Lu Kewen can't even talk about the hunan issue, how much credibility does it have to talk about the world(II)

Yesterday I said that Lu Kewen attributed the rise of talents in modern history in Hunan to the huge wealth brought by the Xiang Army after it pacified the Taiping Army, and this funny view has never been written in serious books, but even in the stall magazine. WHY？

First, Lu Kewen's view is logically a paradox, and zeng, zuo, Hu, and Peng of the Taiping Army, as well as many generals of the Xiang Army, are themselves a peak of talent in Hunan, especially Zeng Zuo, whose merits to the Chinese nation are now underestimated. Why Hunan will suddenly appear in thousands of years of history this peak of talent, your Lu Kewen's point of view can not explain at all. If you want to explain the talent phenomenon in Hunan, you first have to explain and ask what will be the Xiang Army? Why is there Zeng Zuohu? And not because there is a Xiang Army.

Second, the fact that the Xiang army used the plunder of wealth to set up education and drive the peak of Hunan talents is inconsistent with the facts, and even if the Xiang army set up education in Hunan, there is no record in the correct history, and it is completely the author's imagination. We can also confirm this from the side. After the Taiping Heavenly Kingdom, in order to change the backward appearance, the Qing government sent primary school students to European and American countries many times to learn advanced technology and advanced ideas, and the leader was Zeng Guofan. The names and places of origin of these primary school students are available for information, you can go to a certain degree of encyclopedia query, I looked at it, among the hundreds of international students, most of them are from Jiangsu, Zhejiang, And Guangdong, and there is no Hunan nationality. If, as Lu Kewen said, the generals of the Xiang Army had the heart to educate their children and grandchildren, would they miss these opportunities? Later, during the Xinhai Revolution at the end of the Qing Dynasty, although outstanding figures such as Huang Xing, Cai, Chen Tianhua, and other outstanding figures emerged in Hunan, the total number of overseas students was not much, not only lower than that of Jiangsu, Zhejiang, and Guangdong along the coast, but also lower than that of Sichuan and Hubei inland. And then in the revolutionary struggle led by our party, it is true that the largest number of Hunan founding fathers and outstanding generals have emerged, but if you look closely at their growth process, not only are not all international students, but even only one has attended an authentic university.

Therefore, attributing several peaks of talent in Hunan to education is inconsistent with reality and attributing to the wealth of the Xiang Army, which is even more ridiculous.

Some people have said that you can't just oppose others, so what is your point of view? I'll just outline a few of the areas I know.

In fact, everyone knows that the barbaric period in the history of Hunan is really longer than most provinces. Hunan is surrounded by mountains on three sides, and the mountains in the east are shorter and can still be passed. The mountains to the south and west are steep like grabens and are inaccessible. Surrounded by mountains on three sides, an opening was opened to the north, but this mouth was blocked by eight hundred miles of caves and the vast Yangtze River. This unique terrain determines that it was civilized relatively late, and the time of the melee with tigers, wolves, insects and leopards was relatively long, and at the same time, there were many mountains, fragmentation in various places, and civil unrest was also more serious. Jiang Baili, a great Chinese militarist in modern times, once said that Hunan is the second prism of China. It can be understood that Hunan is China's second border, the first border is lost, and the second border of Hunan is there, but if the Hunan ridge line dies in China, it will not be guaranteed, this is really not a Hunan people bragging, it is a fact of China's terrain. This may also be the reason why Han Gaozu set up a Changsha state in the remote and narrow Changsha when he first divided the kings. These practical and historical factors in Hunan have created the brave and extremely resilient fighting qualities of the indigenous people of Hunan, and Hunan has created a unique vocabulary in China, hegemony. "Hegemony is brutal, patience is annoying, not afraid of death" is the family motto of every Hunan native. After the Tang and Song dynasties, the east learned from the west, and Chinese culture gradually changed from the Central Plains, because of the Five Hu Chaohua, the crown crossed south to Jiangsu and Zhejiang, Jiangsu and Zhejiang became the cultural center, and the strong Confucian culture finally gradually penetrated into Hunan through Jiangxi. Cheng Zhuzhixue flourished and developed in Hunan, and Hunan was influenced by Chinese culture, opened by the people, and gradually civilized. The combination of Chinese Confucian culture and the barbarian culture of the indigenous people of Hunan has created a unique characteristic of Hunan people. It can be said that the cultural genes are better than those of Hunan, such as the central plains and the coastal areas such as Jiangsu and Zhejiang, which do not necessarily have the bravery and agility unique to Hunan culture. For example, Yunnan, Guizhou, Guangxi and other places are bolder than Hunan, and there is no civilization in Hunan. This kind of agility and bravery in Hunan culture is like "cone in the bag" in the war-torn environment, and it must stand out. This is the reason why Hunan must prosper every time there is chaos.