I watched "My Father and Me" on the day of the premiere.
I didn't want to write anything, but it was over.
But recently, I have seen how well Zhang Ziyi's "Poems" are filmed on the Internet, and I really dare not compliment them, from my point of view, Zhang Ziyi's "Poems" should be the worst of the four stories.
Some friends may not be convinced, each spending their own eyes, we do not argue, only say my own opinion.
Let's come one by one, let's talk about the first one, Wu Jing Wu Lei's "Riding the Wind".
It's a movie that surprises people enough.
It is hard to imagine that the first set of propositions in "My Father and Me" is that the father chose to sacrifice his son in order to save the people.
It's a very heavy story.
We can understand this father's choice.
The mission of a soldier is to defend his family and country.
This home is not only my own warm little home, but also belongs to this nation and belongs to this country of heaven and earth.
Therefore, when faced with the desperate situation of enemy encirclement, facing the death of hundreds of people who died with it, as a commander, as a soldier, he had no choice but to make a decision that his father would rather die than make.
The tiger is a hundred beasts, who dare to touch its wrath. Only parent-child affection, step by step review.
At that moment, I think his heart should be extremely painful
He was not a good father, but he was a qualified commander and a great Chinese soldier.
It is precisely with such soldiers that we have today's China, prosperous and prosperous!
Needless to say, the horse battle behind it.
Raise your sword to drive out the Tartars, and draw your sword to behead your enemies.
When the red flag flew in this world.
As a Chinese, it's hard not to be touched by this.
The final ending is also very meaningful, riding the wind, the same lineage, different surnames, the same name, for the father, maybe his own son, is still alive.
Last rating: 95
It would be nice if it were longer, but time constraints are understandable.
The second, "Poetry"
Many people on the Internet and even professional screenwriters say that it is good.
But I can tell you from a professional point of view, what is not good about it.
First of all, the theme is nothing wrong with it, the spirit of spaceflight, very great.
But does it speak of the greatness of the spirit of spaceflight?
Yes, but not comprehensively.
First of all, the theme of the story is me and my father's generation, but in fact the poem is about an adopted son and his adoptive mother.
After all, father is a very broad word, and talking about mother is not off topic.
But comrades, students, your protagonist in front of you is your brother, and then your sister became an astronaut?
Just like the Western Heavens taking the scriptures, the four Tang monks and disciples experienced 9981 difficulties, and the result was that the last person to obtain the true scriptures was the third prince of Nezha, do you say humor?
Even so, there is a line in the middle that is inexplicable.
That's what the kid said.
My dad and my former dad are dead.
Then an explanatory plot popped up.
Rank, delete this nonsense, doesn't it affect your storyline at all?
Good stories are never explained for the sake of explanation.
It's like talking about crosstalk.
If this sentence is excerpted without affecting the audience's understanding, there is really no need to add this sentence.
This is the fault that is committed here.
Suddenly, inexplicably.
There are also movies that are montaged.
What is a montage?
The popular explanation is that it is not necessary to shoot everything out, and the moderate omission does not affect the audience's understanding of this is called montage.
But what about "Poetry"?
It was made like a science and education film.
Afraid that the audience will not understand, flashbacks repeatedly to explain the plot.
In fact, everyone understands well?
You go back and forth in such a short period of time, it will only make the audience look inexplicable.
Some people said, I think it's very good, I see crying.
It is normal to see crying, although the story is not very good, the logic problem is very large, but the actor is still remarkable, moved by the character performance, moved by the final Shenzhou spaceship soaring into the sky, which is understandable, but as a movie, if you don't tell a good story, this is a failure, no matter how good the acting skills, it will eventually become mediocre.
So I scored it last: 60
Xu Zheng's "Duck Prophet"
Last year's "Last Lesson" in my hometown earned enough tears.
This year is another comedy.
A unique Shanghai alley style comedy.
Incorporate all the baggage into the fragments of life.
In fact, this is a very advanced way of comedy performance.
Originally, this work could also be supernatural.
But the final ending, it feels like it has to be linked to the modern point in time, in fact, I think it is a particularly good ending with a bunch of advertisements, and finally a little... What to say, dog tail sable?
Of course, the flaws are not hidden, and small problems do not affect the brilliance of this story.
Final score: 90
Shen Teng's "Young Man's Journey"
Teen line is really ok!
Happy twist familiar style.
Not too novel but exciting enough story.
As the finale of "My Father and Me", according to the cross-talk stage, Shen Teng handed over a satisfactory answer sheet.
The laughter point baggage is definitely full.
However, it is also because it is too full, resulting in the last sensational part almost meaningless.
Of course, this may have something to do with the fact that everyone themselves have not had contact with robots, knowing that this is a machine, compared to people, it will always feel less sad.
But in any case, this "Young Line" as a short film, is absolutely wonderful, everyone is worth watching.
Final score: 95
In summary, my evaluation of the movie "My Father and Me", just like my title, is two super, one good and one mediocre, what opinions do you have, we can discuss together.