Li Zhiyan: In order to make money, some experts deliberately say that the fake is true, or that the real is false

At present, China's collection market is chaotic, and some people say that one of the important reasons is the inaction or low level of the cultural relics appraisal industry. What do you think of Li Zhiyan on this issue?

Li Zhiyan: At present, some people in the people, out of the relationship of interests, viciously attack the old experts, and even fabricate facts out of nothing. Whenever experts say it is true, they say it is false, and whenever experts say it is false, they say it is true. For example, the "Ghost Valley Down the Mountain" Yuan Qinghua large pot auctioned in the United Kingdom, obviously the people came from a clear road, the inheritance was orderly, he did not see it, insisted on saying that it was fake, and also sent dozens of articles in a row.

Li Zhiyan: Indeed, there are big problems in the appraisal industry now, and the level of appraisal is uneven. In order to make money, some experts deliberately say that the fake is true, or that the real is fake. Desperate, if you have money, you will open a certificate, two words: really! There are also fake certificates. We should straighten out the appraisal contingent, and in conducting appraisals, we must have our own cultural accomplishment, and we must temper and accumulate through practice. Of course, the appraiser is not a god, and he will make mistakes, but he cannot be deliberately deceived, coveting a little profit, and betraying his conscience to harm people. Such people should be condemned and rectified!

Expert identification is not purely "ophthalmology", but also science. We also have to confirm and judge from all aspects, including historical knowledge, craft knowledge, aesthetic knowledge, etc., which is also a comprehensive appraisal. Some people originally had neither academic qualifications nor qualifications, and after being attached to a department, they appointed themselves as "researchers" and "professors" under the banner of "XX Appraisal Committee" or "XX University", and cheated everywhere under that banner. Things like this are difficult to do, and it is not easy to rectify.

Li Zhiyan: No matter how much ability and experience you have, you must also take a closer look, I have always advocated careful observation, slow conclusion, in the work of cultural relics identification can not be successful, many places are right, as long as there is a place that is not like, you must be extra careful. He believes that engaged in the identification of cultural relics, the character is the most important, the object is not right, we must carefully check the data, find evidence, sloppy, if you see the wrong thing, you must correct it in time, in the face of science, pay attention to seeking truth from facts, can not just want face.

Li Zhiyan: Folk collections are often not valued, and the phenomenon of collections being hastily "killed" abounds. The irresponsibility of some experts has greatly hurt the feelings of folk collection enthusiasts and the enthusiasm of folk collection activities, and the formation of this situation is naturally related to the fact that the mainland has not yet established a practical and feasible cultural relics appraisal qualification management system - who has the qualifications for cultural relics appraisal, who can supervise cultural relics appraisal activities and personnel, and this also leads to the current situation of counterfeiting and counterfeiting in the cultural relics collection market.

Qingqianlong imitation brother glazed string pattern plum bottle