What happened to the Song Dynasty? Why do future generations think that "there are no generals in the Northern Song Dynasty, and there is no phase in the Southern Song Dynasty"
Author: Wen Reading History (I hope you will support and pay more attention to Wen Reading History)
This article is the first original, without my consent is strictly forbidden to plagiarize, carry, otherwise you will resort to law, the consequences are at your own risk!
The Song Dynasty, which occupied an important place in Chinese history from 960 to 1279 AD, is known for its unique political, economic, and cultural characteristics. However, in the historical evaluation of later generations, there is often the assertion that "the Northern Song Dynasty has no generals, and the Southern Song Dynasty has no phase". This assertion not only reveals some of the military and political dilemmas of the Song Dynasty, but also provokes us to ponder the history of the Song Dynasty.
1. No generals in the Northern Song Dynasty: the dilemma of the military system and the loss of military generals
1. The background to the formation of the military system
The military system of the Song Dynasty was closely related to its founding process and ruling philosophy. The founding emperor Zhao Kuangyin, as a military general born in the army, seized the world by force in the chaos of the five dynasties and ten kingdoms. However, he was also well aware of the dangers of uncontrolled military power, so after the establishment of the Song Dynasty, he set out to reform the military system to prevent generals from mutiny and maintain centralized power. This idea was further carried forward by his successor, Song Taizong, and formed a unique military system of the Song Dynasty.
2. Separation of powers, checks and balances, and separation of civil and military
The military system of the Song Dynasty was established under the principles of separation of powers, checks and balances, and separation of civil and military. The Privy Council, as the highest military leadership organ, is in charge of military decision-making and troop transfer, but does not directly command the army, but is carried out through institutions such as the Sanya (the Command Department of the Palace, the Guards and Horses, and the Guards and Infantry Divisions). This system design avoids the monopoly of military power by any one institution or individual, but it also weakens the autonomy and flexibility of the military.
In addition, the rulers of the Song Dynasty valued the role of literati and despised the status of military generals. Civilian officials serve in the military as military supervisors, jiedu envoys, governors, etc., and are responsible for military decision-making, scheduling, auditing, and other affairs, while military generals are mainly responsible for military command, training, and operations. Although this system of separating civil and military forces has strengthened the central government's control over the military, it has also led to the loss of military generals and the waste of military talents.
3. Military decline and war loss
The military system of the Song Dynasty was effective in maintaining centralized power, but it also led to the decline of the military. The army loses its autonomy and flexibility, is unable to adapt to the changes of the war, and is unable to effectively defend itself against enemy aggression. During the Northern Song Dynasty, in the face of the invasion of Liao, Western Xia and other countries, the Song Dynasty army was repeatedly defeated, and finally had to sign a peace treaty in exchange for peace. These treaties not only ceded territory, but also paid huge amounts of coinage, which imposed a heavy economic burden on the Song dynasty.
4. The awkward position of military generals
During the Northern Song Dynasty, the position of military generals was relatively awkward. Although they have a certain amount of military power, they are constrained and restricted by civilian officials and are unable to give full play to their talents. At the same time, due to the suspicion and precautions of the rulers, it is often difficult for military generals to be reused and trusted. This situation put the Northern Song Dynasty in a difficult situation militarily, unable to train excellent generals to resist foreign invasion.
2. The Southern Song Dynasty has no phase: the dilemma of the political system and the powerlessness of the prime minister
1. The evolution of the political system
During the Southern Song Dynasty, the political system developed on the basis of inheriting the Northern Song Dynasty. The central body is still the "two-government system", that is, the two institutions of the Central Committee and the Privy Council hold both civil and military powers. However, with the changes in the situation and the needs of the rulers, the political system has also undergone some adjustments. For example, in the early years of the Southern Song Dynasty, the left and right officials of Shangshu were abolished, and the powers of the prime minister were concentrated on the official positions of Shangshu left and right servants, such as Pingzhangshi and Governor of Zhongshumen. Although these adjustments have strengthened the centralization of power to a certain extent, they have also made the power of the prime minister more decentralized and powerless.
2. The Prime Minister's inability to fight with the party
The prime ministers of the Southern Song Dynasty faced many difficulties and challenges. On the one hand, they had to deal with the Jin Dynasty and Mongol incursions from the north; On the other hand, they also need to deal with internal party disputes and contradictions. In such cases, prime ministers often struggle to display their talents and ambitions. They not only have to deal with heavy administrative and military affairs, but also maintain neutrality and balance in party struggles. This situation made the prime ministers of the Southern Song Dynasty seem powerless and helpless.
3. The impact of partisanship
Party strife during the Southern Song Dynasty had a profound impact on politics. The struggle between different political factions not only consumes the resources and energy of the State, but also prevents the Government from developing effective decision-making and implementation mechanisms. In such a situation, it is difficult for even a talented prime minister to play his role. They are often entangled and constrained by partisan strife and are unable to concentrate on handling government and military affairs. This situation plunged the politics of the Southern Song Dynasty into chaos and predicament.
4. External pressure and internal contradictions
The Southern Song Dynasty also faced external pressure and internal contradictions. The Jin Dynasty and the Mongol invasion seriously threatened the border security of the Southern Song Dynasty; The internal peasant uprisings and ethnic contradictions also exacerbated social unrest and unrest. Under these circumstances, the Southern Song Dynasty government needed to devote a lot of resources and energy to meet these challenges. However, due to the difficulties of the political system and the inability of the prime minister, the Southern Song Dynasty government was often unable to respond effectively to these challenges, resulting in serious threats to the security and stability of the country.
3. Reflection on "the Northern Song Dynasty has no generals, and the Southern Song Dynasty has no phase".
1. Pros and cons of system design
The military and political system of the Song Dynasty achieved certain results in maintaining centralized power, but it also brought many drawbacks. Although the separation of powers and balances and the separation of civil and military forces in the military system have prevented the defection of the army and the dictatorship of the generals, they have also weakened the autonomy and flexibility of the army. The partisanship in the political system and the inability of the prime minister make it impossible for the government to form an effective decision-making and implementation mechanism. These drawbacks were reflected and reflected to varying degrees in the Northern Song Dynasty and the Southern Song Dynasty.
2. Historical Revelations
Although the assertion that "the Northern Song Dynasty has no generals, and the Southern Song Dynasty has no appearance" is somewhat one-sided and absolute, it also reveals certain military and political dilemmas and problems of the Song Dynasty. These predicaments and problems not only affected the historical development process and destiny of the Song Dynasty, but also left us with profound historical enlightenment and reflection. We should draw lessons and lessons from the history of the Song Dynasty and constantly improve and develop our military and political systems to meet the challenges and opportunities of the future.
3. The prosperity of culture and the dilemma of institutions
It is worth noting that despite some military and political dilemmas and problems, the Song Dynasty reached a peak in Chinese history with its culture. During the Song Dynasty, the commodity economy was prosperous, culture and education were developed, science and technology developed rapidly, Song Ci flourished, and the art of calligraphy and painting also made high achievements. These cultural achievements have not only enriched the cultural treasure house of the Chinese nation, but also made important contributions to the development of world culture. However, it is also a reminder that the development and prosperity of culture does not completely obscure institutional dilemmas and problems. We should constantly improve and improve our institutional design to better promote the prosperity and development of the country while promoting cultural development.
epilogue
Although the thesis that "the Northern Song Dynasty has no generals, and the Southern Song Dynasty has no phase" is somewhat one-sided and absolute, it also reveals certain military and political dilemmas and problems of the Song Dynasty. We should draw lessons and experience from the history of the Song Dynasty and constantly improve and develop our military and political systems to meet the challenges and opportunities of the future. At the same time, we should also see that the cultural prosperity and achievements of the Song Dynasty added rich content to the cultural treasure house of the Chinese nation and made important contributions to the development of world culture.