Say it at the front
Looking for loopholes in "The Condor Heroes" is not to belittle Jin Yong
——
Martial arts novels are fictional literature, and they are making up stories, since they are made up, there will definitely be loopholes, but the loopholes in Jin Yong's "The Legend of the Condor Heroes" are very interesting, but it must be stated that finding the problems in Jin Yong's works is not to belittle Jin Yong, but to revisit Jin Yong's martial arts classics in another way, and interact with your chivalrous friends.
So don't think that the editor is picking bones in the egg and is full, the editor is just providing you with another way to read the classics, so there will be certain loopholes, but don't be angry, let alone serious, because if you are serious, you will lose.
Here's the point
What are the loopholes in Jin Yong's "The Condor Heroes".
——
1, Qiu Qianqi eats dates every day at the bottom of the valley of despair, how does she drink water and deal with personal hygiene?
Sometimes martial arts really write wherever they want, and they don't have to consider the Xi of ordinary people at all, so Qiu Qianqi's legs are disabled at the bottom of the desperate valley, and she relies on launching date cores from her mouth to obtain food, but how does she drink water? Jin Yong did not write this, and the reader did not delve into it, in fact, as long as he studied deeply, he would feel that this point was too unreasonable.
2, Guo Jing and the heroes guarded Xiangyang together, but why didn't Hong Qigong, known as the righteous hero, come?
Hong Qigong is the most righteous chivalrous man in Jin Yong's pen, although he is in the beggar gang, he can contribute to the country of the Great Song Dynasty, but the problem is here, Guo Jing guarded Xiangyang for so long, and in the end, even Huang Yaoshi and Ke Zhenwei came to help, but Hong Qigong never helped Guo Jing before fighting Ouyang Feng, could it be that he really didn't care about anything after he retired?
3. After Darba won Yang Guo's "Soul Transfer Dafa", he has been calling Yang Guo Senior Brother.
This section is particularly interesting, at the scene of the competition in Xiangyang, because Yang Guo performed the "Soul Transfer Dafa" on Darba, and Darba has been calling Yang Guo Senior Brother since then.
4, Master Yideng, Zhou Botong, and Aunt Ying finally met in Huashan, aren't the three of them embarrassed?
From a practical point of view, this article really can't be regarded as a problem, but it makes people feel a little embarrassed, even if Master Yideng Buddhism is profound, but when he meets Zhou Botong and Yinggu, how can there not be a trace of embarrassment? Jin Yong did not write this point, but the reader can really feel uncomfortable.
5, Guo Jing took Yang Guo to Quanzhen to teach art, how could there be so many veterans in the middle who didn't recognize Guo Jing?
Don't forget, Guo Jing has fought against Qiu Qianren and Ouyang Feng in Chongyang Palace, so there should be many people who know Guo Jing, but the problem is that he hasn't seen him for a few years, when Guo Jing went to Chongyang Palace again, he was mistaken for a Mongolian villain, and no one in the Chongyang Palace recognized Guo Jing, hasn't it been a few years, is the enrollment of Chongyang Palace so successful?
6. There is a stone tablet at the foot of Chongyang Palace Mountain, and the inscription is a poem written by Qiu Chuji about the beauty of Xiaolongnu, what is this bull nose thinking in his heart?
Is this setting directly satirizing the immortality of the old Taoist of the Quanzhen Sect? What kind of mentality did this Qiu Chu have to write such words? Could it be that Jin Yong was satirizing the Quanzhen Sect that "the upper beam is not right and the lower beam is crooked," so that a rapist like Yin Zhiping will appear?
7, Yang Guo misbehaved in the book, and provoked many women successively, which is too much.
Yang Guo has always been a peach blossom in "The Condor Heroes", like Lu Wushuang, Cheng Ying, Wan Yanping, Gongsun Lucalyx, Guo Fu, Guo Xiang, as well as Uncle Li Mochou and fellow sister Hong Lingbo, these women are a little related to Yang Guo, so Yang Guo's product is simply possessed by peach blossom essence, Jin Yong is not a little too much to shape Yang Guo like this.
8. The Mongolian army of more than 100,000 attacked Xiangyang, and only a few martial arts masters defended the city, can it be fake?
Of course, some chivalrous friends will say that Guo Jing's group of martial arts masters is just a part of the army defending the city, but if you look at "The Condor Heroes", there is no mention of the regular army guarding Xiangyang at all, most of them are still those martial arts masters guarding the city, this loophole is too big. Imagine on the battlefield, what martial arts master is blind in the face of more than 100,000 people.
9, guarding Xiangyang is so important, Huang Rong can still come to the rivers and lakes from time to time, does she have annual leave?
Huang Rong and Guo Jing guard Xiangyang, she is a think tank and military master, but she can come to the rivers and lakes from time to time, is this really appropriate? Or does Huang Rong still have annual leave to guard the city? Don't forget, there is no holiday on Chinese New Year's Eve this year.
10. Xiaolongnu has been at the bottom of the valley for 16 years, does she have a change of clothes?
This loophole is still related to life, of course, martial arts is not life, so although these common-sense things are loopholes, readers and authors don't seem to care. It's like Yang Guo broke his arm, how he cut his nails and tied his trouser belt, so it is not a problem to find a hundred or ten loopholes like this, but readers are attracted by Jin Yong's story and don't care about these details that have nothing to do with the story at all.
Write at the end
It's interesting to find the loopholes in "The Condor Heroes".
——
I don't know when I got hooked on martial arts novels, and I don't know when I like to find loopholes in novels, of course, there are real loopholes in them, but it's more about revisiting classic works in a way that looks for loopholes, literary works are interesting, but there are also logic, but after all, it's not real life, so the above ten loopholes may not be worth mentioning at all, but as long as the process is interesting, won't it make people happier?
Therefore, the so-called finding loopholes is just to read books in a happy way, and at the same time to interact with your chivalrous friends, which is enough.
Jin Gu martial arts
Let's talk about those things about martial arts