【Lao Jia Jet Air】
Text‖ Jia Fengxiang Picture‖ Internet
[Guan Yu reads "Spring and Autumn" at night]
Cao Cao asked Guan Yu and the two imperial sisters-in-law to live in a room, only gave a candle, Guan Yu split it in half, and read "Spring and Autumn" at night. This plot is not in "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" and "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", it is a legend.
The spread of this story began in the Yuan Dynasty, and then the Spring and Autumn Tower was built accordingly. There are two possibilities: one is that someone created this story during the Yuan Dynasty, and the other is that this story is true, has been circulating among the people, and by the Yuan Dynasty, someone had sorted it out and made it public.
【Guan Yu writes and paints bamboo poems】
"Romance of the Three Kingdoms" and "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" are not there, they are legends.
[Guan Yu beheaded Yan Liang, Wen Chou]
The twenty-fifth and twenty-sixth chapters of "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" write that Guan Gong beheaded Yan Liang and wrote ugly.
Beheading Yan Liang is recorded in the "Chronicles of the Three Kingdoms". However, it was a spear or spear, not the Green Dragon Glaive. At that time, there was no such weapon as a broadsword. (Want to see what Lao Jia is waiting for?Welcome to click the following link to enjoy: 1. Hey, these strange village names in Xuchang have a lot of origins; 2. Why do lions guard the gate? Listen to the story of Yuzhou!)
"Romance of the Three Kingdoms" says that "stabbing the face is good under the horse", not saying "cutting the face is good under the horse".
Wen Chou was killed in the Battle of Guandu, who killed it, there is no clear record in the history books.
【Baling Robe Picking】
"Romance of the Three Kingdoms" was not written, and "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" was written in the twenty-seventh chapter.
Skeptical Proposals:
The question of the age of the construction of the Xuchang Baling Bridge. In 1991, the excavation and cleaning of the original bridge site found that the bridge foundation was a member of the Yuan Dynasty, and the upper part was a building of the Ming and Qing dynasties. If the construction time is the Yuan Dynasty, then how could Guan Yu of the Three Kingdoms pick a robe on the bridge? There is Bashui in the east of Xi'an, and there is the mausoleum of Emperor Jing of the Han Dynasty next to it, which is called Baling, so the bridge on the river is called Baling Bridge.
Xuchang has neither Bashui nor Baling, so how can it be called Baling Bridge? This is a story created by a storyteller in the Yuan Dynasty. He mistakenly assigned Guan Yu's resignation to Chang'an. When Luo Guanzhong wrote "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", he used this story. Change Chang'an to Xudu. So the Bali Bridge in Xuchang became the Baling Bridge.
Answer in the affirmative:
The flood silted up, and the bridges of the Han Dynasty or earlier than the Han Dynasty were deeper. It is impossible for this folk artist to make up a story out of thin air, it should have been a folklore before. Folklore is not necessarily fake.
Why did this artist make up the location of the story to Chang'an? It should be: Folk legend Guan Yu picked up the robe at the Bali Bridge in Xuchang, this artist didn't know where the Bali Bridge was, and there was a Baling Bridge in the east of Chang'an, so he used homophony. Chang'an was originally the capital of the Han Dynasty, and he lacked historical knowledge and mistakenly believed that Guan Yu was starting from Chang'an.
Later, when Luo Guanzhong wrote "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", he changed Chang'an to Xudu. Luo Guanzhong only said the bridge, not the name of the bridge. But the Baling Bridge that the artist said has spread, so everyone homonyms the Bali Bridge on the Qingni River as Baling Bridge.
【Pass five levels and kill six generals】
"Romance of the Three Kingdoms" was not written, but the twenty-seventh chapter of "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" was written.
Skeptical Proposals:
Liu Bei was at Yuan Shao in Zhuozhou. Zhuozhou is located in the north of the eastern part of Xuchang. Guan Yu went to find Liu Bei, he should go northeast. Lao Luo asked Guan Yu to walk a few hundred miles west to Luoyang, and then turn a hundred and forty degrees to go east, which was too unreasonable. The tiger knows how to walk in a straight line, Guan Yu's IQ is not as good as that of the tiger? That artist lacks historical knowledge, Luo Guanzhong lacks geographical knowledge, and this story has made up loopholes, indicating that it is fake.
Answer in the affirmative:
To make up a story based on legends, of course, it is necessary to enrich some content. It is the responsibility of the author that the story is not compiled, but the original material cannot be denied on this basis. First, Guan Yu originally got the wrong news, thinking that Liu Bei was heading west of Luoyang, and only got accurate information after arriving in Luoyang. Second, in order to get rid of Cao Cao's pursuit, Guan Yu deliberately made a big detour. 3. It is more convenient to cross the river there, and the danger is small.
Skeptical Proposals:
From Xuchang to Luoyang, you must pass through Dengfeng eighteen plates. The generals guarding the pass only need to send three soldiers to pile stones on the hillside, and when the time comes, Guan Yu and the two imperial sisters-in-law will be turned into meat cakes. Therefore, it is impossible for Guan Yu to pass through here.
Answer in the affirmative:
How could it be impossible? The generals guarding the pass had special respect for Guan Yu and took the risk to let him go. Or the generals guarding the customs are irresponsible and don't know the news of Guan Yu's clearance.
Skeptical Proposals:
Huazhou in the Five Passes did not have this place name during the Three Kingdoms, which shows that this story was created later.
Answer in the affirmative:
This place name was made up by the artist when he created it later, but it cannot be used as a basis to negate the original material.
【Huarong Daoyi Interpretation of Cao Cao】
Seen in the fiftieth chapter of "Romance of the Three Kingdoms". In "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", it is said that Liu Bei went to intercept, but it was too late.
【Single Knife Meeting】
The Chronicles of the Three Kingdoms states:
Lu Su persuaded Sun Quan, considering the overall situation of Lian Liu to resist Cao, and lent Jingzhou to Liu Bei, who had no place to live. Later Sun Quan demanded restitution, appointed the local governors of Changsha, Lingling, and Guiyang counties, and went to take over, while Guan Yu expelled him.
Sun Quan was furious and sent Lü Meng to lead 20,000 horses to seize the three counties. Liu Bei personally rushed to the public security from Chengdu and ordered Guan Yu to lead the troops to seize it. Sun Quan also personally went to Lukou to take up the town, and sent Lu Su, who was originally stationed in Lukou, to lead 10,000 troops to Tun Yiyang to confront Guan Yu.
Lu Su didn't want to see each other, so he invited Guan Yu to meet and talk, and the soldiers on both sides were a hundred steps away, and the general went to the meeting alone. As a result of this negotiation and because Cao Cao was about to capture Hanzhong, Liu Bei proposed that the two sides divide Jingzhou with Xiangshui as the boundary.
Guan Hanqing's script "King Guan Goes to the Single Sword Meeting Alone" is written like this:
In order to please Jingzhou, Lu Su designed to invite Guan Gong to the meeting and ask for Jingzhou as a gift. If they don't return it, they will detain all the warships on the river, and not let Guan Gong cross the river to go back, so that Guan Gong will return them after knowing the plan. If you don't return it, hide the armor, when you are drunk, hit the golden bell as the number, ambush the soldiers, capture Guan Gong, and return Jingzhou to release Guan Gong, otherwise take advantage of Jingzhou to attack without a master.
Guan Yu went to the meeting alone, and at the banquet, Lu Su asked for Jingzhou, Guan Yu said: "This is the foundation of my Han family, what does Sun Quan of Eastern Wu have to do with my Liu family?"
Guan Yu found the ambush and said, "If there is an ambush, one sword will swing in two!" Lu Su was intimidated by Guan Yu's majesty, and did not dare to start, so he had to bid farewell to Guan Yu.
The sixty-sixth chapter of "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" has been further developed.
Guan Yu hinted that Zhou Cang asked Guan Ping to respond. Guan Gong held a knife in his right hand, and grabbed Lu Su's hand with his left hand and pulled it to the river. Lu Meng and Gan Ning each led their headquarters to come out, but when they saw Yun Chang holding a big knife and holding Lu Su in person, they were afraid that Su would be injured, so they didn't dare to move.
Why was Guan Hanqing's script written like this? The Song and Yuan dynasties had sharp national contradictions, and this was because the Shu Han dynasty was regarded as the symbol of the Han national regime, and the Shu and Han characters were admired from the angle of resisting foreign aggression, and the national integrity was praised in a tortuous way. From this point of view, the script and the novel are positive.
【Flooded Seventh Army】
The Chronicles of the Three Kingdoms states:
Yu led the crowd to attack Cao Ren and Yu Fan. Cao Gong was sent to Ban Zhuren. In autumn, it rained, the Han water overflowed, and the forbidden place supervised the seven armies. It was forbidden to descend the feather, and the feather beheaded the general Pound. Liang, Jia, Lu Hun group thieves or remote by the feather seal, for the party, feather power shocked China. Cao Gong discussed the relocation of Xu to avoid his sharpness.
"Romance of the Three Kingdoms" was written seventy-four times, and it was played.
【Bone scraping to cure poison】
"Romance of the Three Kingdoms" records:
Yu taste for the flow of arrows, through its left arm, after the wound healed, every rain, the bone often pain, the doctor said: "The arrow is poisonous, poison into the bone, when the arm is broken to make a wound, scrape the bone to toxin, and then this affliction is to remove the ear." Yu then stretched out his arm and ordered the doctor to split it. Shi Yushi invited the generals to eat and drink, and the blood in the arms flowed away, surging in the plate, and Yu cut the wine, and laughed freely.
In the seventy-fifth chapter of "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", it is written that the doctor is Hua Tuo, but it is not, Hua Tuo is dead at that time.
【Death of Guan Gong】
"Romance of the Three Kingdoms: The Biography of Lü Meng" records:
Meng to seek the sun, as far as its elite soldiers in the boat, so that the white clothes sway, as a businessman clothes, day and night, to the feather placed by the riverside waiting, all the restraints, is the feather does not know.
"Romance of the Three Kingdoms: The Biography of Guan Yu" records:
"The right to send the envoy to the son Suo Yu girl, Yu scolded and insulted his envoy, not allowed to marry, and the right was furious. ”
"Nanjun Taishou Elfang is in Jiangling, and the general Shirentun Public Security is suspicious of Yu and himself. ”
"The power of yin tempts Fang and benevolence, and Fang and benevolence make people welcome power. ”
"The right has been based on Jiangling, and the wives of the Yu soldiers have been captured, and the Yu army has dispersed. The right to send the feather back, cut the feather and the son to be depressed. Sun Quan proposed, Guan Gong refused to marry in the seventy-third chapter of "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", and the other content is in the seventy-fifth to seventy-seventh chapters of "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", but it is written more specifically.
In the seventy-seventh chapter of "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", Yuquan Mountain appeared and Cao Cao carved the body of agarwood to bury Guan Yu, but "Three Kingdoms" did not write.
Jia Fengxiang was the first in the province in the Chinese language and literature major for graduation from colleges and universities in Henan Province, graduated from Central China Normal University, and is now a literature teacher at Xuchang Veteran Cadre University. He has published works or won awards at the national and provincial levels in the fields of novels, essays, dramas, film and television, folk arts, poetry, literary criticism, historical research, calligraphy, music, photography, speeches, and performances. He has published more than 30 books. He is a member of the Chinese Dramatists Association, a member of the Chinese Essayists Association, a member of the Chinese Hard Pen Calligraphy Association, a member of the Henan Writers Association, and a member of the Henan Quyi Artists Association. It is listed in the "Dictionary of Contemporary Chinese Writers and Artists". The blog was rated as one of the top ten emerging talents in the world by Sina headquarters.
1. This article is authorized by the author to be published, and the author is responsible for the author's own responsibility. The views of the authors of this article do not necessarily reflect the position of this headline.
2. The text and pictures have nothing to do with each other. The pictures in the article are from the Internet, and the copyright belongs to the original photographer or the original producer, and I would like to express my sincere thanks. If there is any infringement of the pictures used in this article, please notify the "hometown Xuchang" Toutiao number to delete it immediately.
3. "Hometown Xuchang" copyright works, please send an email to [email protected] for reprinting or submission.
Love Xuchang's hometown, look at "hometown Xuchang". Hometown Xuchang, feelings, temperature, taste!
This article was originally written by the author of Toutiao. Unauthorized reproduction is not permitted.