幾種基于HTTP協定的RPC性能比較

今天寫個程式測試了一下Axis(SOAP), Hessian(Binary), Burlap(XML-RPC), REST的性能。

服務端的是一個簡單的加密、解密方法，各種協定使用同一個實作的代碼。

用戶端是獨立的java程式，分别用各種協定對服務端的方法進行調用。每一種協定循環調用n次，然後取平均值。

循環1,000次的測試

第一次

Axis --------------->> Total time: 11123 ms, Avg time: 11.123 ms
Burlap ------------->> Total time:   866 ms, Avg time:  0.866 ms
Hessian ------------>> Total time:   581 ms, Avg time:  0.581 ms
REST --------------->> Total time:   929 ms, Avg time:  0.929 ms
AxisUsingWSDL2Java ->> Total time: 11998 ms, Avg time: 11.998 ms
           

第二次

Axis --------------->> Total time: 11256 ms, Avg time: 11.256 ms
Burlap ------------->> Total time:   816 ms, Avg time:  0.816 ms
Hessian ------------>> Total time:   582 ms, Avg time:  0.582 ms
REST --------------->> Total time:   919 ms, Avg time:  0.919 ms
AxisUsingWSDL2Java ->> Total time: 11908 ms, Avg time: 11.908 ms
           

循環10,000次的測試

第一次

Axis --------------->> Total time:  88013 ms, Avg time:  8.8013 ms
Burlap ------------->> Total time:   5789 ms, Avg time:  0.5789 ms
Hessian ------------>> Total time:   5162 ms, Avg time:  0.5162 ms
REST --------------->> Total time:   8316 ms, Avg time:  0.8316 ms
AxisUsingWSDL2Java ->> Total time: 112801 ms, Avg time: 11.2801 ms
           

第二次

Axis --------------->> Total time:  87359 ms, Avg time:  8.7359 ms
Burlap ------------->> Total time:   5784 ms, Avg time:  0.5784 ms
Hessian ------------>> Total time:   5084 ms, Avg time:  0.5084 ms
REST --------------->> Total time:   7983 ms, Avg time:  0.7983 ms
AxisUsingWSDL2Java ->> Total time: 113234 ms, Avg time: 11.3234 ms
           

測試結果

Hessian最快，Burlap第二，REST第三，Axis最慢。前3種要比Axis快了10倍或者更多。

上面的測試，服務端用的是Resin-3.0.13，出于好奇，我又用Tomcat-5.5.9測試了一把，結果是Resin确實比Tomcat快些。

Tomcat-5.5.9 循環10,000次的測試

Axis --------------->> Total time: 122551 ms, Avg time: 12.2551ms
Burlap ------------->> Total time:   6401 ms, Avg time:  0.6401ms
Hessian ------------>> Total time:   5745 ms, Avg time:  0.5745ms
REST --------------->> Total time:   8090 ms, Avg time:  0.809ms
AxisUsingWSDL2Java ->> Total time: 156908 ms, Avg time: 15.6908ms