In the past two years, it seems that everyone has fallen in love with singing. Singing variety shows are very popular, and there are many offline singing competition activities. In addition to the contestants, the judges are often the focus of controversy. Recently, an 8-year-old child star was pushed to the forefront.
It turned out that one of the judges invited by the organizers of a singing competition in Jining, Shandong Province, was an 8-year-old child star.
At the age of 8, many children are not familiar with the world when they are so old ~ and this child star has become a judge of the "2020 China Jining National Singer Competition".
In the face of the contestants of the uncles and aunts and even the grandparents, the child star was not afraid of the stage at all, and was very sophisticated in shaking baggage and giving advice with the attitude of a person who came over.
Is it really good to comment in public on adults singing at the age of 8? This has sparked heated discussions.
Some netizens think that the child's evaluation of the elders is impolite, some netizens question her professionalism, and some netizens worry that they can't see the innocence that this age should be in her.
In response, ms. Huang, the agent of the child star, responded that seeing that there were many objections on the Internet, and some singers with representative works also opposed, Ms. Huang asked: "Do you have her famous?"
Some netizens feel that there is nothing wrong with child star reviews, and they cannot be intimidated because of their young age.
Dog fox is the original intention: planing out the words of the agent, I think there is no problem with what the children say ~ there is no problem with what the children say ~ There is no respect for people ~ Why can't children comment on adults? Since it is a national singing activity, is there any problem for children to comment from the perspective of children?
Hip-hop:? Why can't children comment on their elders? Are they also quite objective, because the adults are elders, so there is a sense of superiority?
1998 Deng Feifei: Did the child say something wrong? Why can't I review it because of age?
The little cute can be me: I think this child is very good, very polite, and uses honorifics for the uncle... If you have a certain foundation, it is not condemnable to teach others, regardless of age. (Personal opinion)
Some netizens are worried that letting children soak in commercial performances will "ripen" them.
Aoyama Daimayuki: I can't see innocence in her body, it feels more like an adult talking, and the parents are a bit anxious.
LV – Quiet Good Years: I don't think it's true that a child comments that an elder is rude, and if she has the ability to do so, she can comment. The question is how high is the level of singing and theory of an 8-year-old child, can she be a judge? Would you rate it? The organizers are doing this to be eye-catching.
Cute stars like the wind: Some children are naturally more sensitive to music than some adults. But commenting on others requires not only talent, but also qualifications, experience, emotional intelligence, and expression, especially for children, imitating adults to talk too early, really don't look like a child. It felt like she was raised like a child who imitated maturity but was not mature at all, but was used as a cash cow by her parents.
In fact, this is still the cliché of "prodigy obsession" and "child star manufacturing". Obviously, when children participate in activities, their words and deeds look like small adults, which must not be out of the nature of children, but are deliberately imitated by adults the day after tomorrow. As the Beijing Youth Daily said, "At the age of 8, when I first started learning, most of them were still in the stage of enlightenment, and they lacked experience and knowledge accumulation. This is actually an over-consumption of child stars, and it is a tool to use child stars as a tool to make money. This is also extremely irresponsible for child stars. ”
As a parent, if your child has any strengths or talents, it is advisable to provide them with opportunities to cultivate and exercise because of the situation. However, if we blindly disregard the natural growth laws of children out of selfishness, artificially "create stars" and treat them as "cash cows" and "tool people", it is a violation and deprivation of children's rights and interests.
What do you think about this? Welcome to leave a message to discuss.