Before reading this article, I would like to thank you for your support by clicking "Follow", which is not only convenient for you to discuss and share, but also can bring you a different sense of participation!
---------------
If Liu Chan hadn't surrendered back then, would he have been able to avoid the demise of Shu Han?
In the years of the Three Kingdoms, Liu Chan, the last emperor of Shu Han, stood at the crossroads of history. The iron horses of the Wei State came like a tide, and the rivers and mountains of Shu Han were stormy. Faced with the choice of life and death, Liu Chan's heart is full of struggles and contradictions.
Chengdu, the capital of Shu Han, was besieged by the Wei army. On the city wall, Liu Chan looked at the war in the distance, and his heart was mixed. He knew very well that surrender meant that Shu Han's national throne would be cut off in his hands, and holding on seemed to be a path of no return to despair. However, deep down, he was not willing to give up the foundation that his ancestors had worked so hard to build.
At this critical moment, Liu Chan's heart surged with an unyielding fighting spirit. He convened hundreds of civil and military officials to discuss countermeasures. Although most people believed that surrender was a wise move, Liu Chan was adamant in his adherence to it. He knew very well that surrender would only plunge the people of Shu Han into deeper suffering, and holding on might win a glimmer of life for Shu Han.
In order to boost morale, Liu Chan personally inspected the city defense and shared weal and woe with the soldiers. He told the soldiers that as long as everyone worked together, there was no difficulty that could not be overcome. Inspired by him, the morale of the Shu Han soldiers was greatly boosted, and they swore to defend their homeland to the death, and fought to the death against the Wei army.
However, the brutality of war is far greater than you can imagine. The siege equipment of the Wei army poured down like a torrential rain, and the city defenses of Shu Han gradually collapsed under the onslaught of the Wei army. The soldiers fought bloodily, but suffered heavy casualties. Seeing that Chengdu was about to fall, Liu Chan's heart was full of despair.
At this critical moment, Liu Chan's personal guards persuaded him to surrender. The guards told him that continuing to resist would only make more soldiers die in vain, and that Shu Han's national strength had been exhausted and could no longer compete with Wei. However, Liu Chan resolutely did not agree to surrender. He believes that even if he can't change the direction of the war, he must fight to the end for the honor and dignity of Shu Han.
In the final decisive battle, Liu Chan led the remaining soldiers into a fierce battle with the Wei army. Although they were extremely brave, they were ultimately unable to withstand the powerful offensive of the Wei army. In the fierce battle, Liu Chan was seriously wounded and captured by the Wei army.
Liu Chan's surrender did not bring a turnaround for Shu Han. Under the rule of Wei, the people of Shu Han suffered even more deeply. And Liu Chan himself was also placed under house arrest and spent the rest of his life.
However, history did not end with Liu Chan's surrender. People began to reflect on this period of history, thinking about whether Shu Han would have been able to avoid the fate of extinction if Liu Chan had not surrendered back then.
Some people believe that if Liu Chan had not surrendered back then, Shu Han might have been able to continue to resist for a while. However, the state of Wei was strong, and in the end Shu Han was still difficult to resist. Moreover, the long-term war will only make Shu Han's national strength more exhausted and the people's lives more difficult. Therefore, surrender may be a reluctant option, but it is also an option to reduce casualties and suffering.
Some people also believe that if Liu Chan had not surrendered back then, he might have been able to stimulate the fighting spirit and potential of the Shu Han soldiers. In desperate situations, people tend to burst out with amazing power. If Liu Chan can lead the Shu Han soldiers to resist bravely, he may be able to create a miracle and turn the tide of the war.
However, history has no ifs. We can't change the facts of the past, but we can learn from this history. Although Liu Chan's surrender led Shu Han to its demise, it also showed us the cruelty and ruthlessness of the war. It reminds us that we need to remain calm and rational and make informed decisions in the face of strong enemies and adversities. At the same time, we should also cherish a peaceful and stable life and avoid war.
In this story, we see Liu Chan's helplessness and struggle. His surrender may have been a reluctant choice, but it also made us think about the relationship between war and peace, sacrifice and selfishness. So, if Liu Chan didn't surrender back then, would Shu Han be able to avoid the fate of extinction? There may not be a definitive answer to this question, but it provokes us to think deeply about history and human nature.