The distinction between the authenticity and falsity of Liu Wendian's calligraphy

Recently, I saw a calligraphy work on the Internet that claimed to be Liu Wendian's codex, which was written by himself: The hometown is no longer a thing, and the country is in conflict. The township pass beacon fire sound book is broken, and the secret cabinet cloud smoke classic is slight. There are thousands of articles, and there is no news when to return. Lan Chengjiu held an outlier and looked at Chunhui independently.

The payment is: Peng Zidong Poetry Bong Yongpu Mr. CunZheng

Signature: Brother Wendian

Plutonium Seal: Dawn

Online comments said that the calligraphy of this work is "bone force hole", I don't understand much, the calligraphy is good or bad, but I think this is a forgery, should not be written by Mr. Liu himself.

Throughout his life, Liu Wendian "followed Sun Yat-sen, rescued Chen Duxiu, expelled Zhang Shizhao, and denounced Chiang Kai-shek", and was a famous figure and master of traditional Chinese studies during the Republic of China period. However, the so-called "real fake can't be fake, and fake can't be true", after all, imposters can't stand scrutiny. Let me now talk about the reason why I insist that this is a forgery from two aspects.

First, this work is written as a poem given to his wife by Liu Wendian, and he should not make a mistake in writing his own work, but the last sentence of the poem in the calligraphy should have been "Independent Cang cang look at the sunset" but written as "look at the spring hui", a word difference, so that the meaning of the poem can not be explained, the master of traditional Chinese studies can not make such a low-level mistake.

Second, the explanation of the falling paragraph does not make sense. Liu Wendian was born in 1889 and died in 1958, and once in his life he experienced the year of Pengzi, that is, in 1948. Mr. Yongpu, also known as Yao Yongpu, in early 1928, Anhui Province prepared to prepare for the establishment of Anhui University, that autumn when the school opened, Yao Yongpu was hired as a professor of the College of Literature, and Liu Wendian was the president. However, Yao Yongpu was born in 1861 and died in 1939. How could Liu Wendian still write poetry ten years after a person's death?