In 1979, a sudden war broke out on the border between China and Vietnam. Although the conflict, known as the self-defense counterattack war against Vietnam, lasted less than a month, its consequences and impact were far-reaching and complex. As the smoke of the war dissipated, the situation in Vietnam and the outside world changed dramatically, especially for Vietnam, which was not only a military challenge, but also a profound national disaster.
The cost of war is severe. The death toll in Vietnam is close to 110,000, and this number is not just a cold statistic, it represents the shattering of countless families, the shattering of dreams, and the suffering of the country. But death and pain are only the beginning of the story.
The background of the self-defense counterattack against Vietnam
In 1979, as tensions escalated along the Sino-Vietnamese border, the Chinese government decided to retaliate against Vietnam in self-defense, in response to Vietnam's border intrusions and excessive regional ambitions. On February 17, the Chinese People's Liberation Army crossed the border, marking the official start of the self-defense counterattack against Vietnam. The decision was made against the backdrop of Vietnam's deepening intervention in the Cambodian conflict, as well as harassment of China's southern border areas. China's actions are intended to send a clear signal that it will not tolerate any threat to national sovereignty and territorial integrity.
In just one month, the Chinese People's Liberation Army mobilized hundreds of thousands of troops, involving multi-arm joint operations, which was extremely rare in the international environment at that time. The PLA acted swiftly and forcefully, penetrating deep into the northern regions of Vietnam, destroying several important strongholds of the Vietnamese army. The tactics and tactics used by the Chinese military demonstrate its military strength and organizational capabilities, especially in the face of mountainous operations with complex terrain.
The Chinese army's offensive, although rapid, did not intend to occupy Vietnamese territory or overthrow the Vietnamese government for long. The purpose of the war was to "teach Vietnam" a "lesson" and force it to reconsider its attitude and policy towards China and its neighbors. The decision to withdraw in March reflects this strategic intent in China, which the Chinese leadership hopes to use this short but forceful military operation to make Vietnam understand the cost of its regional ambitions and prompt it to revise its foreign policy.
As a direct result of the war, the Vietnamese military and political leadership had to reassess its tactics towards China, as well as for Southeast Asia as a whole. Vietnam's dream of becoming the world's third power was shattered by the war, a concept that was widely promoted by the Vietnamese leadership before the war with the intention of establishing Vietnam's leadership in the region. But the war demonstrated Vietnam's huge military, economic, and political disparity with China, forcing the Vietnamese government to rethink deeply about its foreign policy and regional ambitions.
Lessons of the war for China
While China has achieved clear tactical victories on the battlefield, it also faces a number of internal challenges. The war was not only a military response to Vietnam, but also an important test of China's military system and tactical capabilities. Although the war was short, it had a far-reaching impact on China's military strategy.
First, the war exposed some flaws in the organizational structure of the Chinese military. The lack of a clear system of military ranks has caused a lot of confusion in the mobilization and deployment process. On the battlefield, the chain of command between commanders and soldiers is not clear enough, which affects the rapid reaction capability and operational efficiency of the troops. This institutional inadequacy poses a major challenge for the army in organizing large-scale operations on an ad hoc basis.
Second, the issue of equipment has also become a conspicuous shortcoming in warfare. In particular, the lack of sufficient armored transport vehicles, which directly affected the mobility and flexibility of the troops. Faced with Vietnam's complex and varied terrain, the Chinese army was unable to quickly adjust its position and tactical arrangement, and sometimes even relied on the primitive way of infantry carrying tanks to move. This lack of equipment has limited the combat capability and tactical diversity of the Chinese army to a certain extent.
In addition, the brutality of war is also on full display in this conflict. The Chinese army lost nearly 7,000 soldiers in the war, and many more were wounded. This figure highlights the brutality of the war and the enormous attrition of personnel. Despite the high level of courage and sacrifice shown by the Chinese army in the face of difficulties, it also made the military leadership aware of the importance of improving combat efficiency and reducing casualties.
However, in the test of this war, the Chinese army has also given birth to a number of outstanding military talents. After experiencing the baptism of actual combat, these talents have gained valuable experience in strategic understanding, tactical application, command and coordination, and so on. Many of them later became the backbone of China's military reform and construction, contributing to the modernization of China's armed forces.
Faced with the problems exposed by the war, China's military leadership embarked on a series of profound reforms. The establishment and improvement of the military rank system has become one of the focuses of the reform, aiming to solve the problem of confusion in the chain of command and clarify the responsibilities and chain of command between officers and soldiers. At the same time, upgrading equipment has also been put on the agenda, especially strengthening the research and development and procurement of key equipment such as armored transport vehicles, so as to improve the mobility and rapid reaction capability of the troops.
Heavy losses for Vietnam
Vietnam suffered heavy losses in this war, with nearly 110,000 dead and wounded, which seriously weakened Vietnam's national and military strength, which had a long-term negative impact on its national development. After the Vietnam War, the already severely depleted human resources were hit again by this short but fierce war, resulting in an extreme shortage of labor. The war, which followed the Vietnam War, made matters worse for an already exhausted country.
During the Vietnam War, millions of young men from North and South Vietnam were drafted into the army, and many failed to return from the battlefield. This demographic loss was further exacerbated by the war of self-defense and counterattack against Vietnam, which led to severe damage to an important pillar of Vietnamese society and economy. The shortage of labor has led to a significant decline in agricultural production, and large areas of farmland have been abandoned and uncultivated, which has directly affected Vietnam's food production capacity. In the process of post-war reconstruction, Vietnam had to face this challenge and try to find a solution.
In addition, Vietnam's industrial development also encountered serious difficulties due to the loss of a large number of male laborers in the war. Many factories have shut down due to a lack of workers, and even some infrastructure reconstruction projects have been hampered by lack of manpower. This has largely slowed Vietnam's post-war economic recovery, making it even more difficult for an already fragile economic system to withstand the pressure.
To make matters worse, in the mid-eighties, there was a massive famine in Vietnam, which was largely triggered by labor shortages and reduced agricultural productivity due to the war. With thousands of Vietnamese starving to death due to food shortages, this humanitarian crisis further highlights the devastating impact of war on Vietnamese society and economy.
In the self-defense counterattack against Vietnam, Vietnam's military strength also suffered heavy losses. Vietnam has not only lost a large number of soldiers, but also suffered great damage to its military equipment. This left Vietnam with serious defense and security challenges after the war.
The total stagnation of economic development
The industrial system in northern Vietnam has suffered a catastrophic blow, which has had a long-term negative impact on Vietnam's economic development. During the war, in order to weaken Vietnam's military capabilities and economic base, many industrial facilities and infrastructure were systematically destroyed. The destruction of these facilities has not only affected Viet Nam's production capacity in the short term, but has also hindered its economic recovery and development in the long term.
In northern Vietnam in particular, the industrial system that had been built up over the years had been almost completely destroyed. Critical mineral extraction and processing facilities have been severely damaged, resulting in the loss of Vietnam's ability to exploit some key resources. In addition, the aid provided by China before the war, including food and medical supplies, was massively relocated at the time of the withdrawal. Equipment and buildings that could not be removed due to time constraints were often damaged. This not only means that Vietnam has lost vital resources for economic recovery, but it also means that additional time and money are needed to rebuild these infrastructures.
After the war, the economic development of northern Vietnam was struggling. The loss of industrial productive capacity has led to an increase in unemployment and a decline in living standards. Many regions that once relied on industrial production are facing a near-total stagnation of economic activity. This situation is undoubtedly worse for Vietnam, which has already suffered a serious loss of human resources. Despite the Government's efforts to rebuild, the recovery process has been slow and difficult due to a lack of financial, technical and human resources.
In addition, the war of self-defense and counterattack against Vietnam has led to long-term tensions between Vietnam and the international community, especially with China. The war not only destroyed the friendly relations between the two sides for many years, but also affected Vietnam's position in the international arena. As Vietnam struggles to restore its economic and military strength, it also faces the dual challenge of rebuilding international credibility and relations.
Decades after the end of the war, many parts of northern Vietnam still have not been able to fully shake off the shadow of the war. The reconstruction of industrial facilities and the recovery of the economy require long-term efforts and international assistance.
The long-term impact of Sino-Vietnamese relations
After the war of self-defense and counterattack against Vietnam, Vietnam's international status and foreign policy underwent a remarkable transformation. The war not only had a profound impact on Vietnam's domestic politics and economy, but it also fundamentally changed its behavior and positioning in the international arena. In particular, with the weakening of the Soviet Union in the late eighties, Vietnam lost one of its most important international supporters, which forced Vietnam to reassess and adjust its diplomatic strategy, especially in its relations with China and other Southeast Asian countries.
Vietnam, with Soviet support, had tried to expand its influence in Southeast Asia, including military involvement in Cambodia and ambitions to establish a federation of Indochina. However, the decline of the Soviet Union and the defeat of the self-defense counterattack against Vietnam forced Vietnam to face new realities of international relations. The inability of the Soviet Union to continue to provide sufficient economic and military support posed a huge challenge to Vietnam's defense and economic development. As a result, Vietnam was forced to withdraw its troops from Cambodia, ending its long-term military occupation of the country.
Faced with the new international environment, Vietnam began to adjust its diplomatic strategy, seeking to improve relations with its neighbors such as China. In the late eighties and early nineties, Vietnam actively sought to restore and improve bilateral relations with China, which marked a major shift in Vietnam's foreign policy. The Vietnamese government realized that in order to ensure the stability and development of the country, it must abandon its confrontational foreign policy and seek peaceful coexistence with neighboring countries, especially China.
Vietnam had dreamed of becoming a dominant force in Southeast Asia through military and political means, but the war and subsequent changes in the international environment made Vietnam realize that its strength and resources were far from able to support this ambition. As a result, Vietnam began to seek to guarantee its national security and economic development through diplomatic means and international cooperation, rather than through military expansion and regional hegemony.
Over time, relations between Vietnam and China have gradually improved and developed. The two countries have made some progress in resolving problems left over from history and promoting economic and cultural exchanges. The normalization of such relations is not only conducive to the long-term peace and development of the two countries, but also contributes to the stability and prosperity of the entire Southeast Asian region. Vietnam's foreign policy adjustment and practice have proved that resolving differences and common development through dialogue and cooperation is a more effective and sustainable path for the development of international relations.
The impact of Vietnam's comprehensive diplomatic strategy on the settlement of disputes in the South China Sea and China's countermeasures[J].South China Sea Journal,2023,9(2):30-41.)