Students, meet again!
Today, the big teacher will talk about how to buy "Le Yi Theory"
The rough stone of the jasper version of the "Thirteen Elements of Roselle Endowment" was found in the Ming Dynasty and is recognized as the best version of the "Thirteen Elements of Roselle Endowment", while the "Treatise on Le Yi" is not so lucky.
The version of le yi does not have a particularly recognized "best version", so when selecting a version, the rounded and non-obvious decorative characteristics of Wei Jin Xiaokai mentioned in the previous article have become one of the most important criteria.
The "Treatise on Le Yi", which is now handed down, is a facsimile. Famous people, the Southern Song Dynasty has Yuezhou Shi Bangzhe's "Yuezhou ShiShi Thesis" (now in The National Museum of Tokyo, Japan), the Ming Dynasty Has Wen's "Stop Cloud Pavilion Thesis" ben, Chen Wei's "Yuyantang Ti" ben, Wu Ting's "Yu Qing Zhai Ti" ben (now in the Palace Museum in Beijing), Wang Kentang's "Yugang Zhai Ti" ben, the Qing Dynasty Has Feng Quan's "Kuaixuetang Ti" ben, etc., generally believe that the "Yuezhou Shi Shi Ben" is better, but there are missing characters.
In addition to the above version, in the 2018 Jiade Autumn Auction, an Siyuan's eleven kinds of rare book inscriptions were auctioned for nearly 200 million, of which the third "Song Tuojin Tang Xiaokai" and the second is "Le Yi Theory".
This post is proofread with Li Zonghan's Collection of Yuezhou Shi's Ben, and seems to have been translated from the Yuezhou Shi's Ben, but because of the subtlety of Gle, it is also a good model for learning and research. App is not tired of calligraphy and the lecture notes given in our system small class are also in this version.
Seeing this, I believe that many small whites are blinded, according to the above version to a treasure to search, nothing can be found! That's because when the publishing house publishes the post, it doesn't necessarily choose which version, and we generally can only search for the publishing house, and we can't search for which version, so the problem is... How to choose?
If you want to save trouble, it is still recommended that the Zhejiang People's Fine Arts Publishing House's "Five Kinds of Xiao Kai Le Yi Theory", which lists the Yuezhou Shi Shi Ben, the Xiang Yuan Bian Tibetan Ben, the Zhang Yanji Tibetan Ben, the Yu He Lin Ben, and the Feng Wen Wei Lin Ben together, which is suitable for everyone to compare and study.
In addition, the Ansiyuan Tibetan Song Tuoben and Yuezhou Shiben recommended by the great teacher are not very good to buy high-quality and inexpensive distributions, especially the Ansiyuan Tibetan Edition, which is clear and clear, the strokes are round and not bloated, and it is very suitable for learning, which is a pity that there is no single book published at present. However, this version of the online high-definition image is still a lot, you can download and print.
2018 · Jiade Daguan · Ancient Books Rare Book Golden Stone Stele Catalogue
In addition to the Ansi Yuanben, the Great Teacher also recommended the Yuezhou Shi Ben. In addition to being selected in the above-mentioned Zhejiang People's Fine Arts Publishing House's "Five Kinds of Xiao Kai Le Yi", this edition has also been selected by the Japanese Erxuan Society's Famous Writings Series 79 "Eleven Kinds of Jin Tang Xiao Kai" and the Japanese Ordinary Society's "Song Tuo Jin Ti Five Kinds". (Also in the Japanese Erxuanshe Calligraphy Series Series, the 96th "Wei Jin Xiaokai Collection" is selected from the Yu Qingzhai Ben).)
However, comparing these two books, it can be found that the ordinary society that is still expensive is more clear (although they are all Yuezhou Shishiben, the time of Tuo is not the same as that of The Extension).
The picture on the left is the famous handwriting of the Erxuan Society, and the picture on the right is the Ordinary Society
In view of the fact that it is not easy to buy, the big teacher also gives the electronic version to everyone
Koshishu Ishijimoto
In addition to not being easy to buy, the Yuezhou Shi ben and the An Si yuan ben also have a common feature - the first page is missing words. But everyone must still be clear, the choice of words is not necessarily the clearest is the best, "Roselle Endowment Thirteen Elements" and "Le Yi Theory" are examples.
After saying the recommended (sorry again, it is not easy to buy), let's talk about the version that is more common on the market, but it has not been recommended by the big teacher
1. Duoyun Xuanzang Song Tuoben
/
Shanghai Calligraphy and Painting Publishing House "Wang Xi's King Dedication of Xiao Kai"
❌
Although this book is not like the Yuezhou Shi Ben and An Si Yuan Ben lack words, the Tuoben strokes are relatively bloated, and the horizontal closing point is sometimes obvious by pressing the traces, so it is not recommended.
Yuezhou Shi Ben VS Duo Yun Xuan Tibetan Song Tuo Ben
2. Collections of the National Library of China
\
Xiling Printing Society's "Jin Tang Xiaokai Collection"
Jiangxi Fine Arts Publishing House", "Selected Works of Wang Xizhi and Wang Xianzhi xiaokai of the Eastern Jin Dynasty"
The first page of this book is not short of words, and the engraving is not bloated, but the front and back of the strokes are slightly more decorative, and it seems to be slightly more influenced by Tang Kai, so it is not recommended.
And Yuezhou Shi Ben VS National Library Collection
3. Yu Qing Zhai Ben
Erxuanshe Chinese Law Book Selection 11 "Wei Jintang Xiaokai Collection"
Erxuanshe Calligraphy Series 96 "Wei Jin Xiaokai Collection"
Yu Qingzhai is stored in the Palace Museum in Beijing, this version of the strokes are light and thin, the overall weathering is more serious, so it is not recommended.
Mr. Koshishu-Ishimoto VS Yosei Komoto
4. Stop Cloud Pavilion Post
This version can be searched for high-definition pictures on the Internet, compared with the Shanghai Calligraphy and Painting Publishing House's "Wang Xi's King Of Dedication to Xiao Kai", which seems to be from the same base; and compared with the "Thirteen Kinds of Jin and Tang Xiaokai" on the official website of the Palace Museum in Beijing, it seems that it is also from the same base. Some of the strokes in this book are more square and hard, which are different from the Wei and Jin styles, so they are not recommended.
Four comparisons: Yuezhou Shishiben, Shanghai Publishing House, Forbidden City Net Map, and ShuyunGuan
5, Song Tuo excellent ben
Erxuanshe Primary Color Fa Thesis Selection 26 "Wei Jintang Xiaokai Collection"
The specific version of this book is not clear, because it is different from other versions seen, so it is listed separately. This small, rounded stroke can also be used as a learning model.
Yuezhou Shi Ben VS Song Tuo Excellent Ben
6. Secret Cabinet Book
Japanese Kiyoyado "Three Kinds of Music"
The three types of "On the Theory of Le Yi" published by Kiyoyado in Japan selected the more famous secret cabinet books. However, the strokes of the Secret Cabinet are more serious, and some strokes are too thin and the weathering is more serious, so it is not recommended.
Mr. Koshishu Osamoto VS Himotomoto
7. Shen Bingcheng "Flounder Yanlu" old collection
Japan QingYa tang "Thirteen Kinds of Jin Tang Xiaokai"
At present, this book can only be found in the qingyatang publishing of the small kai collection "Thirteen Kinds of Jin Tang Xiao Kai". This version is also more severely broken, with relatively blurry strokes. The prints published by Qingyatang are more expensive than those of ordinary people because of the large print volume, but the printing volume of this book is small, so today, more than thirty years after publication, the price of this book has exceeded 4,000 yuan.
Yuezhou Shishi VS Flounder Yanlu Old Collection
In summary, for the version of "Le Yi Theory", either choose the "Five Kinds of Xiao Kai Le Yi Theory" of Zhejiang People's Fine Arts Publishing House, or download the electronic version of Yuezhou Shi's ben to print and learn by yourself
Well, this issue recommends the version of "Le Yi Theory" to end first, if you think it is useful, everyone enthusiastically leaves a message! The next issue of Da Ning teacher will arrange the "Declaration Table" for everyone, then we will not see or disperse in the next issue! ～