The material in this article comes from the Internet, if it is inconsistent with the actual situation or there is infringement, please contact to delete.
Since everyone's evaluation of the role of Song Jiang in "Water Margin" can be described as mixed. Some people say that he combines "loyalty, filial piety, wisdom, and righteousness", lectures on morality, attaches importance to love and righteousness, has far-reaching strategies, and takes into account the overall situation, and can be called a good man. However, it is also pointed out that he is "sleek", good at disguise, extremely deep in the city, and shrewd in appearance. From a modern point of view, it may be called the "insidious Virgin", and it is also an old fritters in the workplace. Such a contradictory character directly led to the tragic end of the good man of Liangshan.
For the shaping of Song Jiang in the film and television version, there are different opinions. Many film and television works adapted from "Water Margin" emerge one after another, and there are countless actors who play Song Jiang. Among them, the performances of Bao Guoan, Li Xuejian and Zhang Hanyu were highly recognized. Relatively speaking, Zhang Hanyu's role is more in line with modern people's understanding of Song Jiang, he exudes a strong atmosphere of rivers and lakes, and looks like a "big brother". However, compared with the description of "Xiaoyi Kurosaburo" in the original work, it is slightly different, perhaps missing some "pedantic" taste, but pedantic is one of Song Jiang's distinctive character characteristics.
For me, I prefer Bao Guoan's performance in the 83 Shandong version of "Water Margin" and Li Xuejian's performance in the 98 CCTV version of "Water Margin". Because their interpretation is closer to the original, they vividly interpret Song Jiang's complex and multifaceted character and psychology.
Bao Guoan's performance in the 83rd edition of "Water Margin" is impressive. He vividly interpreted Song Jiang's honest loyalty and power-climbing side. His performance is impressive in many scenes, especially the play "Angry Killing Yan Poxi", from the initial bitter pleading to the final decision, Bao Guoan presents Song Jiang's inner world vividly through delicate emotional changes. His performance makes people feel the reality and three-dimensional of Song Jiang.
In contrast, Li Xuejian's performance in the 98th edition of "Water Margin" is also impressive. He expresses the rich emotions in Song Jiang's heart through delicate eyes and movements, especially at critical moments, he shows Song Jiang's complex character in a weightlifting way. His performance makes the character of Song Jiang more real and lifelike.
Although both actors are national first-class performance artists, their interpretations and understandings of the role of Song Jiang are slightly different. Bao Guoan's version of Song Jiang is more in line with our traditional impression of this role, loyal and moral, full of the arrogance of a good man in the green forest. And Li Xuejian's version of Song Jiang is more life-like, making people feel that he is around us and a real character.
Bao Guoan and Li Xuejian both played the role of Song Jiang in their own unique ways, each with their own strengths. Bao Guoan vividly shows the complex character of Song Jiang through superb performances, while Li Xuejian makes Song Jiang more real through delicate emotional expression and life-oriented interpretation. Therefore, I don't think it's possible to say who plays better, each version has its own uniqueness, making it difficult to choose.
In general, Bao Guoan and Li Xuejian are excellent actors, and their performances are impressive. They bring the character of Song Jiang to life in their own unique ways, making people feel the authenticity of this complex and multifaceted character. Whether it is Bao Guoan's version of loyalty and boldness, or Li Xuejian's version of life-oriented performance, it gives us a deeper understanding of Song Jiang. It also reminds me of the hard work and unique creativity that the actors put into shaping the characters, which is admirable.
To sum up, the performances of Bao Guoan and Li Xuejian in "Water Margin" are deeply impressive. They each show the complex character of Song Jiang's character through a unique interpretation method, which makes people feel the authenticity of this character. Therefore, I don't think it's easy to judge who plays better, each version has its own uniqueness and deserves our appreciation and discussion. At the same time, it also makes us cherish the efforts and creativity of the actors in shaping the characters.
The above content and materials are derived from the Internet, and the author of this article does not intend to target or allude to any real country, political system, organization, race, individual. The above does not mean that the author of this article endorses the laws, rules, opinions, behaviors in the article and is responsible for the authenticity of the relevant information. The author of this article is not responsible for any problems arising above or related to the above and does not assume any direct or indirect legal liability. Due to the rules of the platform, you will only be recognized as a fan if you have more interaction with me. If you like my article, you can click "Follow", and you can receive the article push as soon as you become an iron fan. This article is only published in today's headlines, please do not move.