The child went to the exhibition hall during the holiday and unintentionally broke the porcelain vase worth 120,000 yuan, which was originally thought to be inextricably linked, but the museum was full of patterns, saying that it was not intentional and could be exempted. The child realized the mistake, and the museum said that it would be exempt from compensation, which can be said to be a happy thing, but many netizens were dissatisfied and demanded compensation, why is this?
On May 2, the May Day holiday continued, and last year's popular Zibo once again ushered in a large number of tourists, in addition to eating barbecue and tasting Shandong cuisine, Zibo's ceramics and glaze are also a major feature. In fact, many people don't know that Zibo's ceramics are very level in the country, which can be described as top works of art, and even decorative tiles, the origin of many brands is in Zibo, and the price is quite cheap, which is almost known to locals.
Therefore, after coming to Zibo, many people will not only enjoy the food, but also go to many exhibition halls to appreciate the glass and porcelain. However, in the Culture and Art Museum of Zibo National Art Center, an accident happened. A child accidentally broke a ceramic vase with a price tag of 116,000 yuan, a price of nearly 120,000 yuan, and he is not sure whether it is a master's work. Of course, 120,000 is not the highest, and there are nearly 200,000 worth of porcelain.
With the sound of broken ceramics, many tourists at the scene also hurried over, and some also took out their mobile phones to shoot, among them, a photographer also revealed the inside story at the time, the child who broke the porcelain was only three or four years old, when the porcelain was broken, it seemed that he was also startled, and seemed to realize that he was in trouble, so he cried loudly, I have to say, such a scene, it is really worrying.
Subsequently, according to the description of the person in charge of the venue, we learned that it was 6 adults who brought 3 children to play, one of the smaller children accidentally knocked down the vase when they were close to the porcelain, and the child was very scared.
I have to say that this wave of pattern in Zibo is really too big, and it is generally really impossible to do it, and after the staff encounters this kind of thing, they are not angry at the first time, nor do they blame the parents and children, let alone ask for compensation, but first see if the child is scratched. Originally, this matter should have become a beautiful talk, but after the incident, it also caused a lot of discussions, and netizens expressed their opinions one after another, and also raised 3 questions.
1. Is broken porcelain antique?
At the beginning, many netizens thought that this was a museum of ceramics and thought it was an antique, so many netizens thought that what was placed outside and without protection might be a fake. But in fact, according to insiders, the pavilion is not a museum, but a porcelain hall next to it, which belongs to a commercial place, and the porcelain is a modern work. In fact, this is the pavilion of the most well-known porcelain brand in Zibo and even in the country, although it cannot be said to be an antique, but it is indeed a work of art.
Many people may think that it is not worth it, let alone 120,000 yuan, thinking that this is the product of modern ordinary porcelain, and taking it out to "fool people", because on weekdays, we do not have many opportunities to contact top ceramics, and they encounter some modern and general handicrafts, so the perception of netizens is that if it is a ceramic antique, it may be valuable, but the modern technology of ceramics is not worth much, this idea is obviously wrong.
In fact, the locals know that the ceramics are not ordinary ceramics, which belong to the national porcelain, representing the highest level of our ceramics, but also the supplies of the state banquet, the quality of the ceramics, not the general ceramics can be compared, have seen the real thing or bought as a gift to give people know, the price itself is not expensive, the workmanship is visible to the naked eye There is a clear difference, there is a sense of luxury. And generally put in the exhibition hall, not everyone can usually buy, basically from the hands of masters, and because of the difficulty, low yield, so very rare, indeed worth the price, many netizens may not understand the value, but in fact, generally the highest level of state banquet or national gift, can be seen, this is a cultural symbol.
Therefore, don't speculate excessively, human nature is not all dark, don't think that this thing is worthless, so the pavilion is exempt, in fact, it is because of the large pattern of the pavilion, it is exempted, we should give such a pavilion, such a business to praise, worthy of admiration.
2. Are the porcelain not being protected?
Because the exhibition hall is a commercial exhibition hall, not a museum, so in terms of protection measures, it is not like a museum, after all, it is a commercial exhibition hall, and everyone should not ask for it to be like a museum. And there are tips on how to protect it, and there are staff on site to take care of it. This time something like this happened, the relevant staff also made it clear that the child was not intentional, and as a member of the exhibition hall, he also had a certain responsibility, because there were many people, so he was not well taken care of, so he had taken the initiative to take part of the responsibility, so he was exempted. Of course, the exhibition hall does not carry out perfect safety protection for fragile items, although there are mistakes, parents in public places, for the disadvantage of children's care, naturally it is also wrong, so, this matter, even if the exhibition hall is controversial protection measures, but children and parents, still have to bear the main responsibility.
3. Is the deductible reasonable?
For whether there should be a waiver, in fact, everyone has discussed a lot, some people think that this is a hype, that it is deliberate by the pavilion, I have to say, human nature is really elusive, if people are this kind of thinking, it is really sad. And if the city of Zibo, if it is really as netizens think, then it is impossible to become popular, the simplicity of Zibo people does not need to be doubted, otherwise it is impossible to be recognized by everyone, and this kind of thing, there is really no need to hype, because this brand itself is a high-end brand, there is no need to lower its price, to engage in this kind of "Internet celebrity, traffic" thing, familiar with this brand, in fact, will not have such an idea.
In response to this matter, in fact, many lawyers also spoke out, expressed their views, and made it clear that the parties who did not intend to break the cultural relics should bear the corresponding civil liability, but now it has been clearly stated that the place where the incident occurred is not a museum, but a commercial place, and porcelain is also modern art, but even so, if something is broken, and there is an obvious price and prompt, it must also be liable for compensation.
And many media also believe that if the way to avoid compensation is to avoid the determination of responsibility, it is actually not a good thing for tourists, because in this way, tourists will have a fluke mentality, and even fail to recognize their mistakes, so that in the future, whether it is a scenic spot or an exhibition hall, the same thing may occur one after another. To put it bluntly, you can't believe in people's consciousness, for many things, it is best to do it in accordance with the rules and laws, otherwise it is easy to let some unconscious people have no constraints. In fact, not only the media thinks so, but many netizens also think so, everyone thinks that if the compensation is waived, the other party will not realize their mistakes, and they will not reflect on it, because they did not accept the punishment and take responsibility, so they will do such things in the future, excessive tolerance, in fact, they are harming the other party.
In this regard, some netizens said:
Some netizens also said:
Some netizens said:
In fact, this is a solution, and this kind of program not only shows the local kindness, but also has to be forgiving and forgiving, giving people a chance, logically speaking, this way is okay, and it does not violate the law, after all, the parties say that there is no need to compensate, and it does not involve legal matters, which is a personal choice.
Of course, the worries of netizens are understandable, but here, we still have to consider a problem, the reason why this matter is exempted from compensation is special, after all, the child who broke the porcelain is small, if the parents of the child are responsible, there may be an unbearable situation, and the local exhibition hall pattern in Zibo is also very large, but you must know that there are so many cities in the country, and there is only one Zibo, this matter is just an example。
So it doesn't affect everyone's perception and doesn't break any rules. If because of this incident, parents and children have not realized their own problems, so they continue to have a fluke mentality, then in the future, they may encounter the same problems in other cities, and at that time, there will be no deductible. Therefore, we don't need to worry, everything is reasonable, legal and compliant, it will not cause any bad impact, but show the empathy between people, the heart to the heart, the warm and kind side.
What are your thoughts on this?