Does it really matter if you make a mistake on the spot?
A sentence by Park Shu in "Tomorrow's Creation Plan" triggered a discussion on the whole network.
"I don't care about their mistakes, that part is something I would ignore," he said. ”
As soon as the voice dropped, netizens began to question.
"Don't care about mistakes, what kind of dangerous statement is this?"
"It's a game, it's not fair to others."
"Park Shu's idea is not right, we chose a singer not a personality."
"No wonder he doesn't care, he himself is not stable on the spot."
Barrage is all opposed to this view held by Park Shu.
This can also show the unity of his attitude towards music.
Because last season, he had the same attitude.
"Your clumsiness, youthfulness, and unskilledness are all very precious."
I was not at all surprised that this sentence came out of Park Shu's mouth.
This state of performance, which focuses on authenticity and nature, is a true portrayal of himself.
Everyone scolded him and questioned him, and I can understand.
Volkswagen is more from the perspective of a game.
If you can't evaluate objectively as a mentor, it's obviously unfair to other players.
No matter how cute and pure the personality is, what is the point if the business ability is not passed?
However, Park Shu's point of view made me think about it a little.
In the process of selecting musicians, is singing mistake really the most important?
For original musicians, the quality of the performer and the quality of the work seem to be more noteworthy than the singing ability itself.
An excellent stage needs to achieve the unity of singers and singers.
The view that Park Shu holds is, in my opinion, a sense of reality.
As The Ear Emperor said, technology can reach full marks through acquired training, but the special and agility of the performers cannot be trained.
Compared to the full score of technology, the sense of realism is more precious.
No matter how many years have passed, I will never forget the scene of Park Shu's "Farewell".
Video loading...
The first time I saw this video, I cried.
I was singed by him and soothed for a long time.
Objective evaluation, he made a mistake.
As a performer who can't cry until he can't cry, we can criticize him for having too weak emotional control.
The singer's emotions cannot be conflicted with the defense line, and can only be transmitted by relying on the song.
But after the video fermented online, I didn't see a single critical voice.
He obviously made a mistake, but why didn't everyone pay attention?
There are only endless emotions and praises in the message.
When the emotion is too strong, the listener automatically ignores the mistake.
In the face of such a sincere expression of emotion by Park Shu, who can always adhere to rationality.
It was precisely because he cried that I choked up several times and finally shed tears.
If he had remained calm and composed from beginning to end, I don't think he would have been so moving.
The truth and sensibility presented in Park Shu's version of "Farewell" will never be forgotten in my lifetime.
In my heart, this is the singing.
Including his performance of "Those Flowers" at the Chengdu Xingchao Music Festival during May Day.
He had the audience sing a whole paragraph.
It's not because he's trying to ease his voice or avoid mistakes, but it's an emotionally cohesive approach.
His scene did have problems with unstable breath and inaccurate sound.
But in that moment, the audience didn't care at all, because everyone was immersed in the emotional atmosphere he created.
For him, he pursues a real performance, not a perfect one.
For me, the mistakes caused by the outpouring of sincere emotions can become classics that will last forever.
In addition to Park Shu's "Farewell", I also remember Shan Yichun's "Love Letter to filmmakers" deeply.
On the stage of "The Voice of China", she sang the chorus part directly choked, and several sentences were not sung.
In the process of tearing, the pitch and breath were greatly affected.
As a singing competition, this will undoubtedly become a deduction for judges.
But the result is completely different, she not only got a high score, but also won the praise of the whole network.
"From a competitive point of view, this is a mistake, and from a singing point of view, this is the unity of human songs."
"Why do I feel that the choking area is the most moving, the more I listen to it, the better it sounds."
Many listeners said that her mistake was just right.
Not only did it not bring down the whole performance, but because of the mistake, the work was sublimated.
Because of an unexpected mistake on the spot, it turned imperfection into perfection.
This is unexpected and reasonable.
Rene Liu cried bitterly and sang "Later", which is also a good example.
At the last stop of the tour, she sang "Later".
As a singer, the biggest fear is that it is too emotional and can easily cause a car accident scene.
Singing to the chorus part, the emotions directly collapsed.
She stood on the stage, watching the crowd, listening to the chorus, and the tears kept flowing down.
I could feel her self-blame and anxiety as she sang and stopped, and finally finished the song with all the audience.
This mistake, however, created the classic scene of "Later", which is also an unexpected gain.
In fact, there are many examples of classic music scenes that have become classic music scenes due to mistakes, such as Eason Chan's "Pompous" sung by a cold, Huang Qishan's "Cut Love" sung while tears on the "Singer" stage, and Lin Junjie's failure to enter the accompaniment "We" in time because of his deep affection...
In fact, to talk so much is to say that the imperfection of the scene is likely to create perfection.
Live performances are inherently full of accidents, and of course, such accidents must be based on real singing.
This unexpected emotional exposure happens to be the most moving.
It moves us, but also because the singers are real enough.
This also returns to the point of controversy about Park Shu's negligible mistakes, for him, performance is to be real.
As long as the performance is sincere enough, the small mistakes in the singing can be ignored, because your emotions are so strong that the audience no longer pays attention to small details.
The above is some small thinking triggered by Park Shu's point of view.
Of course, objectively speaking, "mistakes can be ignored" only applies to talented players such as Park Shu, because most people cannot cover up flaws with emotions.
For most performers, it's better to practice the basics.
After all, skills can be achieved by hard work, and their own characteristics can be found.