Written by Xiao Yao
In the early morning of December 26, Beijing time, the 2021-22 All-Russian Championship officially came to an end. 15-year-old rookie Valieva won the first place in the fault with a 40-point advantage; "hardcore girl" Trusova successfully fell on the ice in 4 weeks and shocked the whole field and won the silver medal; "Qianjin" Serbakova made a slight mistake and finally won the bronze.
However, after the game, ice fans who followed figure skating expressed their dissatisfaction with the bronze medal of Sherbakova, and for a time they were full of condemnation.
"Sherbakova has jumped like this, and she has not caught a single jump, is the Russian Ice Association blind like this?"
"When the water is just up, ok you can stand and fall on the ice to finish, and the fan water you are all watery." Water you've been on for three years and really think you're on this level?
Other players rushed 44 rushed 54, rushed double 3a rushed 3a four-week set, and Serbakova stood on the podium with a single 4 also pounced on the street set Meimei"
"Congratulations Sasha... I hope to form a group lineup with K Bao to impact the group gold. Don't give The Thousand Gold Sherbakova any chance to rub the gold medal. ”
At present, Valieva and Trusova have locked up the Winter Olympic places in advance, and the third place will be decided after the European Championships.
As the champion of the New Koko World Championships, the third consecutive all-Russian champion and the most stable player in the "three small" competitions, Serbakova has always been one of the players with the highest demand for the Winter Olympics. So why is there a very different voice after this All-Russian Championship than before?
In fact, this is not the first time there has been controversy.
Soon after she was promoted to the group, Sherbakova became the heart of the Russian Ice Association, and her flexible and cute posture and gentle temperament also made her gain many fans at home and abroad.
The results of the Beijing Winter Olympic cycle have also been good. But her results have been controversial.
The following is a brief analysis of her controversy from the two aspects of technical points and artistic expression.
1. Sherbakova's best four-way jump is 4Lz and 4F, and the first jump in free skating this season was the 4F. However, due to the fact that F jumps with an inner blade and Lz jumps with an outer blade, which is the opposite, and many players use the blade at the beginning of learning these two jumps without correcting it in time, so the field will also see the situation of "point ice stepping blade" and "one jump and two uses".
There is a wrong blade in Sherbakova's F jump. In this year's figure skating sub-station in France, because of the water on the ice surface, coupled with the blurring of Serbakova's internal and external blades, her 4F direct jump failed and fell to the baffle. In fact. If her 4F is really a clean and clean inner blade jump, the quality of the jump may be reduced due to the ice surface, but it will never slide directly.
2. Jump to save weekly problems.
The first is the problem of jumping the pre. Pre refers to the player's feet off the ground, the body begins to rotate, which can be simply understood as delayed rotation.
Strictly speaking, the pre of the ice jump should be at 45 degrees, and the pre of the F jump should be at 90 degrees. But Serbakova's jump of 180 degrees, combined with early ice drops within the rules allowed, made her actual weeks less than 4 weeks.
However, throughout the Beijing cycle, except for the technical score of the 2019 China Cup Sherbakova was caught, other times her technical score was very high, and the dissatisfaction in the hearts of ice fans naturally accumulated.
3. Artistic expression score: The level of artistic expression score is not only affected by the contestant's personal style, program content, and effect, but also the subjective factors of the referee. There is a hard rule in the figure skating rules: if the player plays wrong, the p-point should be reduced.
However, Serbakova's p-point has always been above another four-week jumping genius Trusova, and even if she plays wrong, the p-point is quite high, which also makes some ice fans feel unjust.
Controversy Breaks Out:
This season's All-Russian Championship, Sherbakova's free skating play was abnormal, except for the 4F fall, the quality of the jump completion in the other three weeks was not high, but the technical points were still unequal with the play; and the technical points of Tuktamiseva, who played well and jumped with excellent quality, were suppressed.
In addition, Serbakova's p-points once again surpassed Trusova's, and her bronze medal eventually broke out into controversy. Netizens have accused her of being "unworthy of morality".
At present, the last Winter Olympic quota has not yet been determined, the storm has begun, do you think Serbakova has a chance to come back to Beijing?