Text: Mr. Vanilla
sequence
Ding Taisheng has really had a headache these days, but he didn't expect to be scolded by netizens for criticizing Hailai Amu.
Even his black history has been ripped upside down.
Netizens showed no mercy to him, and there was a lot of scolding in the comment area.
But just yesterday, things took a dramatic turn.
Some netizens stood up to speak for Ding Taisheng, saying that he actually has his own artistic opinions.
It's just that the expression is more direct.
Some netizens said that although they didn't like Ding Taisheng.
But this scolding war was also too much.
Of course, among them, Rozette, a well-known Canadian vocal teacher, commented on Hailai Amu directly on the hot search.
Let's see what she has to say.
"Singer 2024" was exposed to revision? Rozette bluntly confessed that she had been deceived
On May 16, Rozette, a well-known Canadian vocal teacher, watched the premiere of "Singer 2024".
She usually comments on Chinese singers.
This time was no exception.
There is a small episode in the comments, when I heard Na Ying sing the sentence in "Mo" that sentences love to lifelong loneliness.
Rozette looked puzzled and listened three more times.
The assistant hurriedly explained, saying that Na Ying sang the wrong words.
I sang a sentence to a sentence.
But Rozette doesn't think so, she feels that her voice has been processed.
That is, the pronunciation.
This time, the assistant was not calm.
This is a live broadcast, how can it be repaired?
But Rozette was adamant, saying that the voice she heard was repaired.
Because I always thought that "Singer 2024" was a live broadcast.
So her evaluation is based on this premise.
Now that the premise is gone, she doesn't want to comment anymore.
Rozette as a professional vocal teacher.
I don't think I would say such things casually.
And the matter of repairing the sound can also be done during the live broadcast.
If "Singer 2024" is really exposed to a sound repair scandal.
That's embarrassing.
After all, this show has been popular for more than ten years, and if you deceive the audience for the ratings.
So what's the difference with a show like "The Voice of China"?
Rozette commented on Hailai Amu's song "Uncomfortable"
In videos up to 80 minutes long; He also commented on the song "Your Thousands of Rivers and Mountains" by Hailai Amu;
However, her opinion made netizens explode!
You must know that Rozette is a very famous vocal teacher on up;
She has commented on many big names in domestic entertainment, such as Tengger, Zhou Shen, and Lin Zhixuan.
"Your Thousands of Rivers, Thousands of Mountains" is Hailai Amu's signature song;
That tearing sound is his trademark. But Rozette said she didn't hear much resonance with the song;
Whether it's sound or emotion.
She feels that Hailai Amu is "keeping the sound of tearing" throughout the song, although this is rare, but is it really necessary?
Her assistant listened to it and said that the song sounded very earthy;
It reminded him of the hard-working Chinese people, and he felt very high.
But Rozette disagrees with this view because she doesn't understand the meaning of Chinese lyrics.
She thinks that mature singers use that kind of "clip sound" to create an atmosphere;
It's not about showing off or singing the whole song.
She doesn't understand why this love song should be sung so "uncomfortable", is this the true meaning of love?
But in the end, Rozette still saved some face for Hailai Amu;
said that his pitch is not bad, much better than Wang Sulong.
It seems that music really has its own opinions!
"Original Video Capture"
Loading...
Ding Taisheng commented on Hailai Amu: Crude or art?
Earlier, we talked about the evaluation of foreign vocal music teachers on Hailai Amu, and now let's listen to what Ding Taisheng has to say.
Ding Taisheng said in his video;
The "soil" he said does not refer to the earthy atmosphere or the turtles, nor does he mean that Hailai Amu is the people at the bottom.
He explained that "soil" actually means that the work appears crude, not advanced enough, and relatively low in artistic level.
And this "earth" corresponds not to "foreign", but to a higher and more accurate artistic expression.
This high level of artistic expression is related to talent, talent, and knowledge.
To put it simply, Ding Taisheng felt that Hailai Amu's songs were not art, they were crude and low-level.
But he also emphasized that this "soil" has nothing to do with Hailai Amu's personality.
So, is Hailai Amu's song dirty or not? Are we wrong to blame Ding Taisheng?
Actually, the question is quite simple. music that ordinary people like;
There is not only that elegant spring and white snow, but also the down-to-earth lower riba people.
There are 1.4 billion people in China, many of whom are farmers or people living at the bottom.
This kind of "lower riba" music is more likely to get their support.
Therefore, even if Hailai Amu's songs are said to be "earthy", even if his works are not favored by some people, more than 19 million people still like him and follow him.
And those works that are called art tend to have a less wide audience, because they may be detached from the lives of ordinary people.
It doesn't matter who is suitable for Hailai Amu's songs, the important thing is that someone likes and supports it.
As for whether he will pursue higher artistic attainments in the future, then we will wait and see!
Netizens have different opinions
When it comes to Hailai Amu, the social platform explodes.
Netizens have their own opinions.
Some people say that Hailai Amu has an ordinary voice, but he can write songs and compose music.
It is a talent, and it is very popular with young people.
Some people also say that Hailai Amu and Gao Jin are like a new generation of Daolang, but they are always excluded in the music industry.
Some netizens think.
Modern pop music is played by Europeans and Americans, but it is not difficult to admit that others are excellent.
Some people also think that Hailai Amu is already at the master level, and he doesn't need to participate in small competitions to be judged.
Daolang and Amu.
They are all good singers liked by the people.
Some netizens even said that if Amu is a fifth-dan player.
That Dao Lang is definitely a master of the super ninth rank.
Ding Taisheng also spoke, saying that Hailai Amu is not suitable for the singer stage.
More suitable for short videos on Douyin.
But netizens retorted that although it sounds a little crowded for their amateur self.
But I still want to squeeze him into the Spring Festival Gala.
This discussion about Hailai Amu's singing method is really interesting.
We often judge singers by their musical skills and the beauty of their voices.
But the influence of music and singers goes far beyond the stage.
Hailai Amu's unique style is loved by many people, and not only because of his musical skills.
And because his music touches people's hearts.
It could be because of the lyrics, personal stories, or the emotions and attitudes conveyed in the music.
These are socio-cultural factors.
Critical to the success of an artist.