"Flying snow shoots white deer in the sky, and the laughing book god man leans on the blue duck." In Mr. Jin Yong's "Shooting Eagle" trilogy, "Yitian Slaughtering Dragon" is a novel that has attracted much attention, and Zhao Min, as the absolute heroine of the book, is especially loved by everyone because of her eccentric and resourceful personality. Up to now, in terms of TV dramas alone, "Yitian Slaughtering Dragon" has undergone eight adaptations, which means that there have been eight TV series versions of Zhao Min who have met with the audience. Among them, Zhao Min played by Li Zi in the 2001 version of "Yitian Slaughtering Dragon" and Zhao Min played by Jia Jingwen in the 2003 version of "Yitian Slaughtering Dragon" are the most impressive, so who is better than Zhao Min played by these two people? Let's compare.
Appearance: The two are equally divided
The woman who plays Zhao Min must be a first-class beauty, which, whether it is Li Zi or Jia Jingwen, their appearance and image are in line with people's imagination of Zhao Min.
Needless to say, Li Zi's beauty is a first-class existence even if she is placed in the entire Hong Kong showbiz circle. Even Cecilia Cheung, who is known for her beauty, has also admitted very convincingly that in the whole of Hong Kong, only Li Zi is more beautiful than her. Although this sentence has a modest meaning, it also reflects that Li Zi's beauty is recognized by everyone.
And Jia Jingwen's appearance has also been affirmed by everyone, when starring in "Little Li Flying Knife", Jia Jingwen's appearance is actually slightly green, but in "Yitian Slaughtering Dragon", at that time, Jia Jingwen has fully grown, a proper goddess. Even Andy Lau, a superstar of the Heavenly King, has also commented on Jia Jingwen's beauty: Lin Chiling is the most beautiful woman with more than 170 centimeters; jia Jingwen is the most beautiful under 170 centimeters.
Zhao Min, played by the two, is very in line with the depiction of Zhao Min in the original work, which is beautiful and beautiful, so in terms of appearance, I think the two are equal.
Acting: Jia Jingwen slightly won
In the acting field, I personally prefer Jia Jingwen to be slightly better.
Of course, when I say this, I don't mean that Li Zi's performance is not good, on the contrary, her performance in "The Book of the Dragon Slayer in the Heavens" is almost perfect, which completely satisfies my imagination of Zhao Min's role as bright as jade, eyes as clear as water, and brilliant as roses.
The reason why I think Jia Jingwen's acting skills are slightly better is from a comprehensive point of view. Jia Jingwen has always been an actor who has been delayed by her appearance, and as everyone knows, in the acting field, she has never been vain to anyone. Do you remember the TV series "The Distance Between Us and Evil" that aired a few years ago? In this play, Jia Jingwen almost dedicated textbook acting skills to us, and with the role of Song Joan, she herself won the Golden Bell Award for Actress in a Drama Program.
Although Li Zi's performance in "Leaning Heaven" is perfect, her performance in other works is not as good as Jia Jingwen. The most obvious is that in the drama "Pearls and Treasures", her performance is really lackluster; and even in "Golden Branch Desire", which made her win the honor of the after-view, I personally think that her performance is inferior to that of Deng Cuiwen, the "Rufei" actor in the same play.
Temperament: Li Zisheng
Playing the role of Zhao Min, I personally think that temperament is the most important part, and the actor who plays her must have the unique potential of being heroic and cool in men's clothing and bright and indispensable when women's clothing.
In this area, I believe most people will think that Li Zi is better. When she first appeared in men's clothing at the top of the bright light, she made people feel indistinguishable from male and female, and that witty and fierce temperament instantly fascinated a large wave of viewers in front of the TV; and when she changed into women's clothing, Li Zi instantly transformed into a smart elf, a pretty woman who dared to love and hate, which made people feel pity.
Jia Jingwen in the women's clothing, in fact, is not weaker than Li Zi, she plays the women's clothing Zhao Min, the same magnificent, delicate posture fluttering. But in the men's wear area, Jia Jingwen is much worse than Li Zi, at least when I watched the 03 version of "Leaning heaven", I did not feel that the men's clothing Zhao Min played by her had a sense of strategic calm, in summary, or her daughter temperament is too strong.
Conclusion: In general, whether it is Zi Min or Wen Min, it is a very good version among many Zhao Min actors. We don't have to tear each other apart over the merits and the disadvantages. Friends who really like Zhao Min will chase after two versions of "Leaning Heaven"; and friends who don't like another version will not get it if they don't watch it?
What are your thoughts on this article? You are welcome to comment on the message.
This article is original by "Rose in Red Wine" and unauthorized reproduction is prohibited.
Image source: Network