Cover a variety of topics and share a variety of discussions
Use unbridled thinking to write unique reviews
Take a look, think about it, talk about it
Focus on having something new to talk about every day
Today's new conversations:
Why can't the Song Dynasty dominate the world for 300 years???
Do you know what problems exist in Yue Fei's Northern Expedition?
1. Unpredictable war wins and losses. No one can guarantee that Yue Fei will definitely win, just like when Liu Yuke returned to the two capitals, who would have thought that the situation in Guanzhong would change suddenly? What if Yue Fei's Northern Expedition failed, the whole army was annihilated, and the Jin army took advantage of the situation to go south?
2. Unforeseen political risks. First, Song Qinzong was still alive at that time, even if you think that Song Qinzong's southern return could not move Song Gaozong's status, but what about the heirs? Song Gaozong is the heir, and Song Qinzong returns to the south, so naturally some people will propose to make his son the heir, so the unpredictability of the court situation is too high. Second, there is the possibility of martial artists becoming bigger, Yue's army has a tendency to be privately armed, and the success of the Northern Expedition will be Yue Fei's prestige unprecedented, isn't Song Gaozong worried that Yue Fei is the second Liu Yu?
Well, even if Yue Fei is able to fight and be loyal enough, hit the Great Wall and recover Yanyun, can he solve the crisis in the north of the Song Dynasty? No! China's wars with the northern ethnic minorities have not stopped since the Qin Dynasty, for Song Gaozong, is there an essential difference between fighting on the Great Wall and fighting on the Yangtze River? Huo Quzhi won the Xiongnu, and the north of the two Han Dynasty was too peaceful? Li Jing swept away the Turks, and the northern Tang Dynasty didn't fight? Yue Fei can't overthrow the Jin Dynasty, the grassland will always be "wildfires can't be burned, and the spring breeze blows and grows", and Yue Fei's Northern Expedition can't be done once and for all.
You asked Song Gaozong to take both military and political risks, and all he got was a change in the national border and some false names.
When Song Gaozong was running south in the Jin army, although he was running, he still chose to resist. However, when he stabilized the situation, the regime was safe, and he no longer worried about the Jin army going south, of course he would not seek to forge ahead, after all, the risks and benefits were completely disproportionate, you all stood in the perspective of God and the moral high ground, blaming Song Gaozong, did you really think about it seriously, if you were in Song Gaozong's position, would you really support Yue Fei's Northern Expedition? This is what the world is like, but any emperor with a little brain will choose like this, choosing decisions that are beneficial to him (not necessarily beneficial to the world).
Yue Fei was under Zong Ze, but he was just a middle and lower-level officer, but he was pulled by Song Gaozong, and the rocket rose, without Song Gaozong, there would be no Yue Fei, without the existence of Song Gaozong, and there would be no establishment of the Southern Song Dynasty, in the eyes of Song Gaozong, the Southern Song Dynasty is his personal property, and the autocratic emperor is like this, rather than criticizing Song Gaozong, it is better to criticize the autocratic monarchy.
From the perspective of autocratic monarchy, Song Gaozong did nothing wrong, he was selfish, very selfish, but never stupid, this is the biggest misunderstanding of your team Song Gaozong, a mediocre person, it is impossible to establish a dynasty with the identity of the only son of the royal family, after all, everyone in the Song Dynasty knows what it is: "The Son of Heaven would rather have a kind of it, and the soldiers and horses are strong", the imperial power in the two Song Dynasty has long lost the sacred feeling of the two Han Dynasty.
Speaking of ideas, the Turks and Liao are not opponents of the same level, and the difficulty of Xiao Song beating Liaojin is several levels higher than that of Datang fighting Turks. Without him, the northern nomads are also learning to evolve.
Whether it is the Wei and Jin gates or the Sui and Tang Qiu Ba, they have never died in the world
And the civil officials with Song and Ming will inevitably drive the car to Yashan and Maolu Mountain
"The Qin Dynasty must not be five hundred years" Or are you studying the difference between the Qin State and the Qin Dynasty?
Although the mistake upstairs was outrageous, Zhao Guangyi's strategy and tactics at that time were not very wrong, and Yelu Xiuge also fought hard to succeed in the surprise attack.
said that Zhao Kuangyin usurped the throne, the question is whether Chai Rong has a general who can be trusted? Zhao Kuangyin is the general he can trust the most, and other generals are even more unreliable, so in this matter, Chai Rong has no reason to blame Zhao Kuangyin, his descendants will not be able to keep the throne no matter what, at least Zhao Kuangyin did not kill the Chai family, and when he arrived at the underworld, Chai Rong also had to accept Zhao Kuangyin's feelings.
Reunification costs money, but doesn't it cost money to guard against Western Xia Liaojin? Doesn't it cost money? If it can really be unified, it will cost you once. A large number of Northwest troops spent 100 years of money. It also indirectly led to the desertification of the entire northwest land, which has not been restored until now. How do you calculate this money? The Northern Song Dynasty has no ability, and some talents will not be used, otherwise if any unified dynasty is changed, how can the Western Xia withstand it, even if it is Liao, it is impossible to stand in Youzhou.
What's the difference? The difference is in the strength of the country. Li Tang's founding army was at least hundreds of thousands, and the Northern Song Dynasty's founding central forbidden army was 120,000, counting this number, it was not enough for Li Tang to die. For other dynasties, is 100,000 troops enough? dream
Zhu Yuanzhang should not just be for the legitimacy of the Northern Expedition, Hongwu ascended the throne in the first year, and he had already driven the Yuan Dynasty out of Dadu and recovered the sixteen states of Yanyun, but until the twenty-fifth year of Hongwu, he repeatedly went on the Northern Expedition until the border trouble was eliminated. What is it for, it is nothing more than hoping that future generations will not be Huiqin. History is like this, some things keep circulating, but those who come after are trying their best to improve in order not to repeat themselves in history.