Before reading this article, please click "Follow", so that you can continue to enjoy the celebrity stories that have touched you and me, thank you for your support.
Photo/Potato Entertainment said
Editor/Potato Entertainment said
Preface
In the Chinese film and television drama "In the Name of the People", the existence of the character Zhang Guimei has become a unique landscape. Interestingly, the same role was played by different actors, namely Haiqing and Song Jia. Surprisingly, however, the two actors received very different reviews when they played the same role.
Some viewers expressed dissatisfaction with Haiqing's performance and criticized her. Some commentators believe that she failed to perfectly present Zhang Guimei's personality traits, making the character image seem a little thin. This has sparked discussions, with some questioning the actors' acting skills and understanding of the characters.
On the contrary, Song Jia was praised for her performance in "In the Name of the People". The audience recognized her acting skills and grasp of the role, believing that she successfully gave Zhang Guimei a richer and deeper connotation. This made Song Jia the focus of discussion, and her performance was considered a highlight of the show.
This very different evaluation has led to thinking about the performing arts of actors, and it has also led to discussions about the interpretation of different actors in the same role. Audiences' expectations and standards for how to understand and shape characters are also evolving. In the process, the actors' performance style and understanding of the role will continue to be scrutinized and judged by the audience.
Haiqing's word-of-mouth has reversed at two levels
In this movie, the once low-key actor Haiqing fell into an embarrassing situation. She has been recognized by the audience for her steady acting skills and excellent performance in the past, however, this time she played Zhang Guimei was negatively evaluated. At the same time, we focus on Song Jia's choice. Taking over the image of Zhang Guimei is a difficult challenge for any actor.
Zhang Guimei is a veteran actor who is loved by the audience, and her image in many film and television works is unforgettable. Thus taking on this role is tantamount to confronting the high expectations of audiences and critics alike. Song Jia's choice is both a kind of courage and a show of her great confidence in her acting skills.
However, this decision also put her under a great deal of artistic and social pressure. In the process of taking over the role of Zhang Guimei, Song Jia not only had to deal with the huge challenge of character building, but also had to cater to the audience's expectations for the original role. Zhang Guimei's image has left a deep imprint in the hearts of the audience.
Therefore, to re-enact this image, it is necessary to have sufficient acting skills and a deep understanding of the role. Whether Song Jia can successfully present Zhang Guimei has become the focus of keen attention of fans and the media. Whether she will be able to make her mark in this pressure, or whether she will fall victim to controversy, has become a curious mystery.
Song Jia lived up to expectations
The controversy of the movie "Girls' School in the Mountains" has just passed, and the TV series version has been announced to be completed and the first trailer has been released. After experiencing the "antecedent" of "I Am a High Mountain", netizens paid special attention to this drama, but after watching the trailer, I think this drama is worth looking forward to.
In the trailer, the line "My only dream in my life is to create an all-free girls' high school" attracted the attention of netizens, because it was different from "Girls' School in the Mountains" and "I Was a High Mountain". In the movie version, Zhang Guimei, played by Haiqing, often appears in delirious clips, and her deceased husband seems to be her spiritual support.
Women's colleges, by contrast, don't seem to be her focus. However, in "Girls' School in the Mountains", Zhang Guimei played by Song Jia is full of power, and her mental outlook is brave and fearless. Zhang Guimei in reality is also resolute and has spent those difficult years alone. Some of the scenes in "Girls' School in the Mountains" are significantly different from the movie version.
In the movie, we see a father who works hard to get his children to school, and a mother who is an alcoholic and abusive. Such character portrayals seem relatively common in movies, but in real life, these niche situations are more realistic in "I Am a Mountain". However, "Girls' School in the Mountains" chooses to fully respect the archetypal story.
The problem of alcoholism in the clip is still placed on the father, and the violence against the child also comes from the father. Even when his mother stopped him, his father still started beating people when he was grumpy. At the same time, the drama version does not shy away from gender sensitivities. It is a straightforward display of the preference for men in the Daisen region, and the reality that women face in their predicament.
Despite the adaptation of some details, as a whole, "Girls' School in the Mountains" tries to maintain respect for the archetypal story and is committed to restoring the real situation. does not evade, does not adapt, even if it fails to see the whole story, the information revealed in the trailer shows that "Girls' School in the Mountains" strives to maintain its faithfulness to the original story and strives to show real life situations.
The supporting cast of "Girls' School in the Mountains" is strong
In biographical dramas, another controversial point is casting, especially in "Girls' School in the Mountains", the core character is Principal Zhang Guimei. In the drama version of "Girls' School in the Mountains", Zhang Guimei's role was given to Song Jia. This makes people feel that the gap between the images of Song Jia and Principal Zhang is even greater.
However, viewers who have watched Song Jia play a volunteer teacher in "The World" know that with her acting skills, it is not a problem to play Principal Zhang well. In the trailer, Song Jia has short hair and wears black-rimmed glasses, similar to Principal Zhang Guimei, and her eyes reveal tenderness. In the next moment, she held a loudspeaker to cheer for the students, and her expression was a little more nervous and serious.
Just as Principal Zhang gave the impression. Song Jia's version of Principal Zhang Guimei is very exciting. In this kind of biographical drama, the choice of actors often determines the presentation of the role and the audience's acceptance, and Song Jia's acting skills and acting ability give people confidence, and people can't wait to see how she plays this much-talked-about role.
conclusion
Haiqing and Song Jia, who played the same role, presented completely different images of Zhang Guimei. Haiqing's performance in the film version of "I Am a High Mountain" has caused a lot of controversy, and some people have accused her of a vicious image, which is inconsistent with the gentle image of Principal Zhang Guimei. In contrast, Song Jia's role in the drama version of "Girls' School in the Mountains" shows a refreshing image of Zhang Guimei.
It brings more expectations to the audience. First of all, Zhang Guimei, played by Haiqing, showed delirious clips in the movie, focusing more on her deceased husband, making the character image a little thin. The audience criticized her performance, believing that it did not perfectly present Zhang Guimei's personality traits.
In contrast, Song Jia's performance in the trailer is more powerful, she shows Zhang Guimei's perseverance and fearlessness, and injects a more three-dimensional and profound connotation into the role. Secondly, Haiqing has been recognized by the audience for her steady acting skills and excellent performance in her past works, however, this time she played Zhang Guimei was negatively evaluated.
On the contrary, Song Jia's choice is considered a kind of courage and great confidence in her acting skills. Through Song Jia's role as a volunteer teacher in "The World", the audience has higher expectations for her acting skills. Finally, in the trailer, Song Jia showed a unique image, with short hair and black-rimmed glasses, showing the gentleness and firmness of Principal Zhang Guimei.
Her performance has been affirmed by the audience, which makes people look forward to her performance in the play even more. On the whole, Haiqing and Song Jia respectively presented a completely different image of Zhang Guimei, and it can be seen from the trailer that Song Jia has better restored the prototype story and presented a more profound and vivid character to the audience. Her performance and image are more appropriate, so the audience is more full of expectations for Song Jia's version of Zhang Guimei.