Editor's note: From my experience, I know that this article of the Yellow River ancestor will definitely have many people jumping out and spraying. For example: First, the typical carrying of the essence, you don't know that it is a movie? Second, I think you are full of food. Third, another one who has eaten enough to support, there is really nothing to write, is it? Fourth, the police chase the bandit line: stop, don't run. You say, is that? Fifth, you are almost depressed! This movie is almost three times! It's nice to look at! I didn't expect you to put in such great effort! Go early and be born early!
The above is still good, and then someone will jump out and buckle your hat, Comrade Huanghe. Like what:
Sixth, after analyzing so many loopholes, I just want to tell you that the movie is very exciting, but this divine drama. When China is strong, there are always some villains who come out to ridicule and understand their childish minds. Seventh, you dog traitor!
Comrade, the above is your message in the article "Walter Defends Sarajevo", haha.
Unlike the Yellow River ancestors, I never watch movies. Most people have fun watching movies, and I understand that. For example, my pleasure is that today I saw that there was a mistake in Xin Deyong's article, and I came to refute him, which is my pleasure. Some people watch movies from the perspective of their expertise, and that's his pleasure. Since I, a person who does not watch movies, can understand the fun of watching movies, shouldN't I also understand the fun of other people looking at movies from different angles? Green vegetables and turnips have their own love, that's all.
The following is the text:
First of all, I basically didn't cry when I watched the movie, because when I watched the movie, I kept thinking, if I write this script, what will happen next. I think the whole progress is similar to what I thought, except that there are more errors in common sense.
"The Wandering Earth" is a science fiction movie, a science fiction movie that is very worth watching, although this movie has some shortcomings of one kind or another, but it is a movie that is very worth watching. In this movie, many people's emotions are ignited by the idea of Jupiter and trigger an emotional explosion, and in my opinion, I prefer the idea of saturation rescue. This idea has never appeared in the previous predominantly American science fiction world, and for our Chinese, it is a simple explanation of our common sense and why civilization continues. Listen to the phrase "everyone is forced to make a final roar" in our national anthem, and the various trials and errors after 1840 are not typical saturation rescues? The Russian national anthem has "God bless you, our only homeland"; the British national anthem "God bless the queen"; the American national anthem "Thank God for the power"; but the French Marseillaise has no God, similar to us, only France and China have experienced the close to the subjugation of the country, know that at this time Di ge can not play any role, have to rely on themselves.
Science fiction is a combination of science and fantasy, and fantasy is based on science. Without science, you can only get the disease-free groaning "Folding Beijing" and "Shanghai Fortress" and other emotional works dressed in science fiction skins, wagging their tails to certain groups of people and praying for wealth and fame. War also needs science, and war is not a fierce blow, because if we do not talk about science in other things, we may die; and if we do not talk about science in war, we will definitely die.
Judging from the finished product of this movie and the various information gradually revealed in the past few days, the team dominated by director Guo Fan has learned a lot from astrophysicists, architects, code farmers, etc., and it is likely that there is a professional communication or code farmer in the screenwriting team, because some of the stems cannot be played by laymen, such as Lao He sarcastic Li Yiyi. And if the name Li Yiyi is not mistaken by Li Er, it must be a code farmer. But I guess they didn't talk to people in chemistry.
1. The first rule of war is to know oneself and know one's enemy, which is obviously not realized by the Team of The Wandering Earth. The earth's posture has changed, it should be known at the first time, and the team on duty immediately analyzes and judges the reasons for it and reports it to the supreme leader, after all, this is a war, and the war carried out by the sun. It can be said that the work of confidant is not done well.
2. The second article is to know the other. With the help of Jupiter's gravitational slingshot, how did Jupiter suddenly increase its gravitational pull by 25%? After all, this is still within the scope of classical physics, so a sudden increase in Jupiter's gravity by 25% can only be a 25% increase in its mass. Then the only way to increase Jupiter's mass by 25% is to swallow Saturn. The first and second largest planets of the solar system merged, and these people on Earth actually had no preliminary intelligence at all, which can be said to be unknown. I know that some people will say that the earth causes a change in Jupiter's centroid, the astronaut's body is also a fluid, the soft packaging food in space is also a fluid, close to the two, there will be no change, the earth is actually an egg, and there is also a fluid under a layer of crust. Or rather, a coconut near you won't have any effect on you unless the coconut hits you on the head.
3. The space station still has three hundred thousand tons of fuel, which is a bit less. The sub-stage of Saturn V plus the fuel of the third pole is 600 tons, which is a global fate, and the technology has crossed the controllable nuclear fusion, so that the fuel is still chemical fuel. Bumped a bit. This is considered to be ignorant of oneself, and the misestimation of one's own ability.
4. In terms of longitude, Sulawesi Volcano is similar to Beijing, Jining, and Hangzhou, considering that the steering engine is on the equator, so this morning and dusk line is stuck at such a distance, which is not reasonable. Shanghai is still a little east, it is daytime, then we put the big Pacific Ocean against the sun, this brake angle is not appropriate. After all, you still have to dig up stones to burn the heavy element fusion engine. [I thought about it last night, it should be that the earth has turned over, the north pole is facing the sun, and the south pole is rushing out.] This explains the Flood, which is too much sunlight in the Arctic. In fact, the possibility of a major flood is unlikely, because most of the water is in the southern hemisphere, because no sun is frozen.
5. In the movie, two children come from the ground to the ground, facing the wind and snow. This is not very reasonable, minus 81 °, no water, carbon dioxide are frozen, where is the snow? The driest place on Earth is not the Sahara Desert, but somewhere in Antarctica, because it is so cold that the water in the air is all on the ground. The wind is reasonable, although the earth has stopped, but because of the uneven heating and the heat of the nearby heavy ion nuclear fusion engine, the wind must be very large.
6. The number of people on the space station is counted, I am afraid that there will not be thousands of people. This bit of fuel allows these people to fly to centaur 4.3 light years away, less, without a shield to protect against objects such as meteorites, all by physical resistance? This is also considered to be self-conscious.
The rest is not to know the "Tao", and not to know the "Tao" is not to know.
7. I am very interested in the material of this planetary engine, after all, it has to withstand such a large reaction force, and you spray at the zenith, acting in the direction of the earth's centroid, how to put the brakes on the earth? If you can withstand the steering of the spout, you will be obedient. A ball, we apply force to the center in all directions, can only squeeze it out, but can not make it turn, naturally can not stop turning. The earth stopped autobiography, personally feel that the significance is not great. You planetary engines are destined to adjust the angle of the nozzle.
8. In the movie, it is the Earth that breaks through the Roche limit as if it is about to be over. In fact, it will not be so fast, if it is really that state, the earth will first become a satellite of Jupiter in a slow circle, and then slowly disintegrate, go home and eat bowls of rice and then commit suicide is still too late, even if the suicide is the most difficult to use "Southern Fourteen-type" pistol, commonly known as the Wang Eight Box, this gun failure rate is extremely high, repair the gun and then commit suicide is too late.
9. If you set the distance in the movie, the ground is not a few hundred meters of ice, but a hell full of lava flowing and fire. According to the density of Earth and Jupiter, the Roche limit is the order of 170,000 kilometers, which is 70,000 kilometers. Everyone can't save anything. Because the earth's crust is a layer of egg shells, the mantle below is thousands of degrees. Mentioning that the Hangzhou dungeon was flooded with magma, I also thought of this, but like the planetary engine, if it can't be pushed, we can't make this movie.
10. If I were to consider shipping tinder, I would consider two other more secure options. One is to backup in place near the engine, in fact, the engine is not far away, set up a Texas region, Binzhou region, Hengshui Daqu can be; the second is Dongfeng Express, the mission will be reached, the warhead can be changed to a return capsule. Not to mention that at that time, all kinds of missile ranges and carrying capabilities can meet the requirements.
11. Before reaching the distance of seventy thousand kilometers in the movie, there is no atmosphere on the earth, because the Roche limit of the atmosphere is the order of million kilometers, and people have long been choked to death. Besides, how is it possible that the density of the air has dropped sharply and the coalition government does not know anything. Pm2.5 goes up a little bit, and we all know that oxygen levels drop by three percentage points, and basically everyone is going to be uncomfortable.
(The earth should be like this at this time)
12. In addition, the Roche limit is related to density. Before reaching 70,000 kilometers, the ice layer will be torn apart and will not be honestly frozen on the ground. So when Hukou comes to the ground, he will be faced with a song of ice and fire, the ground is fire, the sky is ice, and Jupiter, who occupies most of the sky seventy thousand kilometers away, is smiling at him.
(Seventy thousand kilometers away, so big for Jupiter)
13. The distance of seventy thousand kilometers is not a problem of not being able to see Jupiter, but a question of whether to be frightened to death after seeing Jupiter. I always thought the special effects could make this out. Before they reach Jupiter, they can already see this hellish celestial phenomenon, not most of the sky, but bigger than the moon.
(Seventy thousand kilometers away, we see the size of Jupiter)
14. I have always felt that before the distance of seventy thousand kilometers, people should have been unable to stand on the ground, at least the acceleration of gravity would not be so good.
15. The gravitational slingshot does not need to be skipped from such a low altitude. The escape speed in the Earth's orbit is 42.1 km/s, while the Earth's autobiographical speed is 466 m/s (on the equator), so it is not difficult to slowly increase the speed of such a powerful engine that can make the Earth make emergency brakes. The farther away the escape speed, the smaller it is, to know that the speed of the traveler has flown out at a speed of more than ten kilometers per second. Rough calculations don't seem to make jupiters as gravitational slingshots. Anyway, I have the motivation to slowly accelerate behind.
16. The closest thing to Jupiter is Ganymede, about 420,000 kilometers, the nearest Earth in the movie is 70,000 kilometers, obviously a little bit from a distance, even if we have this speed of 30km/s, then a day forward is even a million kilometers, which has reached the Roche limit of air. Lieutenant Colonel Liu Peiqiang glanced out the window a day in advance and knew something was wrong. If it is more than ten years in the movie, then this speed may be even slower, and countless people should have judged it long ago, and the time in advance is rich according to the monthly calculation.
(From Jupiter's moons, 10 km/s is the lowest speed at which the Earth has skimmed Jupiter, and it can't be lowered, and no matter how low it is, it is not left as a satellite, but rather.)
17. The Earth is approaching Jupiter at a very high speed, even if we slow down 10km/s, 5000km is 500s, and some people take a bath and even put on their pants. Earth and Jupiter are not relatively static.
18. Is 70,000 km high? What ICBM can't fly over, just kidding. Now an icing-missile on Earth can only fly twenty thousand kilometers because he only needs to fly twenty thousand kilometers. Now China can hit the synchronous orbit satellite, shooting at a height of 36,000. In the setting of the movie, the missile can fly thousands of kilometers to be attracted by Jupiter's own gravity, and it is a trouble to hit accurately. Besides, igniting with a high-energy laser is enough energy and accuracy.
19. Jupiter's orbital inclination is not much different from ours, according to the setting in the movie, before we approach Jupiter, we must first undergo a baptism of Jupiter rings, the earth is so big, and it is flying near Jupiter's rings, it is too attractive, the space station may have been in ruins. In this case, it is clear that the anti-satellite missile with a sufficiently high altitude is already on duty.
20. Proxima Centauri is not on the ecliptic plane of the Sun, and this little broken ball must also engage in a jumping motion.
21. 70,000 kilometers seems to be a large distance, but the space station is 100,000 kilometers away from The Earth, and there are spaceships to travel back and forth. Can't the spacecraft that picks up Liu Peiqiang complete this detonation mission? From discovery to planning, there is also a day according to the plot, how enough. Besides, if the space station is in front of the Earth, the space station should be closer to the active than the Earth. The material of the space station should generally be aluminum alloy, which is less dense than the earth, and the space station should be affected first.
22. The space station relies on rotation to create gravity, we take Wu Jing's body as a reference, it can be seen that this rotational speed is by no means enough to form a gravitational acceleration of 7.9, not counting, the gap in order of magnitude may be more than an order of magnitude.
23. In this case, it is more convenient to throw a string of hydrogen bombs at Jupiter than to ignite them. It is estimated that the script did not set the hydrogen bomb because it was afraid of detonating Jupiter into a series of explosions into stars. Rest assured, it can't be done. Jupiter does exceed the lower limit of stellar mass and is possible to become a star, but the probability is low.
24. The Earth has its own Van Allen Belt, and Jupiter has its own. Even if there is no sudden increase in Jupiter's gravity, it is necessary to cross this strong radiation belt, why toss yourself so much. Especially on the space station, I am afraid that people cannot bear it.
25. The combustion limit of hydrogen is 4.0-75.0% in air. So instead of igniting Jupiter, it's detonating a little bit of hydrogen on Jupiter, jupiter is too big. Moreover, even if the earth's oxygen is exhausted, although everyone is dead, it is useless. I didn't calculate the specific amount, it should be several orders of magnitude worse, remember Tsinghua's Bi Dao once calculated.
26. The screenwriter probably forgot that more than 70% of our air is nitrogen, so if it is really ignited or detonated, the nitrogen will turn into nitric acid at high temperatures. If you give the earth a nitric acid shower, I'll still be dead.
This is still a good movie, a good movie made by a group of filmmakers. Thanks to the director, thanks to Da Liu, thanks to the screenwriting group, thanks to Wu Jing, thanks to the actors, thanks to the staff, thanks to the Gong Ge producer who made "Bird Cage Mountain Bandit", thanks to those who paid silently behind the two special effects companies that failed to wait for the release of the film to go bankrupt.
The author of this article: Huanghe deceased, the public account "this is the war" to join the author, without the author himself and the WeChat public account "this is the war" permission, may not be reproduced, violators will be investigated for legal responsibility.
About the author of the public account: Wang Zhengxing, a former officer of a field unit of the People's Liberation Army, has served in infantry detachments, headquarters, logistics departments and other units, is committed to the study of war history and tactics, and has a unique understanding of military tactics and non-war operations. His book "This is War" was recommended in two issues in May and June 2014 by Phoenix TV's "Eight Minutes of Open Volume" column. His public account name is also "This is war", welcome to pay attention.