Preface
In 2011, at the door of a court in Henan Province, Zhu Yun, who looked depressed, eagerly questioned his defense lawyer.
"It's obvious that the expert deceived us, why can't we win the lawsuit?" the lawyer sighed and shook his head.
"We have no direct evidence in our hands to confirm that this matter is related to him, and the court's decision that we lost the case is reasonable and legal!" Seeing that Zhu Yun could not hide his indignation, he suggested that he continue to collect evidence.
What happened to Zhu Yun? He couldn't even go to the court to appeal? The matter had to start two years ago.
The ancestral famous painting is actually a fake?
In 2009, Henan TV launched a free treasure appreciation program, which attracted wide attention from audiences across the country, and local farmer Zhu Yun became the most loyal viewer of this program, staying in front of the TV on time every week to watch expert treasure appreciation.
Relatives and friends laughed at his poor peasant family was interested in cultural relics, Zhu Yun smiled and said nothing, and quietly took out an ancient painting handed down from the bottom of the box at night, opened it gently, and watched it carefully.
After watching the lucky audience on the stage hold their own treasures and are identified as genuine by cultural relics experts, those cultural relics are immediately worth a hundred times, and there are countless collectors who collect them with hundreds of thousands or millions of dollars, and they immediately get rich.
I don't know if this ancient painting is genuine, with a nervous mood, Zhu Yun took the baby to the program group to sign up for the treasure, and when he arrived at the program group, he knew that he could not be on the show if he didn't have a baby, and he needed to see if the baby was worth going on stage.
The person who received Zhu Yun was a middle-aged man with a polite manner, and he was an expert who was rich in learning and five cars. After stammering a few words, he opened his collection of paintings and asked experts to taste them.
The expert's name is Liu Yan, when he saw the painting in front of him, he was really stunned for a moment, this painting has been quite old, the silk painting has been yellowed, the majestic towering cypress is painted, the posture is stretched, the brushwork is smart, and the blank space is covered with many seals.
Zhu Yun saw that the expert was silent and thoughtful when he looked at his Tibetan paintings, and after a while, Liu Yan sighed regretfully and said: "This painting is indeed old, but it is still a fake!"
Zhu Yun's brain boomed, looking at his beloved Tibetan paintings, he was stunned and at a loss. Liu Yan explained to Zhu Yun that this painting was the original of a fake, and the point was that there was a problem with the content of one of the seals, and it was impossible for the genuine seal to appear.
Zhu Yun didn't understand Liu Yan's statement, but he just felt that the expert's reasoned explanation must be reasonable, seeing that his Tibetan paintings could not be appraised on stage, he could only regretfully put away the Tibetan paintings and prepare to leave, who knew that Liu Yan stopped him again.
"Don't be too disappointed, I have a good suggestion, would you like to consider it?"
"Kind experts" make deals
After listening to the expert's words, Zhu Yun stopped, and when Expert Liu saw that there was no one in the reception room, he said frankly, "Originally, it was inconvenient for me to say this during the show, and our participation in this matter will make others misunderstand that I have no intentions!"
"But you are a real person at a glance, I will make an exception and say a few words, although your painting is not a genuine work of the Qianlong period, but it is also some years, it should be worth some money, I ask my friends around me, if there is a considerable price, can I help you sell it?"
Zhu Yun saw that the expert looked sincere and thought about himself wholeheartedly, and was very grateful in his heart, so he hurriedly agreed, and the two exchanged contact information.
Two days later, he contacted Zhu Yun to bring a wealthy businessman to see the painting. This wealthy businessman was well-dressed and talked cheerfully, and after a few words, he explained his intention that he wanted to hang an ancient painting in the hall of his villa.
The genuine product is millions at every turn, in case it is coveted and can't be committed, just this kind of good is still a fake for many years, and it doesn't cost much if it is fake, Zhu Yun listened to it reasonably, but trusted a few points.
Zhu Yun watched the two of them go back and forth and cut prices, he couldn't interject at all, and he couldn't help but be very grateful to Expert Liu in his heart. The price of the collection was 170,000 yuan, and the rich businessman hesitated several times, but under the persuasion of Expert Liu, he still made a deal.
After this negotiation, Zhu Yun was very grateful to Expert Liu, and after the painting money was received, he gave Expert Liu a generous gift and thanked him a thousand times. Expert Liu was also very polite to Zhu Yun and specially invited him to have a meal, and the two said goodbye.
Zhu Yun returned home with the money and told his wife about the show, the husband and wife regretted it for a while, and then looked at the fakes and exchanged 170,000 yuan, which is not less, and felt very comforted in my heart, and I was really grateful to Expert Liu for his righteousness.
Who knew that in just two years, everything had changed!
Fakes become genuine
In 2011, in addition to farming, Zhu Yun did some odd jobs in his spare time, and he didn't watch much of the treasure appreciation shows he liked to watch. On this day, he was busy, and suddenly received a call from his wife, "Boss, you find a TV to watch, cultural relics auction, you must watch it!"
is so anxious, it is the first time since he got married, Zhu Yun became curious, found the TV broadcast by the station, flipped through the program, and suddenly found that a station was broadcasting the auction of cultural relics, and the ancient paintings being auctioned were very familiar.
Zhu Yun couldn't wait to lie on the TV, and looked at it carefully for a long time, it was really the ancestral painting of his family, and the seal that Expert Liu swore that should not appear on this painting was stamped on that painting, exactly the same.
After fierce bidding, this painting was auctioned at a sky-high price of 87.36 million yuan, and Zhu Yun, who saw the final result, was weak and his legs were weak. Only then did he figure out the truth of the facts, the so-called expert Liu, united with others to pit himself.
said that the painting was a fake, but in fact this painting was only identified by him alone, and he had no way to tell whether it was true or false. And he took that rich businessman accomplice and sold the painting for a mere 170,000 yuan, and he was grateful to Dade.
Zhu Yun came home in a daze and lay down, the peerless treasure of his own family was actually deceived by such a liar dressed in the skin of an expert. When the wife saw her husband so angry, she couldn't swallow it.
He tried to contact the expert Liu, but found that the phone number was no longer available. In desperation, he found a lawyer and wanted to go through legal procedures to protect his rights and interests.
After some investigation, the lawyer made another surprising discovery.
"What? Two experts named Liu Yan?" Zhu Yun was stunned, and the lawyer nodded helplessly, "Yes, one is in Beijing and the other is in Henan, the basic information is almost the same, which one are we looking for?" Zhu Yun was even more convinced that this expert had a ghost.
Although the lawyer advised Zhu Yun that the evidence found so far was insufficient, Zhu Yun insisted on appealing. An intermediate people's court in Henan Province accepted the case of both parties.
There is no way to appeal and repent of the liver sausage
Zhu Yun's collection of paintings is indeed a fake, and Zhu Yun has no direct evidence to prove that the auction is genuine, and the painting he held at the time is the same. And at that time, introducing a friend to buy Zhu Yun's painting was a voluntary act of both parties, and there was an agreement to testify.
From beginning to end, he had no direct responsibility, and now Zhu Yun sued himself for fraud, which is really unreasonable. And Zhu Yun angrily recounted for a long time, but there was no actual evidence to prove that his painting was the one that was auctioned.
After careful investigation, the court did not have evidence to prove that Liu Yan had defrauded Zhu Yun, and in the end Zhu Yun lost the case.
And Liu Yan never spoke to Zhu Yun in person again, and the only time he answered Zhu Yun's phone call was just a faint saying, "Doing business is a willingness to fight and a willingness to suffer, it is all a matter that you decide, then don't regret it."
Zhu Yun was very excited, he wanted to find evidence and justice for himself, but where to find evidence, he stood at the door of the court, but his eyes were very confused, maybe the justice he wanted was really impossible to find.
This news was posted on the Internet by enthusiastic people, which instantly caused an uproar, contrary to the court's verdict, netizens all supported Zhu Yun, believing that he was calculated by experts, such a large program group, Jianbao has a corresponding process.
A treasure needs to be identified by more than three experts in the end in order to get a professional appraisal result. However, when Liu Yan received Zhu Yun, he only had one expert to identify it, and then directly gave the results of the fake, which was not professional in itself.
What's more, this expert is suddenly interested in the collection identified as a fake, and introduces customers to buy it, and no one will believe it if there is no cat in it.
But everything is the conjecture of netizens, there is no actual evidence, and there is also the agreement on the sale and purchase of the collection at that time, plus the identification process of the treasure appreciation program at that time was not professional and thorough.
Zhu Yun wants to find justice for himself, which is really difficult.
At last
Now that so many years have passed, there has been no follow-up news on the case of Zhu Yun's collection on the Internet, and Zhu Yun, who has not found evidence, has returned to his normal life and chose to give up his right to appeal.
The news that was spread that year also made more treasure appreciation programs in more regions learn from it, and further improved the identification process of free treasure appreciation programs, so as to prevent people with bad intentions from taking advantage of the opportunity and making Zhu Yun's tragedy repeat again.