I carefully read Bi Feiyu's lecture at Peking University, "'Walking' and 'Walking':Logic and Counter-Logic Within the Novel.". Bi Feiyu is a writer I respect very much, and he is a writer in Nanjing. I collected this manuscript, read it carefully, and admired the writer's insight.
Among them, the relationship between Feng Jie and Ke Qing was carefully analyzed, the details of the eleventh visit to Feng Jie were analyzed, and Cao Xueqin's superb techniques and outstanding talents were praised in the name of "anti-logic". In particular, it is mentioned that Feng Jie's walking like this is illogical:
Wang Xifeng left Qin Keqing, she was "walking" in this way, "one step to appreciate". Literally, she was in a good mood and was comfortable, and there was no one else in her heart, including Qin Keqing. The second time, Wang Xifeng left Jia Rui, and she "walked" like this, "Fang moved to come". She was still in a good mood, and there was no one else in her heart, including Jarry. The third time, "the step upstairs", this time, is there anyone in Sister Feng's heart?
Looking back and carefully reading several reviews related to "Dream of the Red Chamber", I found that the details were not accurate. For example, the seventh time, Wang Xifeng was invited to Ning Province and brought Baoyu with him, and here You, Qin and Jia Rong, as well as the "concubines of all the concubines", took it together. When You Shi saw Xi Feng, he would first laugh and taunt, which was not unreasonable.
Li Feng was widowed, and he saw that Xi Feng was still talking about it. It is reasonable for the concubines to laugh at each other when they meet. Wang Xifeng wanted to see Qin Zhong, and did not hesitate to explode and scold Jia Rong, one uncle and aunt scolded his nephew, "Dream of the Red Chamber" abounded; second, Feng Jie always exploded foul language and had no scruples; third, there was You's presence, scolding Jia Rong for having a mother, Xi Feng was originally directed at You's, and Qin's would not feel uncomfortable.
Also, for the eleventh time, Ning Fu made a birthday for Jia Jing. Early in the morning, Jia Rong was sent by her father to the Taoist Temple to give her grandfather a birthday gift. Jia Lian and Jia Qiang arrived at Ning Province first. When Lady Xing, Lady Wang, Wang Xifeng, and Jia Baoyu arrived, Jia Zhen and You Shi joined in and "personally offered tea." Sister Feng explained why Jia Mu "refused to appreciate her face", and Madame Wang inquired about Qin Keqing's condition.
At this time, Jia Yu, Jia Zheng and others came over, and Jia Zhen went out to pick them up. After that, Jia Rong returned, first replied to Jia Zhen, and then came to see You Shi and Xing, Lady Wang Er, as well as Sister Feng and Bao Yu. Jia Rong went out to Jia Zhen's place again to serve the officials and guests for dinner.
At this time, Sister Feng called Jia Rong to inquire about Qin's condition, and Jia Rong invited Sister Feng to take time to visit. You Shi waited for the guests to eat in the upper room, and Jia Rong came to invite the guests to the Huifang Garden to enjoy the play.
At this time, Sister Feng took a leave of absence to visit Qin Keqing.
Jia Rong accompanied Feng Jie, Bao Yu to Tianxiang Lou, Jia Rong called the tea offering, saying that he had not yet used tea in the upper room, it was nothing more than a false word, he did not have the kung fu to have been secretly staring at Feng Jie, he did not have the heart at all, let alone to Feng Jie.
After that, Feng Jie sent Jia Rong and Bao Yu away, because Bao Yu was too unbearable, entered the Tianxiang Building, looked at the couplets in Ke Qing's room, and thought of sleepwalking too illusory. Listening to Ke Qing say that it was not enough to survive this winter, the tears came down.
All of this is logical, there is no counter-logic.
Sister Feng came out of the Tianxiang Building, and Cao Xueqin suddenly wrote about the scenery in the garden. Feng Jie's model came, all the way to the scenery, it seems that some "autumn" wind is proud. It seems like "hysteria", but in fact it has to be so.
Previously, on the same day, Wang Xifeng had already cried once. You Shi replied to Madame Wang's inquiry and mentioned the goodness of Feng Jie and Qin Shi:
Sister Feng listened, her eyes were red for half a day, and half a day fang said: "It is really 'the sky has unpredictable storms, and people have bad luck'." At this age, if it is because of this illness, what fun is it for people to be alive! ”
Sister Feng asked Jia Rong again, and Jia Rong frowned and said:
"Not good! The sister-in-law came back and looked at it. ”
At this time, Feng Jie had a clear understanding of Ke Qing's illness. When she arrived at the Tianxiang Building and entered Qin's living room, she did not give Qin a chance to get up. Bao Yu couldn't help but cry, Feng Jie persuaded, and enlightened Ke Qing, cheered up, optimistic treatment, which is also Feng Jie's own efforts to change her mentality. She can't be immersed in a low mood, she has to "walk" out of the valley floor.
At this time, the scenery in the garden echoes Feng Jie's efforts to get out of the trough and improve her emotions:
Yellow flowers are all over the ground, and white willows are sloped. The small bridge leads to the Creek of Ruoye, and the winding path leads to the rooftop road. The clear streams in the stones are turbulent, the hedges are fragrant, the red leaves on the heads of the trees are turned over, and the forest is picturesque. The west wind is tight, and the warblers cry at the beginning; the warm sun is warm, and the language is added. Looking to the southeast, several pavilions along the mountain are built; looking at the northwest, there are three waterfront xuan. Sheng reeds, don't have a sense of humor; Luo Qi wears through the forest, adding to the rhyme.
Sister Feng must return to the festive atmosphere of her birthday, and she must perform the duties of a daughter and a housekeeper, serving Xing and Lady Wang.
At this time, the obscene embryo Jarry appeared. Sister Feng was surprised and pretended to be circling, and Cao Xueqin also repeatedly emphasized Sister Feng's "false intentions". Sister Feng is "walking" out of her sadness, do you have the heart to flirt with such a lewd man? So he opened his mouth and lifted Jia Lian out:
"I don't think your brother often mentions you..."
Jia Rui did not understand the style, insisted on going his own way, provoking Feng Jie to cross his heart, and there was only one way to die. There is nothing counter-illogical about it either. Bi Feiyu's mistake was that feng jie was flirting with Jia Rui:
"Just visited a dying patient and came back to flirt, which is illogical."
Sister Feng stepped upstairs, at this time she must come out of the low mood, she must come out of the unhappiness of dealing with the lewd man. That's the logic.
afterwards:
Sister Feng stood up and looked downstairs and said, "Where are the masters?" A mother-in-law next to him said, "The masters just went to Ning Xi Xuan and took the ten times there to eat wine." Sister Feng said, "It's not cheap here, and I don't know what to do behind my back!" Yu Shi smiled, "There are all serious people like you there." ”
The grandfathers asked here are a bunch of men who were watching the drama downstairs, among these grandfathers, there can be Jia Rong, and there should be Jia Lian. Jia Lian is Feng Jie's husband, and Jia Lian has never missed even one chance to find flowers and ask Liu or even prostitute the boy's pet! Sister Feng was also known for her jealousy, and she regarded Ping'er as dead, and later forced Sister You to die. The "grandfathers" here can even be understood as referring specifically to Jia Lian. There are lipid batches as evidence:
"I prefer sour vinegar."
You's response was even more problematic, and she also knew Jia Zhen and Jia Rong well enough to know that they couldn't do anything good. But YouShi was not as strong as Feng Jie and chose to be patient. What You Shi said was also a true matter, and only Feng Jie's visit to Ke Qing was a serious thing, and at this time, only Feng Jie was a serious person who did a serious thing.
By the thirteenth time, Qin Keqing died. As I said earlier, Sister Feng was mentally prepared for Ke Qing's death. Ke Qing was dying, and Tuo Dream gave feng jie. Sister Feng woke up, orthogonal four more, the building has hit four cloud boards, people reported that the grandmother of the East House Rong is gone, Sister Feng sent a moment of Lennon, after a bit of reminiscence, before getting dressed and getting up, went to Madame Wang.
At this time, Sister Feng was worried about what to do, and how to deal with it from the Rong Family. It was not what Bi Feiyu said, but when there was a shortage of "office directors" in Ning Province, Wang Xifeng appeared. As for the reactions and styles of Jia Zhen, You Shi, and Jia Rong, as well as the reactions and styles of Bao Yu, they are also reasonable, and there is no counter-logic.
I do appreciate Bi Feiyu's point of view, Feng Jie has two sides to Ke Qing, one side is facing each other, and the other side is facing back. From ancient times to the present, have the girlfriends not been like this? Even so, Sister Feng is still true to Keqing, still affectionate. The subtlety of human nature and the entanglement of relationships are real and credible, and only then are they logical.