Text/Little Seven Drama Station
The long-awaited "Snow Knife Line" was finally broadcast, to be honest, xiaoqi has been looking forward to it since the preparation of the play, first of all, this is the second cooperation between Zhang Ruoyun and Wang Tian, the last cooperation between the two is "Qing Yu Nian", word of mouth and heat double harvest, the two work together again, how to say it will not be too bad.
Second, the original work of "Knife Line in the Snow" is really too famous, after reading the original work, I want to see what it will look like, even if I can't shoot that jianghu, at least I hope to shoot that kind of sadness.
Finally waiting for the drama to be broadcast, Xiao Qiqi couldn't wait to watch the six episodes of the plot, and after watching it, his heart was a little uncomfortable, and his heart was full of mixed feelings and complexity.
It can only be said that the TV series "Knife In the Snow" has little to do with the original work, and the restoration of the original work is very rare, except for the title, personal name and background, the script has almost nothing to do with the original work.
1, the plot is not right
First of all, let's talk about the plot, after all, the plot of the TV series has nothing to do with the original work. In the novel "Sword Line in the Snow", whether it is Xu Fengnian or Xu Xiao, what everyone sees on the surface is not the same as in fact. On the surface, Xu Fengnian is a stupid boy, lustful, and everyone hears of it and avoids it, but in fact, Xu Fengnian is a person with his own ideas.
For the fact that Xu Fengnian is a good person, the original work is slowly detected by everyone, that is, slowly deduced from the details. For example, it is said that Xu Fengnian is lustful, but in fact, he has not moved any woman, saying that he is stupid, in fact, he has secretly saved a lot of people.
But what about in the play? Put these conspiracies on the surface. In the past, the traitors in the Northern Liang Army were hidden very deeply, and they were only pulled out later, and they were rarely mentioned in the front of the novel. As soon as the play came up, he gave Xu Fengnian many clues, and told him bluntly that someone in the Northern Liang Army wanted his life.
As a result, the whole drama has become Xu Fengnian's treacherous spy, without the charm of the original. It is also beneficial to change the TV series in this way, after all, it is completely in accordance with the original book to shoot, at least to shoot a few hundred episodes, so simple less brain-burning, more humor, but lost a lot of charm, no suspense of the plot, there is less interest in in-depth research.
2. The casting is not correct
Let's talk about casting, although we all know that the TV series can't do 100% restore the original character setting, but at least you have to find an actor who is inseparable from ten or meets the conditions, but this casting is really unbearable.
The casting failures of the drama version of "Snow In the Sword Line" are mostly concentrated on female characters, the first of which is the role played by Zhang Tianai. The white fox face was rated by Xu Fengnian as the world's first beauty, originally called the first beauty, but this person often dressed as a man, unable to distinguish between men and women, so it was changed to "beauty".
Zhang Tianai's appearance is indeed high, but this makeup is really a bit ruined, because at a glance, you know that it is a woman, without the secret male and female in the original work, Xu Fengnian can't see the appearance of a female lady.
Sweet potato is Xu Fengnian's mane, the original depiction of sweet potato is a plump body and natural fragrance, so the main job is to warm the bed. However, the sweet potato played by Mengziyi in the play is not only not plump but also very thin and talks a lot, and the difference with the original work is particularly large, so that the sweet potato does not need to warm the bed.
Jiang Ni, played by Li Gengxi, was originally a princess of Western Chu and was given the title of Taiping. Although the title is too peaceful, but people are really not peaceful, the original book mentioned that Xu Fengnian felt that she should change a title. But the play is really peaceful and there are still a lot of words and very clever, which is particularly different from the original.
The most surprising thing is that the role of Yu Youwei, although they are all flower queens, the flower queens in the original work are very different from the flower queens in the play.
According to the reason, Hua Kui should also be the national color Tianxiang amazing talent, but in fact, everyone still watch the stills, do not know why it became Hua Kui, and that set of sword dances is not fragrant at all.
This is only some female characters appearing, and there are several characters who do not quite match the original work, so there are big mistakes in the casting. As for the role of Xu Fengnian, although many original parties said that it did not conform to the original work, since it was hand-picked by the princes of beacon theater, let's skip it first.
3, the production is not right
Not conforming to the original work is already disappointing, but the production of the show is also very perfunctory, especially the fight and special effects. "Knife In the Snow" is also an S-class project, which costs a lot of money, but why are the special effects so perfunctory?
In the six episodes of the plot broadcast, except for the opening war scenes that are still relatively grand, several martial arts scenes and special effects are really like children's homes.
Let's talk about the fight scene where the white fox face appeared, as a master-level master, can only use slow motion to highlight her strength? Even if you drive three times the speed, it looks like slow motion, which shows how distracted this action scene is.
When the face of the white fox flashes, the special effects used are really difficult to accept. It is recommended that the martial fingers of "The Sword In the Snow" learn more about the early Hong Kong films, see how people's fight dramas are designed, and learn how to learn how to fight with other people's masters.
However, the costume of "The Knife Line in the Snow" did really use heart, if you can change the shape and attire of the white fox's face, it would be better.
Therefore, "The Knife In the Snow" has little to do with the original work, and the audience who watched the original work will feel a little unable to watch it, but it can still be seen by abandoning the original work, depending on whether you accept it or not.
Have you watched "Knife Row in the Snow"? What do you think?