Can Han Xue act?
Yes, in the acting competition variety show, Zhang Ziyi couldn't help but clap his hands.
Will Han Xue direct?
Some people say she will, and after watching her adaptation of "Cinema Paradiso" in "Director's Advice", she was moved to tears.
Some people also say that she is moving herself, the whole short film plot is missing, the plot is suspended, the logic is inconsistent, the characters are too single, and it is too embarrassing to force sensationalism.
After the film was screened, Han Xue himself cried a lot, film critics and producers were confused, and Li Chengru did not cry but laughed, and the picture was extremely ironic.
Moving out of Zhang Yimou and Han Hong, Han Xue's directorial debut is still overturned.
Her short film adaptation mainly tells the poignant story of a takeaway brother who travels away from home to a big city to struggle.
At work, you will often encounter customer orders, overtime delivery, and even being hit by a car. He races against time every day, but misses the last time he sees his grandfather, leaving regrets.
The story takes the route of family affection and empathy, and could have earned enough tears from the audience like films such as "My Sister" and "Hello, Li Huanying", but only Han Xue himself cried unceasingly.
Many people analyze the reasons for Han Xue's failure from various angles, and some people point out that the short film lacks the background explanation of the takeaway brother, and also ignores the family background between him and his grandfather;
Some people think that the characters in the short film are too single; some people are very dissatisfied with the reaction of the male protagonist after learning of his grandfather's death.
Netizens brushed together in the bullet screen and expressed puzzlement, not understanding why the male protagonist was in pain but never rushed home to see the last side of his grandfather.
These are the reasons for the failure of Director Han Xue's debut, but these are all problems in professional skills and professional experience, and if you study intensively over time, there will be some improvement.
In my opinion, the main reason for Han Xue's failure is that she is not grounded, does not understand "human fireworks", does not understand the real life of the general public, and naturally cannot shoot works that can make people "empathize".
Han Xue did look serious and careful during the filming of the short film, and she also deliberately emphasized that it should be grounded, the male protagonist can not wear makeup, and must be as life-like as possible.
This is understandable, but the short film that can be made proves that it is too difficult to make the stars grounded!
The takeaway brother played by Zheng Yibin is really experiencing life! Not to mention the dark skin, the face does not see a trace of the vicissitudes of the wind and the sun, but white and tender.
The takeaway brother played by Ou Hao in "Chinese Doctor" has been deeply impressed by many people, that is grounded and life- The character image in Han Xue's short film can't help but make people think of "the domineering president experiences life".
There is also the living conditions of the male protagonist, and people who have had experience working in big cities know that such a delicate bedroom must be expensive, which is too inconsistent with the setting of the character's occupation in the short film.
Also in "Chinese Doctor", the narrow living conditions of the takeaway brother are restored very really.
It's not that they have to live in a house with poor conditions, but everyone who has had difficult times or earned hard money knows that it is very difficult to make money, and some money should be spent and some money can be saved, after all, there are many places where money is needed.
Seeing this, you may say that I am too grounded, but this is the life of the general public, this is the real human fireworks. It can only be said that Han Xue, who wants to be grounded, is too detached from the lives of ordinary people. With a luxurious lineup and the original intention of life, Han Xue lost on "not grounded".
In fact, this is not a problem for Han Xue alone, many stars have such a problem.
Recently, the performance of Ouyang Nana and Wang Sutaki in the variety show "Strange Encounters in the Corner of the World" was also unanimously complained by netizens: Why not eat meat?
The program team arranged for them to experience errands with the runners, such a hard job of earning money by physical strength and running for life, which became a "romantic and happy" job in the eyes of the two stars.
The errand runners race against the clock to grab the single and send the order, and they are all the way to the hip-hop and play;
Runners complete one more order to earn more money, in order to make life better, they are for happiness, not rushed a day's income can buy a cup of mung bean paste, is their happiness of running errands.
The literary and artistic atmosphere is too heavy is not an excuse, and the need for program recording is not the reason, under the banner of "empathy with the general public", but with the superiority of "experiencing the human world under the stars".
Not understanding fireworks in the world and being separated from the lives of ordinary people is the biggest problem of "Han Xue".
You may say: "As stars, they earn money so quickly and have a relatively large income, why should they live the life of ordinary people like you?" ”
That's what they can do. But when they are directors and actors, and they want to complete a work that makes ordinary people empathize, they need to "ground the gas" first.
Duan Yihong is a "drama maniac", in order to better interpret each role, his acting has always been an "experiential" performance.
In the early years, when he was shooting his graduation work, in order to play a mentally ill person, he voluntarily went to a mental hospital for a few days. Before filming "The Detonator", Duan Yihong insisted on experiencing the life of a miner.
During this period, he talked deeply with miners of all ages, working with the workers on the first line of the mine for a kilometer, he said:
I don't touch them, I don't feel what they're thinking, if I don't talk to them, I don't know what kind of psychology they have for this state of life, just for money? Is it just for a living? Won't they think about the possibility that they won't be able to get up the well tomorrow? How much fear is there under the well? These are things I can't take for granted. ”
Sometimes the stars seem to be too high, which will lead to ungroundedness, and the works will only be false filters on the screen, lacking human fireworks, and cannot move anyone.
The works made can only move themselves, not excellent directors. The role played is not infectious and cannot resonate, nor is it a good actor who can act.
This point, "Han Xue" need to remember!