The variety show "Director Please Advise" has been broadcast, this season's program is mainly directed, but also wants to win the popularity of several new directors, among the 16 directors, there are well-known Guan Jinpeng, Cai Kangyong, Wu Zhenyu, Han Xue and Bao Bell, there are also wang Wenye, Zeng Gift, Wang Yichun and Ning Yuanyuan, who are not very familiar to the audience.
At present, the first half of the first episode is broadcast, Bao Bell and Xiang Guoqiang compete, the adapted IP is "Nezha", this original work has a lot of ideological cores in it, but the effect presented by the two directors is really flat!
Xiang Guoqiang divided the 10-minute content into several units, the connection between the units and the units was not enough, the audience needed to think for themselves, Bao Bell was given directly, especially the audience saw that the actors were made of three heads and six arms by special effects, which was also a bit shocking.
The final rating is that Bao Bell won Xiang Guoqiang, some people say that this is a commercial film that wins a literary film, but in my opinion, this level of short film really can't be taken out, if you want to make a movie, can't you come up with some sincerity?
As a Nortel teacher, his theoretical knowledge is no problem, in the process of shooting, the optimistic mentality also infected many viewers, there was a moment when I was going to be fanned by him, but as soon as the work was broadcast, the filter for him was all broken!
But from the perspective of the work, the color is too old, want to shoot the atmosphere of the Hong Kong style, but speaking Chongqing dialect, it looks like a student work, no beginning and no tail, to the third unit is a little confused about what he wants to talk about, is this about love or family affection, or sweeping away the evil?
I can understand that the "sea" of "noisy sea" refers to a small place, and Nezha is the protagonist, but why should he make trouble? Why slap that guy? If the background of the story is not clearly explained, everyone will have everyone's interpretation!
The producer said that this work can not be understood, Li Chengru directly pointed out that if there is no good performance of the actor, the score of the work is only 30 points, because its motivation is not clear, any work, to let others understand, rather than understand, but also to tell others.
Xiang Guoqiang defines his works as a realistic movie, partial literary and artistic style, but I think even literature and art are not counted, the lens is too shaky, the plot development is also inexplicable, the most basic literary and art film is to see comfortable, even if the plot is not good, the set is comfortable, this scene is really difficult to compliment, eat a barbecue to use a 360-degree rotating lens, you don't have to!
It gives the impression that there are too many things to discuss, and if you can't stuff them in, you will use scrawled forms to try to express your profound intentions, and the result is failure.
The point is quite accurate, the protagonist fantasizes that he has three heads and six arms, and the protagonist's name is Li Nezha, but what is the significance of this? He just won Xiang Guoqiang on the emotional level, the theoretical basis really did not understand at all, Xiang Guoqiang at least specified a place, told about a place!
What did Bao Bell want to express: "It is not easy for my mother to give birth to me, I can't die so easily", so why did he climb to the roof on impulse before? Just because he was scolded by the parents of the students, but he also hit people first, if he didn't hit people, there would be no later things happening!
Li Nezha and his mother's two lines are not handled correctly, at least I saw the end to know that these two people are mother and son, even if some subtle plots are used to express their family relationship. A two-line narrative is not bad, but there needs to be a connection point.
This experience of the mother can not exist in the memory of the male protagonist, pregnant in October is only 3 months old, normal people are impossible, even if the male protagonist is gifted, the memory of the birth can be preserved until now, but also need an external factor to remind him of this memory at this moment, unfortunately there is no. The two narratives don't glue together very well, resulting in ten divisions!
Some people say that this variety show is a spit conference, those film critics are to intimidate the producer, from a neutral point of view, in fact, both sides are right, but the producer side knows more about what the audience needs, so it leads to film critics being scolded!
I think it, Bao Bell and Xiang Guoqiang's two works, really not much difference, although Xiang Guoqiang did not tell the story clearly, but at least what he wants to express in, need to think carefully to connect the story, not to be said to be useless, Bao Bell's work is only a little better than Xiang Guoqiang's work, by the producer a praise, it is indeed inappropriate!
If the whole of "Director Please Advise" is only at this level, then it is difficult to explode in the later stage, for now, the actors are good actors, but the director's skills are really lacking!