely minister, and even going out to investigate normally became a problem. After Zhuge Liang's death, it was even more forbidden for the people to build a temple for Zhuge Liang, saying that Huang Hao had exclusive power, after all, Huang Hao was not Wang Zhen, not Wei Zhongxian. Its role is also minimal.
Three Wu Hou died young
In fact, Zhuge Liang is really very authoritarian, especially in the table of the master, "the palace is one, and it is not appropriate to punish Zang or not", which is equivalent to all the systems formulated by Liu Bei when he was alive, even if it is already very unreasonable, Liu Chan must not change a single bit. This made Liu Chan a little "dare to be angry and dare not speak". It really made him feel a little angry in his heart. Since Zhuge Liang's death, Liu Chan has divided Xiang Quan into two, causing Jiang Huan and Fei Yi to restrain each other. Therefore, to a certain extent, Zhuge Liang's death also allowed Liu Chan to realize his political ambitions, but the Shu Han regime was in a quiet corner, and Jiang Wei later cut down the Central Plains, resulting in a great decline in the strength of the Shu Han state.
Four Zhang Fei was assassinated
In 221, after serving as the queen of Hanzhong for two years, Liu Bei saw the abdication of Emperor Xian of Han and ascended the throne in Chengdu, and in 219, Guan Yu had already defeated Maicheng and was in a different place. The one who really felt the grief was Zhang Fei, although Zhao Yun's suggestion to persuade Liu Bei to cut down Wei first was the right proposition, but in terms of personal feelings, Zhang Fei and Guan Yu could be described as "Enruo brothers". Therefore, they will be anxious to let their subordinates rush to create 100,000 white clothes and white armor. However, Fan Jiang and Zhang Da were desperate to take risks because they could not afford the tight deadline. And Zhang Fei's death also made the Shu Han regime wither the stars. Although there was still Zhao Yun Wei Yan and even Guan Xing and Zhang Bao behind. But there really is some no one available.
Five Horse Moddon Street Kiosks
Zhuge Liang's Northern Expedition to the Central Plains, the Battle of Jieting is also crucial. But this involves a question of employing people, in fact, Liu Bei has already said that Ma Mo is useless, but Zhuge Liang did not listen. This also caused a disagreement between Ma Mo and his deputy general Wang Ping in the Battle of Jieting. However, Ma Mo committed another military taboo, which led to the fiasco of the street kiosk. But this was not crucial to the unification of the Shu and Han Dynasties.
5. The defeat of Liu Beiyiling
The Battle of Yiling was a battle in which the Wu-Shu alliance was completely broken, and it was also a battle for Lu Xun's fame. In this battle, Liu Bei's excuse was to avenge Guan Yu, but Guan Yu had already been killed and martyred as early as 219, and the reason was still a bit of a taste of Li Wei to Sun Quan, and the fiasco of the Battle of Yiling also caused the Shu Han regime to be seriously injured. If it were not for Deng Zhi's envoy to the State of Wu, the Shu Han regime might have existed for only 3-5 years before it would have perished. And Fazheng's death did not lead to a fiasco in the Battle of Yiling.
VI Death of Pang Tong
In fact, as far as military wisdom and strategy are concerned, Pang Tong is not under Zhuge Liang, especially in Liu Bei's campaign to march into Chengdu, Pang Tong can be said to have made great achievements. If Pang Tong had not died in Luofengpo, it would not have been Guan Yu who guarded Jingzhou, nor would there have been the later Lü Meng baiyi crossing the river, and Pang Tong's death had indeed disrupted the pace of the unification of the Shu state.
Seven Guan Yu lost Jingzhou
In fact, the author feels that Guan Yu's loss of Jingzhou is the one who has the greatest impact on the Shu Han regime, and it should be known that capturing the forbidden and beheading Pound, the flooding of the Seventh Army's Wei Zhen Huaxia did allow Guan Yu to reach a height in his military history, but for the arrogance of his subordinates, it also led to a very bad relationship between Guan Yu and the insiders of the Shu State, especially when Lü Meng sneaked into Jingzhou, Mi Fang, as Liu Bei's wife's uncle, not only saw death and could not be saved, but lü Meng opened the door of Jingzhou. At the same time, Liu Feng, as Liu Bei's son, also watched with Meng Da on the wall of Shangyong, resulting in the loss of Jingzhou and guan Yu's head, and from then on, Zhuge Liang's so-called "Longzhong Pair" only became a bubble. Guan Yu said that jingzhou was careless, but in fact it was due to personality.
Eight Zhang Fei lost Xuzhou
In fact, Zhang Feidi Xuzhou was only Liu Bei once again became a homeless person with no place to live, and at that time he was still in the entrepreneurial stage and did not have a clear direction. Losing Xuzhou was only that Zhang Fei was still very young and reckless at that time. The great cause of unification of the Shu Han Dynasty did not have very serious consequences.
The above is the author's analysis, what do you think?