Who is Xi Liang Babu? In the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, they are Han Sui's subordinates, namely Hou Xuan, Cheng Yin, Li Kan, Zhang Heng, Liang Xing, Cheng Yi, Ma Play, and Yang Qiu, in fact, in history, they and Han Sui are of equal rank.
"Romance of the Three Kingdoms" After the Battle of Weinan, the endings of Han Sui and Xiliang Eight Parts are simply brushed over, in fact, some people are quite different from the end of zhengshi, and this issue will compare the endings of Han Sui and Xi Liang Eight Parts.
The most dramatic ending: Li Kan
In history, Li Kan was killed in the decisive battle of the Battle of Weinan.
In "Yanyi", the details of the battle death were holed, Yu forbidden to shoot Ma Chao with arrows, Ma Chao flashed, which just shot Li Kan in front of Ma Chao, and Li Kan fell off his horse and died.
The inexplicable ending of cannon fodder: Liang Xing
In history, after the defeat of the coalition forces, Liang Xing fled to Lantian, plundered in the surrounding counties and counties, and captured more than 5,000 households to force them to loot. In response to this problem, Zuo Feng yi Zheng Hun proposed a way to build a city wall, disintegrate Liang Xing's troops from within, and at the same time appease the people. In the end, with the assistance of Xiahou Yuan, they beheaded Liang Xing and destroyed the Yu Party.
In "Yanyi", Ma Chao insisted that Han Sui was disloyal, and Han Sui and the five generals discussed and simply surrendered to Cao Cao. These five will be Yang Qiu, Hou Xuan, Liang Xing, Ma Play, and Li Kan (because the other three are already hanging).
Han Sui and Cao Cao plotted to invite Ma Chao to a banquet, and then came to meet with the outside, but they did not expect that Ma Chao was highly skilled in martial arts, and the five departments would besiege Ma Chao and no one could beat them, Liang Xing and Ma Play were hacked to death by Ma Chao, and the other three ran away.
Be hacked to death early without an ending: horses play
In history, there is no record of horse play after the defeat of the Allied forces.
According to the previous section, he was hacked to death by Ma Chao
The best ending: Yang Qiu
After the defeat of the allied forces in history, Yang Qiu fled to Anding. Later, Cao Cao's Northern Expedition to Besiege Yang Qiu surrounded Anding, and Yang Qiu surrendered to Cao Cao. After Cao Pi ascended the throne, Yang Qiu and Guo Huai quelled Zheng Gan's rebellion and settled Guanzhong, and Huang Chu was promoted to the rank of general of Qiu Kou and made the Marquis of Linjing, and finally died.
In "Yanyi", Yang Qiu, together with Hou Xuan and Han Sui, surrendered to Cao Cao and was given the title of Marquis.
Sooner or later there is surrender: the election
Historically, after the defeat of the allied forces, Hou Xuan fled to Hanzhong, and after Cao Cao pacified Hanzhong, the Hou Xuan surrendered
In "Yanyi", they surrender together with Han Sui.
Cannon fodder for leveling: Cheng Yi
In history, he was killed in the Battle of Weinan.
"Yanyi" is also a brain hole plot, when Cao Cao was in the north of the Wei River, Cheng Yi and Ma Chao went to the night raid together. Cheng Yi rushed to the front, and sure enough, he was ambushed and killed by Xiahou Yuan.
Sad cannon fodder: Zhang Heng
In history, there is no record of the defeat of the Coalition forces,
After Cao Cao crossed the river, the coalition army was caught in Cao Cao's trap, and many people were folded, including Zhang Heng and Cheng Yin.
It is said in the "Yanyi" that Han Sui and Pound De led 50,000 troops, and cao Cao's treacherous plan fell into the pit of horses, Pound De jumped out at once and saved Han Sui and ran out, and then Ma Chao came to resist the cao army that was catching up, and also gave the Western Liang army time to get out of the pit, this battle was fought until the evening and then counted the number of zhang heng and Cheng Yin less than two hundred people.
Folks, the point of this story is that Cao Cao trapped Han Sui with a pit for 50,000 people, not to mention 50,000, just 10,000 people fell into the pit, how big a pit it must be!
Cheng Silver
Historically, like Hou Xuan, he fled into Hanzhong and surrendered after Cao Cao pacified Hanzhong.
"Yanyi" is no longer repeated, and Cheng Yin does not want to die.
The biggest ending in and out: Han Sui
In "Yanyi", Han Sui directly surrendered to Cao Cao, and the ending of Han Sui in history was not so simple.
In 214, when Ma Chao asked Zhang Lu to borrow troops to besiege Qishan, Han Sui was defeated by Xiahou Yuan at Xianqin, and then ran to Luoyang City to collude with the local Qi people, and Han Sui's army became strong with the addition of the Qi people.
At this time, Xiahou Yuan thought of a clever plan, he sent light troops to attack the hometown of the Qi people, Changli, because the families of the Qi people were all in Changli, and the People of Qi all left Han Sui and ran back to Changli to rescue, so Han Sui could only fight with Xiahou Yuan, and the result was lost. This battle can be said to have hit Han Sui's bones, although he later walked around with the Qiang people, but it was impossible to get up again, and his subordinates also had second hearts.
In 215, when Cao Cao pacified Hanzhong, the generals Jincheng and Xiping (not Han Sui's subordinates) together killed Han Sui and dedicated their heads to Cao Cao. This is an official account from the Romance of the Three Kingdoms. The Wudi Ji and the Zizhi Tongjian also use this record. However, in the Book of the Later Han Dynasty, he was directly killed by his subordinates; in Wei Luo, he died of illness first and then was beheaded.