Source: World Wide Web
[Global Network Report Reporter Zhao Youping] "ETtoday News Cloud" and many other Taiwan media news today, sung by Taiwanese singer Lu Guangzhong "The Name Carved in My Heart" won Taiwan's "Golden Melody Award" and "Best Song of the Year Award", the island's variety show host Wu Zongxian on the 28th approved that this song is not original at all, plagiarizing the old English song "Reality". Subsequently, the island's PTT forum netizens also dug out that this song is extremely similar to a piano song published by the mainland in 2019, "Freedom Hill" ("Freedom Hill"), and the prelude is almost "exactly the same". In this regard, the mainland piano composer responded: The front is indeed quite similar, but in popular songs, there are a few likes, and their personal is not particularly concerned, and the Taiwan media praised its "atmosphere" and "high EQ (emotional intelligence)".
Screenshot of Taiwan's "ETtoday News Cloud" report
According to Taiwan's "United News Network", Lu Guangzhong's theme song "The Name Engraved in My Heart" for the movie "The Name Engraved in Your Heart" won taiwan's "Golden Horse Award" and "Best Original Song" last year, and won the "Best Song of the Year Award" at the Taiwan "Golden Melody Award" this year. The song was composed by Malaysian creator Jia Wang, Chen Wenhua and Xu Yuanting, and produced by Taiwanese musician Huang Yuxun.
Taiwan's song, which won two "awards", was scolded by Wu Zongxian for not being original, and netizens on the island dug up it to copy mainland piano music
However, Taiwan's "United News Network" said that Wu Zongxian mentioned at the event on the 28th that Taiwan's "Golden Melody Award" awarded the annual song to "The Name Engraved in My Heart", and he questioned that the song was not original at all, "a plagiarized song, and then Taiwan's judges gave him the best song of the year, which was written on it as original." Wu Zongxian sang the old English song "Reality" while speaking, he said that he had sung countless times in the folk song Western restaurant, and as soon as he heard the melody of "engraved in", he immediately made an association, and he angrily criticized musicians for not even understanding this basic concept.
Lu Guangzhong (left), Wu Zongxian (data map)
According to the report, in fact, some netizens on the Internet questioned this song last year, but as it swept through Taiwan's "Golden Horse" and "Golden Song", the relevant discussion gradually disappeared. Wu Zongxian knew that he was the first person to openly question, "I was really willing to tell that the king was not wearing new clothes at all, then Taiwan did not accept me like this, so I slowly planned to leave the show business circle." ”
Screenshot of Taiwan's "United News Network" report
Subsequently, according to Taiwan's "ETtoday News Cloud" report, Wu Zongxian acid "the name engraved in my heart" plagiarism in the island forum PTT "Gossip Version" caused a hot discussion, some netizens posted an article breaking the news, saying that ""The name engraved in my heart" is basically a splicing song", not only similar to the old Western song "Reality", the prelude is also exactly the same as the mainland musician JINBAO's piano song "Freedom Hill" ("Freedom Hill"), the netizen attached the "Freedom Hill" music link, I want netizens to comment on the reasoning, "Everyone listens to what it doesn't look like." ↓
"The Name Engraved in My Heart" was exposed by PTT netizens suspected of plagiarism of "Freedom が丘"
According to the report, jinbao, the author of "Freedom Hill", is a famous independent musician in the mainland, and many netizens on the island commented "Wow, scared", "It's too much like it", "This song is really like, the 'Golden Melody Award' should be withdrawn", "This is not just like it, it's exactly the same". ↓
However, some netizens believe, "I think there is so much music in the world, it is unlikely to find something completely different." ↓
For the plagiarism storm of "The Name Engraved in My Heart", a veteran musician who was a judge of Taiwan's "Golden Melody Awards" told the "ETtoday News Cloud": "'Reality' only has two sentences almost the same, and this song was very popular in the 80s. He also believes that "The Name Engraved in My Heart" and the first six subsections of "Liberty Hill" are almost exactly the same, "but I think the creator's own cognition is the most important, whether there is plagiarism, I can hardly determine, can only say that it is very similar." ”
For the rumored plagiarism, the lyrics of "The Name Engraved in My Heart", the composer, the studio to which the singer belongs, the "Golden Horse Executive Committee", the Taiwan Cultural Department... They all came out and spoke out, all in denial.
"The Name Engraved in My Heart" was jointly composed by Xu Yuanting, Xie Jiawang and Chen Wenhua, and the three of them issued a lawyer statement through Warner earlier, calling the song original and "definitely not plagiarized"; the singer Lu Guangzhong's Tianyi Chuangyue Studio responded: "After comparison, the songs have certain differences. We respect the creators of Malaysia and also respect the views of Brother Xian, thank you. ”
Qu Youning, the film producer of "The Name Engraved in My Heart", also spoke out in the early morning of the 29th that "holding uneven", believing that plagiarism on the crown is "a crime of wanting to add", "It is a little difficult to agree that this is the advice of a predecessor who loves music." ”
For some netizens advised "Lu Guangzhong was returned to the award", the response of the "Golden Horse Executive Committee" on the 29th was: "The Name Engraved in My Heart" is specially created for the film, rather than using the published song, so it meets this provision, if the song is determined by the law to have a copyright dispute, the association has the right to declare the qualifications are not in line with the law, cancel the qualifications for the award, but there is no such determination, so it will not cancel the qualifications.
In addition, Taiwan's cultural department came out to speak: regarding the 32nd "Golden Melody Awards Annual Song" "The Name Engraved in My Heart" is suspected of involving copyright disputes, according to the "Copyright Law", it should be proposed by the copyright owner, and after the court's rigorous professional judgment, the "Film and Television Bureau of the Ministry of Culture" will then dispose of it according to the judgment results. "The Name Engraved in My Heart" has also been copied from the mainland piano song "Freedom Hill" ("Freedom Hill"), so what does its author JINBAO think?
According to Taiwan's "ETtoday News Cloud", JINBAO "High EQ (Emotional Intelligence)" responded to the matter.
According to the report, for this plagiarism incident, JINBAO responded generously in the early morning of the 29th: "People often send me private messages, and I will make an explanation here." I've heard about "The Name Engraved in My Heart", and the front is really quite similar. However, in popular songs, there are a few likes that also exist, and it is normal for harmony to be carried out. Of course, it is not excluded that the author has heard of my work. Personally, I don't particularly care. Just concentrate on your own business. Thank you. ”↓
JINBAO was plagiarized in the "NetEase Cloud Music" response
Jinbao's profile on the "NetEase Cloud Music" personal homepage is "Independent Musicians."" Post-85s"
Jinbao's account of the plagiarism was also transmitted back to Taiwan. Many netizens on the island left messages on the island forum PTT, praising JINBAO's "atmosphere". Some netizens criticized the composer of "The Name Engraved in My Heart": "Just because people don't care about the measurement doesn't mean you're right." "Just because he doesn't care doesn't mean you didn't copy it." ↓
What do you think?