This morning I saw Xiangyang netizen @7081930735 Liu drunk and ShanWeng wrote a micro headline "Reply to the so-called Earliest Argument of Nanyang Founder Voice", calling me "Nanyang Niu ER", and I was "Hu Stirring Wild Entanglement"!
The article uses a large number of errors to refute the author's argument that the earliest state of cultivated land was determined. Now that he has published his original text, I will answer one by one, and it is naturally clear who is messing around with him.
@7081930735 Stay Drunk and Shan Weng The full text is as follows:
Reply to the so-called earliest state recognition argument of Nanyang Founder Voice:
Nanyang Niu II:
(1) All your evidence is that there is no historian recorded that none of the thirty-seven counties of Nanyang County during the Three Kingdoms period at the end of the Eastern Han Dynasty were called Nanyang.
FangZheng replied: Nanyang is not an empty Nanyang, and Nanyang in the narrow sense refers specifically to Wancheng.
(2) China's earliest state recognized that the cultivation was Xiangyang Longzhong.
Founder answers: The author's erroneous argument comes from the following erroneous basis.
a, at the end of the Tang Dynasty, Jingxiang Jiedu made Zhao Kuangning ask the central government to change Zhuge Liang's title to king of Wuling, and rebuilt the "Zhuge WuHou Ancestral Hall".
Fang Zheng replied: The Tang Dynasty "Yuanhe County Chronicle" identifies Longzhong as twenty miles northwest of Xiangyang. The Zhuge Temple of King Wuling of Tang is thirty miles southwest of Fulong Mountain, where only Zhuge Temple has no Wuhou Ancestral Hall.
b, in the fourth year of the Southern Song Dynasty (1168 AD), the then Emperor Xiaozong of the Southern Song Dynasty decreed that the Temple of Zhuge Liang in Xiangyang Longzhong be given the "Yinghui Temple" and the Jia Renji Number.
Fang Zheng replied: Su Shi of the Song Dynasty determined that Longzhong was in the northwest of Wanshan Mountain, in the clouds; the Emperor of the Southern Song Dynasty gave Zhuge Liang the title of "Renji", or in the southwest thirty miles of Fulong Mountain Zhuge Temple. There is only Zhuge Temple and no Wuhou Ancestral Hall here.
C, in the second year of zhengde i of the Ming Dynasty (1507 AD), Emperor Wuzong of the Ming Dynasty approved the reconstruction of the Xiangyang Longzhong Wuhou Temple, and gave the temple the title of "Zhongwu" and the spring and autumn sacrifices.
Fang Zheng replied: After the above fabricated story "Xiangjian King Seizes the Grass Lu", it was born to have a grass house in Fulong Mountain, and it was born to have a Wuhou Ancestral Hall here. Twenty mile long in the northwest landed here.
These countries believe that Zhuge Liang's cultivated land is hundreds of years earlier than the Yuan Dynasty and the Ming Dynasty.
(3) Not to mention that the Yuan Dynasty official Xiu 's "Great Yuan Yi Tongzhi" records that "Longzhong, Han and Jin Spring and Autumn Clouds: Zhuge Liang's home Nanyang, twenty miles west of Xiangyang, the number of Rilongzhong". It is also recorded that "the Three Gu Gates are in Xiangyang Zhuge Liangyun: The Three Gu Chens are in the grass, and since then the gate has also come out of the past."
Fang Zheng replied: The "Great Yuan Yi Tongzhi" follows the "Han Jin Chunqiu" statement on Longzhong in order to spread false rumors. The "Great Yuan Yi Tongzhi" clearly defines Wollongong as a cultivated land. The earliest state identification of cultivated land occurred in the Yuan Dynasty.
The "Chronicle of the Unification of the Ming Dynasty" records: Xiangyang Province's "Mountains and Rivers" also says that "Longzhongshan is twenty-five miles northwest of the capital city, there is Longzhong Academy, han Zhuge Liang tasted hidden here" also records: "Longzhong Academy in Longzhongshan, Shu Han Zhuge Liang tasted this, posterity because of the construction of the temple, Yuan changed to a college", and "Monuments" Tianyun: "GeJing, in the west of (Xiangyang) Fucheng, Jingzhou Ji Zhuge Liang's house has a well", "Zhuge Liang's house, in the west of the fucheng twenty miles under the long mountain, Shu Han Zhuge Liang lived, there was a summer shelter in the west of the house, because zhaolie three Gu Liang in the grass, There are three gu doors".
Fang Zheng answered: The "Chronicle of the Unification of the Great Ming Dynasty" records that the northwest twenty-five miles of Longzhong are the residences, and at the same time records the Wuling King Temple of Fulong Mountain, thirty miles southwest of Xiangyang. It is clear that Longzhong and Fulong Mountain are not the same place. The Chronicle of the Unification of the Great Ming Dynasty also records that Wollongong is cultivated land.
Qing Qianlong's "Four Libraries of the Whole Book" quotes the "Notes on the Water Classics" and is also in the east of Longzhong, which is the old residence of Zhuge Kongming.
FangZheng replied: The above is a restatement of the "Notes on the Water Classic" in the "Four Libraries Complete Book", and there is no new meaning.
This is the earliest national identification you wrote about is not at the same time more specific to identify Xiangyang Longzhong.
In addition, in the 21st year of the Republic of China, in 1932, President Chiang Kai-shek visited Xiangyang Longzhong and invested 5,000 pieces of ocean to hold a ceremony to sacrifice Zhuge Kongming, build Zhongzheng Avenue, rebuild the lotus pond, copper drum platform, and erect a monument.
Fang Zheng replied: At this time, after the story of "Xiangjian King Seizing Caolu", Shi Zai was possessed by the Fulong Mountain in the northwest twenty lilong, and it has been distorted by falsehood. There is no suspense that Gulongzhong is Zhuge Liang's memorial site, and the above old Jiang's behavior does not mean that he has identified Longzhong as a cultivated land.
I hope that you will get rid of Niu Er's nonsense, pay attention to history, respect historians, and respect the verdict given to the people of the whole country by the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences.
Founder Summary:
First,
Today's southwest thirty miles of gulong was originally called Fulong Mountain, after the "Xiangjian King grabbed the grass lu" fabricated story, the northwest twenty lilong in the false here.
Second point
The earliest state of cultivated land was identified in the Yuan Dynasty, and it was clear that Wollongong was a cultivated land, and Longzhong was only a residence, and the location was not in today's scenic location.
Therefore, Xiangyang's top priority is to find the disappeared northwest twenty-mile longzhong, rather than pointlessly competing with Nanyang for cultivated land!
