Liu Xinwu's study of the Red Chamber of the Qin Clan constructs a magnificent historical picture formed by the struggle between the Japanese and The Moon factions, which is used as a clue to explain the grand funeral after Qin Keqing's death, as well as the changes in the fate of some related characters, such as Liu Xianglian, such as Feng Ziying, such as Wei Ruolan, the prince of WangSun who once appeared in the original work, and later became Shi Xiangyun's husband.
It is difficult to say whether his research direction is right or wrong, in the early years of CCTV's "Hundred Family Forum", Liu Xinwu also explained "Dream of the Red Chamber". As a senior red science enthusiast, he recently carefully read his "Dream of the Red Chamber of Liu Xinwu", and understood it more carefully, he completely abandoned the character ending of Gao Yanxuan and interpreted it according to his own structure according to cao Xueqin's character judgment in the previous article. Here too, I would like to take a brief look at it.
The most concerned heroine Lin Daiyu's ending is from the water fairy, but her body is not, and the dress and hairpin rings and the like all float on the surface of the water, and will not sink to the bottom. The flesh was feathered along with her soul. This ending is very beautiful, but it seems to weaken the tragic plot, making everyone, including Jia Baoyu, think that Lin Girl is a chengxian and can't cause a little sad emotion. In order to explain the phrase "hanging in the forest with jade belts", he designed Lin Daiyu to hang her jade belt embedded with lapis lazuli and glittering green emeralds on the trees of the Grand View Garden before dying, to show that she had fled on her own. This ending does not seem to be very reasonable, I would rather Lin Daiyu is seriously ill, and eventually die of tears, even if Bao Dai has a past life, Dai Yu is to return tears with Bao Yu under the calamity, but this tragic love story still has to have normal development logic, there is a sad color, only touching. Besides, if Dai Yu finally has a corpse left, it will not affect the beautiful image of daizhu fairy in people's hearts, and because of the corpse, Bao Yu can weep, and even lose his soul. Such a love tragedy has an impact!
Shi Xiangyun was naturally widowed first, and at the same time, because Wei Ruolan participated in the assassination of the emperor's Moon Sect, although she was also a criminal minister when she died, so the family of the criminal minister was to be pulled to sell in the street market, but no one dared to buy it, and later she was sold to a brothel. The so-called "wandering in fireworks alley". Later, after being redeemed and meeting Baoyu, the two become hanako and eat sauerkraut together in a broken felt to live a begging life. It also corresponds to the sentence "Because of the unicorn fu white head double star". It was only later that the two people's life situations changed so much, and their mentality completely changed, although in reality they were able to live the life of a beggar with the encounter, but the pursuit and inner taste of a thought could not be reduced, so the mentality of the two people who were happy to sing in the New Year on a snowy day later, and the level of poetry that they did fell greatly, was also not in line with the real situation of the two people.
Miao Yu and Gongzi Chen Yejun are actually another version of Bao Dai's story, but at that time, there was a partisan dispute between the two families in the official arena, and the fathers and fathers did not agree, so they broke off contact. Originally, Miao Yu's family wanted to marry her to the Duke's Palace, but Miao Yu was crying and so much that she went on a hunger strike, so she brought her to practice. Chen Yejun is also one of the characters of the Moon Sect, but he did not die in battle, because of the avoidance of disaster, he and Miao Yu met again, but Miao Yu's personality was relatively lonely and cold, and he refused to take the initiative to propose to continue the leading edge. In the end, she did not hesitate to commit herself to the bones because she saved Baoyu, obeyed the Prince of Zhongshun, and offered the treasure she brought to the King of Zhongshun, of course, in the end she refused to be insulted, so she exploded with her last box of treasures, turned into ashes, and also took the Prince of Zhongshun. This ending is lamentable. But I prefer that she be abducted by robbers, the so-called "desire to clean He Zengjie". The chivalrous approach does not seem to be suitable for Miao Yu, and it is still possible to put it on Xiang Yun. After all, Dai Yu once said that Xiang Yun was pretending to be Jing Ke and Nie Zheng.
Of course, Wang Xifeng was because after her big things and bad things were exposed, coupled with the Jia family's guilt and raiding the family, and her fate went to another realm. However, she has always been detained, because she is the housekeeper of Jia Province, and she has both the situation of Jinling's origin and the finances of the later Rong Guo Mansion. In the process of being escorted to her original hometown, she committed suicide by throwing herself into the water, because she had learned that her daughter Qiao Sister had been rescued by Grandma Liu, and her heart was finished, and she had no worries about her heart, and took the initiative to seek death. This seems to be reasonable, but it seems unlikely that Ping'er and her will be corrected. Otherwise, Ping'er's fate will be bitter and willing, which does not conform to the ideological theme of "Dream of the Red Chamber" of Qianhong crying and Wan Yan and sharing sorrow.
Xue Baoqin and Liu Xianglian met because after the struggle between the two factions of the Sun and the Moon, everyone fled and finally joined, "not in the plum side but in the willow side", this explanation may be reasonable. After all, later Liu Xianglian was a strong beam and had the ability to rescue Baoqin, and Xue Baoqin was naturally willing to combine with Liu Xianglian when the Mei family was hopeless. Baoqin is a beautiful woman, not to mention that liu xianglian also found Qiu Shizhou's "Double YanTu", from Liu Xianglian's point of view, it is also reasonable.
When Baoyu was imprisoned in the prison temple, Xi Xue came out to help because she was married to the jailer King Short Legs. In the matter of rescuing Sister Qiao, Jia Yun and Xiaohong did have a relationship, and they begged Li Feng here, and Li Feng and Jia Lan were unwilling to help. Naturally, it was Grandma Liu who came forward to pool the money, and at the same time, with the help of Miaoyu to a greater extent, rescued Sister Qiao from the brothel, and Sister Qiao eventually married Ban'er, who was innocent, and she was not insulted because of the protection of the prostitute Yun'er. The arrangement of these plots is more reasonable.
Regarding Yingchun, it is not that he was abused to death, but that he could not stand the abuse and hanged himself. In the original work, Sun Shaozu said that Jia Pardon had embezzled 5,000 taels of silver from him, so he sold Yingchun to pay off the debt. The origin of the so-called 5,000 taels of silver, Liu Xinwu's account is that Sun Shaozu flirted with Qiu Duwei's sister, that is, a favorite concubine of the Prince of Zhongshun, and had no time to hide, so he had to take 5,000 taels of silver and kneel under the knees of the great old man and ask for shelter. Later, he mixed with Qiu Duwei and them, thinking that he could be promoted to general and wanted to impeach Jia For pardon, let alone yingchun.
XiangLing was abused by Xia Jingui, so that she died of dry blood, which is still consistent with the original work.
Lin Daiyu's illness was growing, also because Aunt Zhao was behind her back, she instructed Jia Ling and Jia Chang, two drug-dispensed people, to poison Lin Daiyu, slowly leaving Lin Daiyu incurable, and the poisonous gas soaked into the bone marrow to die. Therefore, from this point of view, Lin Daiyu's subsequent self-reliance is even more unreasonable.
Jia Mu's ending was also because Shi Jia was first stripped of his knighthood, and Aunt Zhao deliberately ran to Jia Mu's room to report the news, so that Jia Mu could not bear this blow, fell ill, and died not long after being suffered.
Jia Tanchun was originally the daughter-in-law of the King of Nan'an County, but unfortunately, because after the General of Yuehai and Jia Yucun got acquainted, he was recommended by Jia Yucun, and General Yuehai accepted Tanchun as a righteous daughter and married to Haijiang on behalf of his daughter. And that sea frontier is the Xi Xiang Kingdom. This ending is reasonable. After all, no matter how good Tanchun is, no matter how much Princess Nan'anjun likes Tanchun, she can only be a victim in the face of national interests.
Xi Chun took advantage of the fact that the Jia family had not yet been completely raided, and one day secretly changed into the nun's clothes left by the previous wisdom and ran out. This ending is still in line with the spirit of the original work.
The combination of Xue Baochao and Jia Baoyu is of course the most in line with the original work, but their marriage must have been after Lin Daiyu was no longer there. Moreover, Liu Xinwu believes that Lin Daiyu and Jia Baoyu have a marriage contract, but they have not fulfilled the formalities. This is in line with the principle of conjugal ethics that Baoyu told him about the girls who listened to the singing.
Of course, the flower raider was forced to leave Baoyu, and it was not Xue Baochao who married her out, because The Prince of Zhongshun named the attacker to take revenge on The Treasure Jade, so she first went to serve the mother of the Prince of Zhongshun, and later because the Prince of Zhongshun wanted to envelop the Xiaodan Jiang Yubao under his name, so under the mediation of Fu Qiufang, that is, the continuation of the Prince of Zhongshun, married to qiguan, which also corresponded to the frontier.
Baoyu was born twice, so in the previous article, Dai Yu said that he had been a monk twice. The first time he left home, he was persuaded by Zhen Baoyu to come back, but after he returned, Baochao was already dead, Baochao was because his brother and mother died one after another, Baoyu did not know where to go, chest paralysis attacked heart rate failure and died. But Baochao died in the snow, and he responded alive to the sentence of "buried in the snow of the golden hairpin", which seems a little too straightforward and far-fetched.
Regarding the characters of the Moon Sect, Zhang Youshi is naturally a leader. Yuan Chun was also promoted because he denounced Qin Keqing as the daughter of the deposed prince, and when the Japanese and Yue factions were hunting on the iron net mountain in the final battle, the Yue faction named the emperor to hand over Yuan Chun, so Yuan Chun was strangled by the emperor and then handed over. The oil jelly bergamot was originally a jade object that Jia Mu gave to Yuan Chun to play with, and it was not very heavy in his hand, and the emperor only joked at first, and did not say anything, and then said in this name that Yuan Chun was suspected of assassinating the emperor, which was just an excuse. All women, in the eyes of the emperor, were mere victims of political struggle. If you hand it over, you will hand it over, and it is not a pity to die. It seems that there is also a certain reason for Jia Yuanchun to arrange this arrangement, otherwise, Jia Yuanchun's sudden violent death would not give any reason.
I am Bingshan drunk red chamber, like the red chamber and read all the books of the rational financial women, welcome to pay attention to the review.