There is a historical record about the time when Qin Huiwen Wang Yingsi was crown prince, saying that during the Shang Martingale reform period, Ying Si, as the crown prince, did not obey the will of his father Qin Xiaogong, but stood in the ranks of the nobles in the court and opposed the change of law. The history books say that "in the year of the People's Republic, the kingdom of the Qin People said that the inconvenience of the initial order was in the thousands." So the prince broke the law. ”
Due to the various obstacles faced at the beginning of the change, especially the opposition of the nobility and the people, it seems that it is understandable for Yingsi to follow the trend. Qin Xiaogong and Shang Martin's determination to implement the change of law was unshakable, and they just took the crown prince at this time to open the knife. However, the prince was young and crazy after all, and there was also Taifu Taishi on it. "Punish his Fu Gongzi Qian, and depose his master Gongsun Jia", Gongzi Qian Gongsun Jia became the flag bearer of the new law.
In the Book of Shang Jun, there are "forbidden kings, assassinations, broken feet, and face of people." This means that when the kings of the Qin Kingdom were formulating criminal laws, some were executed, some had their legs cut off, and some of them had tattoos and ink on people's faces. There is no mention of what kind of crime was committed in order to be appeased. In the Book of Shang Jun, there are also "a thousand rings of people, rules and regulations, and the orders are under the city." "It is said that on the battlefield, as a Qin soldier general, if he is afraid of death to escape, he will suffer the humiliation of tattooing his face in front of everyone in full view of everyone, and he will seriously goug out his nose.
Then, as the crown prince's concubine, was it possible to commit the crime of deserters on the battlefield at that time? Logically, the two generations of Qin monarchs at that time, including Qin Xiangong and Qin Xiaogong, were considered to be monarchs who worked hard to govern, and most of them were full of blood, and they fought many battles with the State of Wei in order to recover the land of Hexi. The young people who grow up in this environment should not have a weak personality on the battlefield, so the possibility of deserting on the battlefield is relatively low.
It is said in the "Records of History" that "the order was carried out in the year of the people, and the country of the Qin people said that the inconvenience of the initial order was in the thousands." So the prince broke the law. "When it was said that the first anniversary of the Shang Martingale Transformation Law was completed, there was a continuous opposition in the country." Therefore, this word reflects Sima Qian's point of view, preceded by the opposition of the people, and the purpose of the prince's violation of the law seems to be to petition for the people, deliberately testing the law by himself, and trying to hinder the further implementation of the law change with illegal acts. This kind of statement seems to be more naïve as King Huiwen of Qin. Of course, at this time, Qin Huiwen Wang Yingsi was still young, and judging from his flesh and blood Personality, there was still a certain possibility.
Later, there was the Chronicle of the States of the Eastern Zhou Dynasty, which speculated that Yingsi opposed Qin Xiaogong's move to the capital Xianyang, and used this to slander the new law, and even Shang martingale convicted the prince and punished Gongzi Qian and Gongsun Jia. Here is a more explicit list of the crimes of the donkey. But the credibility is geometric and worth considering. So, what kind of crime is committed by The Donkey, at present, it can only be proved by archaeological excavations.