laitimes

Yao Jiani is followed by Luo Tianyu, and the adaptation of the new version of "Moonlight on the Fifth Day of October" Situ Lixin is also very bad

author:Rambling on film critics

Unauthorized reproduction is strictly prohibited.

The remake of "The Truth of Changing Lives" is "Moonlight on the Fifth Day of October".

Not only does it have classic feelings in the circle of fans, but the aura of Taiwanese drama also makes the audience look forward to it.

But it is a veritable high and low.

Yao Jiani is followed by Luo Tianyu, and the adaptation of the new version of "Moonlight on the Fifth Day of October" Situ Lixin is also very bad

"Moonlight on the Fifth Day of October"

"Moonlight on the Fifth Day of October" premiered with a 22-point rating, in part because of the light of the finale of "The Truth About Changing Lives".

But then it gradually fell below 20 points.

That's enough to say how bad the show is.

Indeed, the new version of "Moonlight on the Fifth Day of October" has been magically changed to make people speechless.

Yao Jiani is followed by Luo Tianyu, and the adaptation of the new version of "Moonlight on the Fifth Day of October" Situ Lixin is also very bad

Objectively speaking, the story of "Moonlight on the Fifth Day of October" is some dog blood.

In particular, the feelings of each character are entangled with each other.

Fortunately, the plot point is over, coupled with the background rendering of Macau Street, the story shown by everyone is particularly humane.

And it will avoid some very thunderous settings.

Yao Jiani is followed by Luo Tianyu, and the adaptation of the new version of "Moonlight on the Fifth Day of October" Situ Lixin is also very bad

Comparing the two editions, let me give the most obvious example.

In the original "Moonlight on the Fifth Day of October", Zhu Shajiao (Xue Jiayan), Zhu Zhanhui (Guo Feng), and Ma Bingxin (Chen Jiayi) are a triangular relationship.

But the plot avoids this triangle and only writes that Ma Bingxin becomes selfish and arrogant under the seduction of his sister.

Yao Jiani is followed by Luo Tianyu, and the adaptation of the new version of "Moonlight on the Fifth Day of October" Situ Lixin is also very bad

The new version of "Moonlight on the Fifth Day of October" not only did not avoid this old-fashioned triangle, but also intensified.

While writing that Zhu Shahua (Yao Jiani) is provoking marital discord between Zhu Zhanhui (Hai Junjie) and Ma Bingxin (Kang Hua).

At the same time, it also shows the ambiguity of Zhu Shahua and Zhu Zhanhui.

Although Zhu Shahua's husband was unfaithful first, now TVB's screenwriters are so blatantly using the cheating plot as a selling point.

Yao Jiani is followed by Luo Tianyu, and the adaptation of the new version of "Moonlight on the Fifth Day of October" Situ Lixin is also very bad

Zhu Shahua was the first place where the magic was changed the most wordlessly.

Originally just an idle character, but he wrote her a dog blood "cheating" play that had nothing to do with the main line.

To emphasize, it is a "spiritual derailment."

The screenwriter very cleverly uses an ambiguous way to touch the problem of the three views of porcelain.

And in the scene, Yao Jiani's appearance rate is even higher than that of several protagonists.

Yao Jiani is followed by Luo Tianyu, and the adaptation of the new version of "Moonlight on the Fifth Day of October" Situ Lixin is also very bad

In addition to Zhu Shahua, Situ Lixin (Luo Tianyu) is another place where the new version is very badly adapted.

Situ Lixin was the second generation of the rich, but when he was a child, he did not take good care of his younger brother when he was swimming, resulting in his brother drowning.

His mother hated him because of this, and there was a gap between him and his parents.

Yao Jiani is followed by Luo Tianyu, and the adaptation of the new version of "Moonlight on the Fifth Day of October" Situ Lixin is also very bad

The original "Moonlight on the Fifth Day of October" is only a brief reference to the past of Situ Lixin (Ma Junwei).

Because this setting has nothing to do with the main line.

The main line is the love of Wen Chu (Zhang Zhilin) and Jiao's aunt, that is, wishing "Good Jun".

Yao Jiani is followed by Luo Tianyu, and the adaptation of the new version of "Moonlight on the Fifth Day of October" Situ Lixin is also very bad

The new version is the complete opposite of the original version, and it is a very detailed representation of Situ Lixin's life.

From the appearance of their parents, the family of three is very strange when they get along.

Situ Lixin took his parents to the tree where he had taken a photo, but his mother suddenly blamed Situ Lixin out of control.

Finally blame all the problems on depression.

Yao Jiani is followed by Luo Tianyu, and the adaptation of the new version of "Moonlight on the Fifth Day of October" Situ Lixin is also very bad

It can be seen that the new version must not only elaborate the Thunder Man setting of Situ Lixin.

But the story is very perfunctory, pushing family problems directly to depression.

And depression is the setting of "On Call 36 Hours".

The estrangement between Situ Lixin and his parents is almost a copy of the mother-daughter story of Han Malley, Huang Zhiwen and Yang Yi in "On Call 36 Hours".

Yao Jiani is followed by Luo Tianyu, and the adaptation of the new version of "Moonlight on the Fifth Day of October" Situ Lixin is also very bad

Overall, although it is necessary to make the works of 20 years old respond to the present, some adaptations must be done.

However, the so-called adaptation of the new version of "Moonlight on the Fifth Day of October" is to make up for the original Thunderman settings that were trying to avoid.

Added Zhu Shahua and Zhu Zhanhui's dog blood triangle.

Meticulously refining the thunderous past of Situ Lixin.

And this story is not only irrelevant to the main line, there is no character in it that is normal.

Yao Jiani is followed by Luo Tianyu, and the adaptation of the new version of "Moonlight on the Fifth Day of October" Situ Lixin is also very bad

In fact, judging from the works produced by TVB in recent years, TVB's screenwriters and producers are indeed not as good as before.

Many scripts are becoming more and more cheesy, either competing for family property or small three.

Professional drama can't write depth, so use emotional drama to make up the number.

Anyway, as long as there is a topic, there is a gimmick.

The new version of "Moonlight on the Fifth Day of October" is named to evoke good memories from the audience.

But at present, it seems that the original warm story has only been adapted into some dog blood emotional dramas.

The pictures in the text are from the screenshots in the play, and if there is infringement, it must be deleted

Read on