1, everyone is scolding Huang Qishan, but scolding the wrong person!
After the end of this year's Spring Festival Gala, as expected, there was another wave of complaints.
Some people say that Yue Yunpeng's cross talk is not funny, some people say that Shen Teng's sketches are too crotch-pulling, and some people complain that Bai Jingting grabbed the C position, and even derived the so-called "Chunshan Learning".
Of course, the most scolded and controversial has to be the ending song "Unforgettable Tonight" sung by Huang Qishan!
Although I belong to the same woman, I don't protect my shortcomings.
Objectively speaking, Huang Qishan's "Unforgettable Tonight" is really not good, and some netizens even used 8 words to describe it: shaking your head and shaking your head, grinning your teeth!
The song is not good, and the people are not good-looking!
was originally a powerful singer, and asked her to sing this lyrical and gentle song, which did not give full play to her advantages, but completely magnified her shortcomings. Being scolded doesn't seem to be a problem.
But no one found a core problem, that is: the unforgettable tonight's interpretation is indeed a failure, but the biggest pot is not in Huang Qishan, but in the director team!
Everyone scolded the wrong person!
2. Why does the biggest pot lie in the director team?
The failure of this deduction is simply a superposition of 2 mistakes: inviting the wrong person and singing the wrong song!
But is this Huang Qishan's problem? No! This is the director's problem!
Last year, Huang Qishan also went to the Spring Festival Gala, she and Xilina Yigao sang a lyrical song "It's a Mother, It's a Daughter", isn't it rave reviews?
Why was Huang Qishan scolded after a year?
To put it bluntly, it's because you made her sing a song that is not suitable for her!
Because Huang Qishan is not suitable for singing this song!
The original singer Li Guyi is gentle and lyrical, full of aura, and this song has been sung for 40 years and has become a symbol of the Spring Festival Gala.
In this case, even if you make a substitution, you can only change someone with a similar style. To put it simply, you have to change to a beautiful one with a similar voice!
The result?
You just found a powerful singer Huang Qishan who is known for her high voice, but she doesn't dare to compliment her appearance, and you also adapted the song, so it's no wonder that you don't be scolded!
What Huang Qishan looks like, what kind of strength she is, and what kind of songs she is suitable for singing, the director team of the Spring Festival Gala should have understood it in advance.
You can ask her to perform, and last year was a good example.
But it would be a mistake to ask her to sing an unforgettable tonight! The song was also adapted, which is a mistake on top of a mistake!
Therefore, the biggest pot belongs to the director team, not Huang Qishan herself.
Imagine, if the director team of the Spring Festival Gala came to you and asked you to sing Unforgettable Tonight, which singer would refuse? What a good opportunity to show your face?
And if you refuse, doesn't it seem like you don't know how to lift?
Besides, Wong Yee Shan sang an unforgettable tonight after several rehearsals. The director team has seen the previous presentation effect, but they have not adjusted it, indicating that they do not feel that there is a problem.
This is the scene of the accident during the live broadcast!
So the biggest pot is indeed the director's team!
3. Two lessons that can be learned
This incident also teaches us two lessons:
First, for classics, don't adapt them without authorization.
It's not easy to do, the success rate is very low, and it's easy to fail if you're not careful.
Second, powerful singers can't sing any song!
Huang Qishan is a powerful person. But you asked Huang Qishan to sing Yang Yuying's "Let Me Tell You Gently", do you think it's appropriate?