There is an example where a 130kg tigress is said to have killed a 170kg brown bear to prove that the tiger has the ability to defeat a brown bear larger than herself, and there is an incident in which a medium-sized tiger is said to have killed a 200kg female brown bear. So is this really the case? Look for the origins of such events!
▲"130kg tigress kills 170kg brown bear" concocted by tiger blowing
This short video has been circulating on the Internet for more than a decade, and the early version was 7 minutes long, and now the variant video released on Station B has expanded its duration to 11 minutes. As for the material of the video, it basically comes from the discussion of a predator forum abroad, coupled with the private goods of "black background and white words".
The short video gives the citation source - "Soviet Mammals" (commonly referred to as "Soviet Zoology" on the Internet). Here, the "mixed compilation of true and false" that tiger blowers have always used to falsify, listing the literature while carrying private goods.
▲ The record of "Mammals of the USSR" quoted in the video
So how was the event recorded in "Mammals of the USSR"?
▲ The original text of "Mammals of the Ussconus"
The original text of "Soviet Mammals" only states that "a brown bear with a body length of 158 cm and a weight of 170 kg was killed by a tigress." As for how big this tigress is, it is never mentioned in the original text. So where does this tigress weigh 130kg come from? Yes, this tigress weighs 130kg and double-clicks is the brain supplement of tiger blowing.
▲ 130kg from the speculation of tiger blowers
The content quoted in the video is the subjective speculation of a group of tiger blowers in a foreign meat-eating forum.
Only some signs of brown bears are recorded in the original text, and there is no record of signs data for tigresses. In this case, there are no records, there are N possibilities of how big this tigress is, and perhaps this tigress is a very large female tiger that is far larger than the average male tiger!
All the uncertain content (how was the video of the tiger killing an 800-pound brown bear made?) - Bilibili), once it gets into tiger blowing hands, it becomes convincing?
▲Baidu Encyclopedia "Dale kills 220kg female brown bear"
In the Baidu Encyclopedia of Tiger Dale (number M20), there is such a record, tiger Dale, weighing 206kg, killed a female brown bear weighing 200-220kg. So is the truth of the matter really as Baidu Encyclopedia said?
▲An early version of Baidu Encyclopedia Tiger Dale
Tiger Dale's Baidu Encyclopedia was created on April 2, 2012, and the early list of killed female brown bears weighed 150-200kg. Until July 9, 2020, for the sake of the cause of Everbright Blowing Tiger, the "150-200kg female brown bear" achieved a leap to "200-220kg female brown bear".
▲Baidu Encyclopedia how to add weight to the female brown bear!
After seeing how Tiger Blowing used Baidu Encyclopedia (Wikipedia is a "website that allows visitors to add or modify information", and everyone can compile (usurp) the content of the series (change)) to achieve the great cause of Blowing Tiger, we return to the original topic.
The prototype of the case in which a tiger killed an adult female brown bear comes from the famous Amur Tiger Project monograph "Chapter 19: The Relationship of the Amur Tiger with Brown bears and black bears", and the lead author of this scientific research paper is Ivan Serriokin.
Chapter 19: The Relationship Between the Amur Tiger and the Brown and Black Bears
Translation: "Four cases left sufficient evidence (both were killing adult female brown bears). There are two inconspicuous marks of fighting, indicating that the tiger quickly killed the bear. Two more fights lasted for a long time, and finally the bear was killed. In July 1997, the adult male tiger M20 attacked a female brown bear, and a fierce fight broke out, resulting in the destruction of most of the bushes within 10×2 meters of the forest. At the scene of the fight, there were a large number of bear hair fragments that fell, and there were also many tiger hair fragments. Within a 30-meter-long radius of the entire fight scene, there was blood on the ground and on trees. Another case occurred in August 2001, when a tiger used the slope to attack a female brown bear aged 8-10 years and weighing about 150-200 kg. During the fight, both beasts rolled down the slope for several meters. There are traces of fighting within 10 × 8 meters. After successfully killing the female brown bear, the male tiger retreated to a distance of 15 meters to rest. The male tiger was also injured and bleeding. The female bear may have taken her cubs with her cubs, who managed to escape. ”
Through the records in chapter 19, it can be found that Tiger Dale did kill the female brown bear, but it is not known how big the female brown bear was killed, and the physical signs data of the killed female brown bear are not recorded in the paper.
Another account occurred in August 2001, in which early understandings identified the unknown tiger as "Dale." Tiger Dale was rumored to have fallen into an ice and drowned in March 2000, and if this rumor is true, then the tiger killing the mother brown bear in August 2001 was not the work of Tiger Dale. Therefore, there is also a medium-sized tiger that defeats a 200kg brown bear.
Returning to the original paper, it will be found that whether it is the tiger trumpeting "200kg tiger king kills 220kg female brown bear" or "medium-sized tiger kills 200kg brown bear", there is no conclusive evidence to support it.
1. In the case of Dale killing bears, the physical sign data of all the female brown bears were not mentioned! How to conclusively say "200-220kg female brown bear";
2. In the August 2001 tiger killing incident, no signs of the tiger were mentioned! How to conclusively say "medium size";
3. In the August 2001 tiger killing incident, the weight range of the female brown bear was "150-200kg", in this range, the weight of the female brown bear can be 150kg, or it can be any value of 150-200kg, there are N possibilities! How to conclusively say 200kg.
In summary, there is no exact scientific record of how big the adult female brown bear killed by Tiger Dale was; how big the tiger that killed 150-200kg female brown bear was, there is no exact scientific record; whether the victimized female brown bear was 150kg or 200kg, there is no exact scientific record.
There is no record in the current scientific expedition records of "tigers killing brown bears larger than themselves"! How come all the uncertain content becomes convincing once it reaches the hands of tiger blowing?
What does the comparison between the side of the tiger and the bear illustrate?
On the one hand, this group emphasizes that brown bears are not much larger than tigers, and like to compare tigers with bears on the side. But when it comes to the example of a tiger killing a brown bear, I like to make up the story of "a small tiger kills a big bear".
What does the head-on comparison between a tiger and a bear illustrate?
If you want to visually compare the size of two species, why not clearly report the values of each sign, and why not make a comprehensive comparison?