There are thousands of remakes, and half of the classics are ruined, but I didn't expect that after the remake of the four famous novels was complained by the audience, even the anti-Japanese drama "Bright Sword", which was regarded as a "masterpiece", was the same.
On December 18, 2011, Huang Zhizhong's version of "New Bright Sword" appeared on the screen, although the show claimed to create a different Li Yunlong, but who knew that not only did it not surpass the old version, but it was also very spicy.
Especially in the scene where Duan Peng sells grain in the new and old versions of "Bright Sword", the gap is really not too obvious, the old version is to create characters with heart, and the new version is to perfunctory the audience.
"Comparison of the new and old versions of "Bright Sword" Duan Peng carrying a sack"
The role of Duan Peng in "Bright Sword", I believe everyone should be familiar with it, he, like Wei Monk Zhang Dabiao and others, is the leader of Li Yunlong's war.
And the actor Duan Peng played in the old version of "Bright Sword", although he is very thin, he looks very strong.
But Duan Peng in "New Bright Sword", although his beard is also very tall, he gives people a sense of weakness.
Of course, this is not the most obvious point of the gap between Duan Peng in the new and old versions of "Bright Sword", and the scene of Duan Peng selling grain in the play is even more different.
For the plot of Duan Peng selling grain in "Bright Sword", many people must have watched it no less than three times, when Li Yunlong and Monk Wei went to the county seat to go to Chu Yunfei's appointment, Monk Wei happened to see the scene of Duan Peng selling grain.
At first, Li Yunlong didn't have any idea about Duan Peng, but Monk Wei, who had practiced martial arts, took a fancy to Duan Peng at a glance, and even proposed to Li Yunlong the idea of including him in the independent regiment.
And the reason why Monk Wei admired Duan Peng so much was because he saw that Duan Peng was able to carry a thick sack with one hand without much effort, and the weight of the sack was 200 catties at least.
In addition, Monk Wei also carefully saw the back of Duan Peng's blackened hand, and his intuition and experience of living in Shaolin Temple for many years told him that this person must have practiced iron sand palms, and ordinary people would not have this situation at all.
Later, when the camera showed Duan Peng, I saw that he first picked up a sack containing millet with one hand, and then picked up a sack with millet with both hands in the next second.
Although everyone knows that it is impossible for normal people to lift a sack weighing 200 pounds with one hand, and the sack in the play may only have some objects, the effect presented is extraordinarily realistic.
Through the lens, we can see that whether it is the sack in Duan Peng's hand or the sack placed on the ground, they are very bulging and realistic.
It can be said that even if the sack does not contain food, it must contain solid things such as sand or soil, at least it does not look perfunctory to the audience.
However, the effect of Duan Peng's grain sales in "New Bright Sword" is not on the same level as the old version of "Bright Sword", even if the plot and lines are copied correctly, even the props are so perfunctory.
In the shot, the new version of Duan Peng took down the sack of the rack car after selecting the venue, and when he picked up a sack with one hand, he noticed that the sack in Duan Peng's hand did not have a sense of thickness.
In addition, the size of the sack in the new version is still very small, nearly one-third less than the old version of the sack, and the overall look is still loose and baggy, without a feeling of bulging.
Although this is a film and television drama, we must at least make the props more realistic, and we can see from the lens that the sack in "New Bright Sword" is likely to contain objects such as foam.
This is not the end, and when the new version of Duan Peng picked up the two sacks in the next second, there was another shocking scene, because the sack in his left hand turned out to be empty.
Good guys, I originally thought that "New Bright Sword" would be perfunctory to the audience, but I didn't expect it to be not even perfunctory, and it was directly empty.
And through the scene of Duan Peng selling grain in the new and old versions of "Bright Sword", it is not difficult to see that in terms of detail processing, "New Bright Sword" and the old version of "Bright Sword" are too different.
"Comparison between the old and new versions of "Bright Sword" Duan Peng was kicked"
Not only that, but there is also a big gap between the effects of the new and old versions of "Bright Sword" Duan Peng in the plot where he was kicked to the ground by Zhao Gang, and "New Bright Sword" can be said to have no discipline at all.
In the clip "Bright Sword", when Li Yunlong led his troops to pursue the remnants of the Kuomintang, he happened to meet Chu Yunfei's 89th Division.
Seeing this situation, after the two sides said a few polite words, they launched a fierce firefight, which was also in response to Li Yunlong's sentence "When a chivalrous man meets, the brave wins."
But unexpectedly, both sides were prepared, Chu Yunfei was shot by Duan Peng as soon as he appeared, and Li Yunlong was injured by artillery shells.
Seeing that Li Yunlong was seriously injured and his life was in danger, Duan Peng didn't care about the overall battle situation, and after leaving some soldiers to continue to fight with the Kuomintang troops, he hurriedly led Li Yunlong to the field hospital.
After arriving at the field hospital, Duan Peng pushed people along the way, and was very anxious to find a hospital to treat Li Yunlong, and at this moment a Japanese doctor stood up.
At first, Duan Peng didn't think so, but after hearing that the other party was speaking Japanese and said that Li Yunlong's operation would not be 100% successful, he immediately became angry in his heart, took out a gun and was about to kill the other party.
Just when Duan Peng and the Japanese doctor were in a stalemate, fortunately, Zhao Gang rushed over, and after he saw Zhao Gang pointing a gun at the Japanese doctor, he directly kicked him to the ground.
It's just that what we need to pay attention to here is that none of the soldiers behind Duan Peng in the shot dared to move, they all lowered their heads and listened to Zhao Gang's words.
In fact, this point is very reasonable, you must know that Zhao Gang is their superior, and he has been the political commissar of these soldiers in the independent regiment before, so he will not act rashly in any way.
But this is not the case with "New Bright Sword", the same plot, when Zhao Gang arrived in time to kick Duan Peng aside, the other fighters hurriedly walked up to support each other.
This scene is really incomprehensible, after the superior kicked his subordinates, the soldiers of the subordinates dared to go up to help, which is too unusual.
Not only that, but when Zhao Gang gave a menacing lecture later, the soldiers behind Duan Peng were even more outrageous, and in the camera, they glared at Zhao Gang viciously one by one.
Should I say it or not, it is too unorganized and undisciplined to show such an expression in the face of the superior's lecture, you must know that these soldiers are not new recruits, but veterans of the independent regiment.
All in all, although so much money was spent on the filming of "New Bright Sword", it was all used in the wrong place, and it still cannot be compared with the old version of "Bright Sword" in terms of details.
Therefore, it is not difficult for us to see that the reason why the old version of "Bright Sword" has been popular for so many years is not without reason, except for the slightly deified plot, other aspects are really impeccable.