laitimes

Whether Wong Kar-wai's "Flowers" can surpass the Shanghainese version of "Debts" depends on whether it can cross these two hurdles

author:Reading drama discernment

With the upcoming broadcast of the TV series "Flowers" tonight, especially the cast of Shanghainese people and the launch of the Shanghainese version, it has aroused a lot of attention and discussion, and also filled the audience's expectations.

Whether Wong Kar-wai's "Flowers" can surpass the Shanghainese version of "Debts" depends on whether it can cross these two hurdles

In recent years, Shanghai-themed TV dramas have emerged in an endless stream, and excellent works have continued, but there are very few Shanghainese speakers, and the only one that counts is "Debt of Sin" in 1994.

Whether Wong Kar-wai's "Flowers" can surpass the Shanghainese version of "Debts" depends on whether it can cross these two hurdles

The play is adapted from Ye Xin's novel of the same name, directed by Huang Shuqin, starring Zhao Youliang, Yan Xiaopin, etc., and tells the story of 5 educated young children who travel thousands of miles from Yunnan to Shanghai to find their father and mother.

Whether Wong Kar-wai's "Flowers" can surpass the Shanghainese version of "Debts" depends on whether it can cross these two hurdles

Because of the Shanghainese lines and tear-jerking plot, "Sin Debt" triggered a craze of thousands of empty alleys as soon as it was broadcast, and even set a rating of 42.62%, with a Douban score of 8.5 now, becoming a popular on-screen talk.

Whether Wong Kar-wai's "Flowers" can surpass the Shanghainese version of "Debts" depends on whether it can cross these two hurdles

Nearly 30 years have passed, and when another "Flowers" focusing on Shanghai alleys will meet the audience immediately, the once familiar memories began to permeate the city, triggering a wave of memories at the same time, but also making many netizens involuntarily compare it with "Sin Debt", looking forward to recreating the grand occasion of the year.

Whether Wong Kar-wai's "Flowers" can surpass the Shanghainese version of "Debts" depends on whether it can cross these two hurdles

Compared with "Debt of Sin", "Flowers" is adapted from Jin Yucheng's novel of the same name that won the Mao Dun Literature Award, directed by the famous Wong Kar-wai, and the actors include Hu Ge, Ma Yili, Tang Yan and other powerful stars, both the original work and the main creative team are not inferior, but it is not easy to reach the height of the former, and there are at least two obstacles to overcome.

Whether Wong Kar-wai's "Flowers" can surpass the Shanghainese version of "Debts" depends on whether it can cross these two hurdles

The first is whether the story adaptation can resonate

The reason why "Sin Debt" is so popular and praised is that the plot coincides with the background of the times when educated youths return to the city, and the twists and turns of the fate of the five children affect people's hearts, and their deeds of finding their parents have aroused strong resonance.

Whether Wong Kar-wai's "Flowers" can surpass the Shanghainese version of "Debts" depends on whether it can cross these two hurdles

At this point, "Flowers" does not have an advantage. This drama is not filmed according to the content of the original novel, but takes Po as the main line, and extracts a part of it for expansion and extension, focusing on the two years of the 60s and 90s, lacking the general environment that resonates with the current era.

Whether Wong Kar-wai's "Flowers" can surpass the Shanghainese version of "Debts" depends on whether it can cross these two hurdles

This is a big challenge for the skills of the screenwriter and director, who need to find the common joys and sorrows in the gap between time and space, give the characters an arc light with the atmosphere of alley and pyrotechnics, and provide the audience with a remote control that touches the soft strings of the heart.

Whether Wong Kar-wai's "Flowers" can surpass the Shanghainese version of "Debts" depends on whether it can cross these two hurdles

The second is whether the actor gives the character a soul

The actors are another highlight of "Sin Debt", regardless of the protagonist or supporting role, each character is vivid, in line with the role positioning, and the performance is real and simple, fresh and natural, with a strong sense of substitution, which instantly pulls the audience back to that vigorous and innocent era.

Whether Wong Kar-wai's "Flowers" can surpass the Shanghainese version of "Debts" depends on whether it can cross these two hurdles

From the current point of view, the casting of "Flowers" can be regarded as attentive, inviting Hu Ge, Ma Yili, Tang Yan, Chen Long, Zheng Kai, Wu Yue, A Qing, Jiang Yilei, Fan Xiangyan, Tong Chenjie, Wang Ju and other Shanghai actors with different characteristics, but I don't know how the actual performance in the play is.

Whether Wong Kar-wai's "Flowers" can surpass the Shanghainese version of "Debts" depends on whether it can cross these two hurdles

If you take the presentation of stills and trailers as the basis, it feels like it has the taste and texture of that era, but in the end, it still depends on whether the interpretation of the character's personality, emotions and heart is accurate, and whether the character can be flesh and blood and truly stand up.

Whether Wong Kar-wai's "Flowers" can surpass the Shanghainese version of "Debts" depends on whether it can cross these two hurdles

Of course, whether a drama can be a big hit, in addition to the plot and acting skills, is also closely related to luck.

is the so-called time and fate, for example, "Debt of Sin" has an advantage that "Flowers" can't compare, that is, the background of the times.

Whether Wong Kar-wai's "Flowers" can surpass the Shanghainese version of "Debts" depends on whether it can cross these two hurdles

In the 90s, there was no Internet, no computers, no smartphones, and watching TV was the most important and fashionable leisure and entertainment activity in the whole society.

Nowadays, with the rise of mobile phone Internet, self-media, short videos, live broadcasts, etc., people's entertainment and leisure time are varied, and people's time for TV is decreasing.

Whether Wong Kar-wai's "Flowers" can surpass the Shanghainese version of "Debts" depends on whether it can cross these two hurdles

However, excellent works will never be ignored, and although today's audiences are more critical and strict, they never hesitate to send praise and applause to film and television masterpieces.

Whether Wong Kar-wai's "Flowers" can surpass the Shanghainese version of "Debts" depends on whether it can cross these two hurdles

I hope that "Flowers" can open the second spring of Shanghainese TV dramas.

#文章首发挑战赛#