Zeng Xiang contemptuously said that Tian Yunzhang and Tian Yingzhang's letters were only at the primary stage and would always be low-level. Some calligraphy enthusiast netizens asked Zeng Xiang, Shen Peng, etc. to write a letter to see if it exceeded Tian Kai, netizen Mr. Huang thought it was funny: "The calligraphy is an entry-level thing of calligraphy, just like the primary school student topic, you have to ask a graduate student to do a few primary school student questions to see, to prove that you can do the same as the primary school problem, is this a level?" None of them are on a level. Lao Decadence believes that since "calligraphy is an introductory thing of calligraphy", Zeng and Shen will not write well, indicating that they have not yet started, how did they jump to become masters?
The Tang Dynasty calligrapher Sun Guoting has a very precise exposition in the "Book Genealogy", he said: "Beginners learn distribution, but seek peace and justice; both know that they are peaceful and must pursue danger; both can be dangerous and return to peace." The first is not reached, the middle is passed, and then it is general. At the time of the meeting, people are old. Zeng Xiang borrowed this exposition of Sun Guoting to make to Ertian's "always low-level" thesis.
Zeng Xiang's thesis is unfair to Ertian's return to the new Ou Kai, who has returned to peace, and obviously, Ertian Ou Kai should have reached the level of old age.
Tian Yunzhang thousand words
Tian Yingzhang' letter
Looking at Shen Peng and Zeng Xiang's letters, it should be that the initial stage of "beginner distribution, but seeking peace and integrity" is not yet enough, but it has jumped to "seek danger"! And resolutely do not "return to peace", in fact, they have not been fair at all, so it is difficult for them to be right.
Shen Pengkai
Zeng Xiang kaishu
Therefore, Shen Peng simply vigorously advocated calligraphy innovation, "rarely posting, writing how you want." Zeng Xiang and other ugly book masters did their best to show their skills under the slogan of "innovation", and ugly books such as shouting blind shooting and jumping were frequently produced, which completed serious pollution of the social and cultural environment, causing indignant resistance from calligraphy lovers and the public. (In order to avoid pollution, there are no pictures of ugly books here)
Chairman Su Shishu and Sun Xiaoyun of the New Book Association returned to tradition, the original source was clean, and brought a clean and healthy atmosphere to the book world, which was naturally welcomed by the public. The weeds in the hundred gardens must be eradicated, and the smog created by the chaos of the book world must be dispelled.
Sun Xiaoyun wrote in letters
MoKe in Tuhua Xuxing cursive