Statement: The article is reproduced from Phoenix Network, only reprinted, infringement can be contacted to delete
Similarities
1. They are all treasure experts packaged by Huayu Gate and Huashan Sword TV programs
2. Baidu Encyclopedia is good at self-false publicity and packaging
Liu Yan is only looking at Chinese paintings and calligraphy, ceramics identification experts, but also more modest, Cui Kai is looking at "cultural relics", all included, talented.
Liu Yan, Han ethnicity, born in Beijing on October 12, 1957, the Revolutionary Committee of the Chinese Kuomintang, graduated from Beijing Business School, is a Chinese calligraphy and painting, ceramics appraisal expert, has worked for the State Administration of Cultural Heritage, the Capital Museum, the Beijing Cultural Relics Appraisal Bureau, the Beijing Cultural Relics Store. He once represented the country in Hong Kong to photograph the three animal heads of the Yuanmingyuan and the Qianlong pastel hexagonal bottle.
After 1983, he was engaged in the appraisal and collection of cultural relics in the appraisal team of the Beijing Cultural Relics Bureau, the Beijing Cultural Relics Store and the Capital Museum, and engaged in the cataloguing of cultural relics in the Nationality and Cultural Relics Bureau, engaged in the research and appraisal of Chinese calligraphy and painting and porcelain for more than 30 years, and studied under Xu Bangda, Liu Jiu'an, Geng Baochang, Sun Huiyuan and Fu Dajie. He is a consultant of domestic art columns such as CCTV's "Treasure Hunt" and Henan Satellite TV's "Huayu's Gate", and teaches cultural relics appraisal courses at Tsinghua University and Shanghai Jiao Tong University. Capital Museum | Consultant, | of Sichuan Museum Consultant, |, Hangzhou West Lake Museum Soliciting consultants, the | of the Calligraphy and Painting Branch of the Association for Relations Across the Taiwan Strait of China Director, Art | of China Poetry and Wine Culture Association General Consultant, Consultant of Beijing Hanhai, Beijing Rongbao and other auction companies, Lecturer of Cultural Relics Appraisal at Tsinghua University and Shanghai Jiao Tong University, cctv 1: "Treasure Hunt" column | Identification expert and consultant, cctv 2: "A Hammer To Determine the Tone" column | Appraisal Expert and Consultant, cctv 2: "Treasure Hunting" column | Consultant, cctv 2: "Art Investment" column | Consultant, Henan Satellite TV: "Huayu's Gate" column | Identification experts and consultants.
On November 17, 2016, the "Preparatory Ceremony of the China Intangible Cultural Heritage Inheritance Center and the Publication Ceremony of the "National Intangible Cultural Heritage Tour" Series" were held in the Great Hall of the People in Beijing. Liu Yan was awarded the "Cultural Ambassador of Intangible Cultural Heritage craftsmen of the Great Power".
Cui Kai, male, Han ethnicity, member of the Appraisal and Evaluation Working Committee of the All-Union Chamber of Commerce for Folk Cultural Relics and Artworks.
Cui Kai, with the appreciation of ancient ceramics as his main research direction. He has been hired as an expert by a number of television media, and is now an expert in the porcelain group of "Huayu Zhimen" of Henan Provincial Television Station, an expert in the porcelain group of Shaanxi Satellite TV's "Huashan Commentary", and a porcelain expert in the column group of "Lingnan Jianbao - Jiuzhou Treasure Hunting" column of Guangdong Radio and Television Station.
There are also a lot of heads, look at Cui Kai's vibrato, kuaishou introduction, wow, good guys, more than 20 false names.
3. It's all gang crime
Liu Yan paid the appraisal fee at home, and is selecting treasures in the sea, the false appraisal is to find a so-called buyer, and then hand it over to Poly Auction House, Cui Kai is also a false appraisal, bought it himself, both are discovered.
Differences:
1. The amount of fraud varies
Liu Yan bought it for 170,000 yuan, 87 million yuan at The Beijing Poly auction, and Cui Kai at 18,000 yuan, in Jun Yimingshi (99% may be a fake auction, because this porcelain is too common).
2. Treatment results are different
Liu Yan chose not to speak up, fled Beijing, went to Hong Kong, after all, he had earned 87 million yuan in his hand, Cui Kai chose to speak out, trying to continue to stay in the antique industry to continue to defraud money, and attacked Lü Chenglong, Ye Peilan, Li Zhiyan, Qiu Xiaojun and other experts in the case of douyin and kuaishou deliberately editing and hiring extras to disguise themselves as antique collectors, but after the Guangxu porcelain incident, Cui Kai once again chose to attack collector Ma Weidu, antique dealer Li Jianchen, and challenged the bottom line of the majority of antique collectors, using "poor people" The word provocative. At the same time, Cui Kai immediately made a false chat record, and under the offensive of public opinion, he had to choose to refund the victim 151,000 yuan, hoping that he would urgently issue a statement to cooperate with his clarification.
3. Liu Yan will not play self-media, Cui Kai will play self-media
In Liu Yan's era, there were Youku videos, etc., or touted each other, in Cui Kai's era, 34-year-old Cui Kai frantically used vibrato and kuaishou to package himself every day, suppressing peer treasure experts around him and inflating his own value.
4. Liu Yan's date of birth is clear, his ancestral home is clear, what work he did before is clear, Cui Kai is what information can not be found, one is 34 years old, one is 42 years old, an antique shop, shut up and do not admit it.