The two words "three vulgar and elegant" can completely describe the controversy caused by Hailai Amu in recent times, because of the appearance of "I Am a Singer 2024", Hailai Amu's singing skills were "spicy" by Ding Taisheng, and it was reasonable to reprimand his singing voice was too earthy, and it was reasonable to be at the bottom.
This evaluation can be described as a stone that stirs up a thousand waves, Ding Taisheng's sharp comments are for traffic or insight, I believe that everyone's opinion is different, the so-called music review is from their own point of view or from a professional point of view or from the audience's point of view, in fact, there are problems, and the evaluation itself is an act that is very easy to cause disputes, because it is unfair to stand from any angle.
With the further fermentation of the incident, the well-known Internet celebrities Xiao Yang and Xu Huasheng have commented on it, the same feelings, the same experience, maybe their words can represent the public's opinions. After all, evaluating the level of a singer cannot be dismantled from a single direction.
On May 13th, Brother Xiao Yang said in Hailai Amu's latest video message: Radish and green vegetables are all loved, the world is so big, do you want to ensure that everyone likes it? Loved by every age? If you don't like it, you don't listen, if you like it, you listen.
Everyone has the right to like it, and I don't evaluate whether the song is good or not, but there are many people around me who listen to it, I can't say that they are dirty, really, I think he is very hard-working, very humble, a grassroots singer, maybe he doesn't have too many professional skills, but he has a heart to fight for his dreams, which is worth learning......
Simple words not only express their own thoughts, but also take the matter in another direction, as mentioned at the beginning, whether it is vulgar or elegant, as long as it can bring good effect and achieve the meaning of the song itself, then it can be called perfect.
Isn't the so-called rural-urban interface an attack on the masses? How many of us in China are urban people? How many people are from the urban-rural area, this is clearly a personal attack, and the evaluation of the song has gone beyond fairness and has risen to the so-called personal insult.
In the face of Ding Taisheng's views, Hailai Amu responded twice, the first time said: I also accept the soil, there are thousands of types of music, and what I express is true feelings, maybe my songs are not high-pressure enough, but it is enough to move people's hearts.......
Yes, how many songs can move people with those so-called elegance? Is the so-called elegance accessible to ordinary people? Rather than standing on a high place and being cold, it is really better to take root in the countryside and have more fun.
In response to Brother Xiao Yang's support, Hailai Amu responded: I don't quite understand how to distinguish between elegance and vulgarity, but I can coexist with doubts and ridicule, and I will be my own.
Such a response can be described as very emotionally intelligent, not only did not refute Ding Taisheng's face, but also expressed his dissatisfaction well and accepted the so-called "criticism".
Subsequently, Xu Huasheng also said: What is soil? What is noble, singing resonance, singing heart, this is what we ordinary people want to hear.
Yes, a song can't move people, so no matter how elegant it is, what's the point? The so-called melody can't resonate, can it be called elegant? It can only be said that the opinions are different.
The audience for music is for all of humanity, not for "all artists" or "all judges".