<h1>Welcome to click on the blue color in the upper right to focus on the "Burning Island Group", we do not do other people's article porters, only provide accurate historical basis and unique insight analysis, and use geology, psychology and sociology to tell the history of wonderful! </h1>
This article is the 85th original article of the "Burning Islands" headline number.
I thought that the film famine after Wolf Warrior 2 could be alleviated in "Dunkirk", but I didn't expect that this became a turning point in Nolan's masterpiece, and I was disappointed!
A lot of equipment abandoned on the beach
The first is the lack of scenes, the historical Dunkirk evacuation, in seven days successively withdrew more than 300,000 British and French troops, of which nearly 40% of the French army. At its peak, more than 50,000 troops retreated every day, and countless pieces of equipment were discarded on the beaches. The Germans also carried out a large number of air raids on the beach, and although the damage was limited, it increased the chaos on the beach. The simple statistics are that there are more than 700 Coalition tanks discarded on the beach, more than 3,000 guns, and tens of thousands of vehicles, and there is not a single tank or discarded artillery in the film, all of which are light infantry, and can't help but doubt Nolan's sincerity.
The coalition forces in the historical archives, after two weeks of hard fighting, the coalition forces cannot be in a good state
Since the rapid German breakthrough on June 15, the rhythm of the coalition forces has been disrupted, and although it can maintain its structure, it lacks adequate supplies and rest, and it is impossible to reach the beach in a good state, and the photos above are true portrayals.
A coalition of troops lined up on the beach
However, in the movie, the British troops are lined up in a neat line facing the sea, and the inexplicable cheering or dodging under the direction of the director is really too dramatic. Although everyone knows that film is the art of deception, the difference between group performances and professional actors is the inadequacy of imaginative performance, when presented to the audience, if you do not add the background rendering, there is no way to experience the chaos and desolation of the great retreat, Nolan insists on not post-production, resulting in the entire film scene is similar to a semi-finished product.
This is one of the few photos of the beach rout that is a bit imposing, but it can only see the infantry, without any heavy weapons
The second is that the setting of the plot is too stingy. The British soldiers who were blown up and launched one after another from the French beaches, the father and son of the cruise ship who voluntarily departed from the British harbor, the Spitfire squad responsible for cover in the air, the three clues developed independently in the early stages, and intersected in the later stages of the film, which was originally a good means of starting from a small point of view, and the most wonderful film in a similar movie was "Crazy Stone". However, in the context of the retreat of more than 300,000 people, it is very stingy. In the movie, 30% of the time is about air combat, 30% of the time is about shipwrecks, and 30% of the time is about entanglements on the beach, which seems to be just that.
The first intersection of the air front and the fishing boat line
The Great White Cliff on the British side of the English Channel is a natural barrier and psychological comfort for the British for thousands of years
Finally, there is the serious lack of emotional lines, which can be understood without talking about love, and Pearl Harbor, which is also in the context of the great battle, has been criticized, and the raw and dragging love scene has proved difficult to implant in the film of a single battle. But the wonderful camaraderie and brotherhood told in "Company of Brothers" and "Saving Private Ryan" were not seen in "Dunkirk", and until the movie was finished, it was not clear what the relationship between the protagonists was. Without human interaction, camaraderie and brotherhood cannot be expressed.
In the real retreat scene, the ship was full of soldiers
A large number of French soldiers also retreated to England with the British fleet
The scene that appears at the beginning of the film refusing to allow the French troops to board the ship was originally thought to be a foreshadowing, which will be modified later to the revolutionary comrades-in-arms, after all, the French army withdrawn in Dunkirk in history was also as high as 130,000 people, but unfortunately, in addition to the French soldier who stole the British uniform, there was no more performance of how 130,000 French troops were transported, which can not but be said to be too small a pattern, and in order to show this small pattern, the real big pattern in history was abandoned.
Discard the Allied equipment at Dunkirk and become the spoils of war for curious German soldiers
If anyone thinks that the father and son on the harbor and the civilians who rushed to the beaches of Dunkirk to save the coalition forces embody a spirit of fearlessness, then this spirit is not enough in the whole film. During the week of the great retreat, a large number of civilian ships shuttled around the beach, and their efforts were the most shining place for the people of the British Empire, but unfortunately, in the hands of Nolan, who refused to special effects, this feeling was held in the chest, choked in the throat, and half plucked, but it was never able to spit out.
Stills of an eagle over London
The accompanying reporter with a hand-cranked camera, the great retreat footage of his lens is more realistic and moving
In contrast, a 1969 old work "Eagle over London" is also from the rout of the Coalition army, dunkirk evacuation began to talk about, a tank ambush battle, a reporter with a hand camera, plus a beach ferry shot in the hands of several reporters, it explains the confidence and pride of the British, I don't know how many people remember it?
Nolan really screwed up this time!
<h1>Pull down a bit, and the high-energy comment area is more exciting. </h1>