laitimes

Is there a problem with singing too perfectly? Iron Voice Sings controversy over Kaneike's participation in "Treasure Singer"

author:Floating Dreams

Jinchi said that in the 9 years since his debut, few music variety shows have found themselves, and they are like a forgotten singer.

Is there a problem with singing too perfectly? Iron Voice Sings controversy over Kaneike's participation in "Treasure Singer"

Thirty or forty film and television interludes have been sung successively, and records have also been released, but the public's impression of themselves is still stuck in 2012's "The Voice of China", and there is no way to connect the songs personally.

Is there a problem with singing too perfectly? Iron Voice Sings controversy over Kaneike's participation in "Treasure Singer"

Coming to "Who is the Treasure Singer", Jinchi named himself °C Singer.

Celsius, related to temperature, Kaneki said, I want to be a singer with temperature.

In fact, before participating in the singing competition in 2012, Jinchi was already a very mature female singer.

He initially graduated from a normal college and worked as a teacher in a rural primary school, and later went to Guangzhou Chen Xiaoqi Pop Music Academy to pursue his musical dreams.

Later, Kaneki worked as a resident singer in a bar and as a teacher at the Pop Music Academy.

Is there a problem with singing too perfectly? Iron Voice Sings controversy over Kaneike's participation in "Treasure Singer"

Therefore, Jinchi, who participated in the competition that year, was very recognized for his singing skills, and his handling of songs was also very mature, which was loved by many audiences.

Now standing on the stage again, Kaneike's singing voice is even more charming, and the professional musician Arai Eleven, who rarely praises people in the show, praises Kaneike:

The singing ability is particularly good, the musicality is particularly good, and the understanding of the song is particularly good, so the interpretation is particularly good.

She actually used the right strength to do a very emotional singing, which must be a sound condition or a high understanding of music to do so well.

Is there a problem with singing too perfectly? Iron Voice Sings controversy over Kaneike's participation in "Treasure Singer"

Jin Chi debuted on the stage of "Who is the Treasure Singer" and sang the ending song "Seat" of "Thirty Only".

Is there a problem with singing too perfectly? Iron Voice Sings controversy over Kaneike's participation in "Treasure Singer"

When singing this song, the bullet screen was also full of praise, and most of the audience said that Jinchi's singing was too powerful and hit people's hearts.

"Seat" is composed by Liu Chang, the lyrics are very delicate and tactful, and the mood of urban women wandering between decency and embarrassment is described very harshly.

"I am my fortress, no one can destroy, love will be my most decent defense." 」

Is there a problem with singing too perfectly? Iron Voice Sings controversy over Kaneike's participation in "Treasure Singer"

In the midst of everyone's applause, Wang Yuan put forward different views:

"I can only appreciate it, but it may be a little bit unimpressing to me."

Is there a problem with singing too perfectly? Iron Voice Sings controversy over Kaneike's participation in "Treasure Singer"

Liu Baixin on the side said that he had watched the last episode of "Thirty Only", so this song brought him a very strong sense of picture. Jinchi's singing is very delicate, and it can give everyone strength and comfort when some people feel tired.

After listening to Liu Baixin's statement, Wang Yuan said: This may be the reason why he can't empathize, because this song is telling the plot, so he can't empathize.

Is there a problem with singing too perfectly? Iron Voice Sings controversy over Kaneike's participation in "Treasure Singer"

But Wang Yuan still actively affirmed Jinchi's singing: your singing is beyond imagination, but I am not too cold about this song.

Is there a problem with singing too perfectly? Iron Voice Sings controversy over Kaneike's participation in "Treasure Singer"

When Wang Yuan spoke, Liu Baixin's expression was surprised.

Wang Yuan can understand this, after all, no song can gain everyone's love, and "Thirty Only" itself is a TV series depicting female emotions.

Boys can't understand the emotions in the lyrics, and it's normal not to empathize.

However, the most surprising thing to the editor is the next comment of Chen Grain, she followed Wang Yuan's words directly said that she was not interested in this type of song.

Is there a problem with singing too perfectly? Iron Voice Sings controversy over Kaneike's participation in "Treasure Singer"

And for Jinchi's singing Chen Grain can not agree, she believes that Jinchi's singing is almost perfect, but gives people a sense of distance.

Is there a problem with singing too perfectly? Iron Voice Sings controversy over Kaneike's participation in "Treasure Singer"

After the comments of the two recommenders, the atmosphere of the singers outside the venue has also undergone strange changes, originally everyone was saying good when Jinchi sang, and even some female singers still had tears in their eyes.

After Wang Yuan and Chen Grain commented, the singers outside the venue also began to say that the song was not very well chosen.

When Jinchi sang and returned to the team, in addition to the old singers of Manjiang, they also supported Jinchi's singing super good as always, and a full-time singer directly rushed up to say: You sing very well, this song is not good, "Thirty Only" Who wrote it? This song drags you down I think.

Is there a problem with singing too perfectly? Iron Voice Sings controversy over Kaneike's participation in "Treasure Singer"

Jinchi could only smile awkwardly.

In Jinchi's heart, the song he sang carefully must have been carefully selected in advance, how could he feel that this song was not good?

And being questioned in person that this song is not good, who wrote this song, for the creators of the song is also very congested, can the scene of Jinchi not be embarrassed?

And the editor's comments on Chen Grain are also full of doubts.

As a professional musician, can the recommender easily use his own "feeling not cold" to characterize a song, even if he expresses his own cold, he should also comment on the problems of singer singing from a professional point of view.

Is there a problem with singing too perfectly? Iron Voice Sings controversy over Kaneike's participation in "Treasure Singer"

When did it start, and singing almost perfectly became a problem?

For a professional singer, the high requirements for singing should be a basic criterion, but now many singers cannot even meet the basic criteria for singing.

According to Chen's logic, shouldn't everyone pursue the perfection of singing, but expose shortcomings?

A singer can present a near-perfect singing, which is not to create a sense of distance, but the result of careful practice and preparation offstage!

In Jinchi's Weibo, she insists on practicing singing even when she travels to a hotel on business.

Is there a problem with singing too perfectly? Iron Voice Sings controversy over Kaneike's participation in "Treasure Singer"

In Kaneki's singing, you can also feel her intentions.

She poured out her emotions on each song, and she dealt with every word without wasting, even if it was a "of" word.

In a later preparation, Kaneike said that he could understand the feelings of the recommenders, because this song was for the TV series.

Is there a problem with singing too perfectly? Iron Voice Sings controversy over Kaneike's participation in "Treasure Singer"

But from any point of view, serving the TV series is not the original sin, we have heard too many theme songs that only serve the TV series before, and many classic film and television drama theme songs.

It can only be said that the regret is that everyone has their own different musical aesthetics and the need for music at that moment.

On last week's unveiling stage, Jinchi performed the song "Will It Be" with another male singer.

Unlike the debut stage singing, when Jinchi sang this time, I opened the bullet screen and found that many viewers had doubts about Jinchi's singing ability.

Is there a problem with singing too perfectly? Iron Voice Sings controversy over Kaneike's participation in "Treasure Singer"

Many viewers feel that Jinchi sings only with skills and no emotions, show off skills, singing anything the same, stereotyping...

In the duet with the boys, Jinchi does have a bit of a leading taste, her every move is very perfect, the boy is obviously inexperienced on the stage, and he seems to be much younger than Jinchi.

Is there a problem with singing too perfectly? Iron Voice Sings controversy over Kaneike's participation in "Treasure Singer"

Friends who have paid attention to Jinchi's singing may have found that Jinchi sings a lot of gestures, and her singing voice and emotions can be played appropriately with the help of these gestures.

I don't know if it is due to the performance experience of the musical, Jinchi's songs are very vivid and flavorful, just like telling a story.

So her singing style is really prominent.

When partnering with other singers, if the other party is not a singer with the same "sense of story", it is easy to be suppressed by Jinchi.

Is there a problem with singing too perfectly? Iron Voice Sings controversy over Kaneike's participation in "Treasure Singer"

Even Arai Eleven, who praised Kaneki in the first show, bluntly said that the performance was not very successful.

Because the co-singers did not play complementarily.

But in the end, Kaneki was given the opportunity to unveil his name and was able to say his name out loud.

Is there a problem with singing too perfectly? Iron Voice Sings controversy over Kaneike's participation in "Treasure Singer"

Faced with the controversial stage, Kaneki expressed his apologies to the singer.

Is there a problem with singing too perfectly? Iron Voice Sings controversy over Kaneike's participation in "Treasure Singer"

He also said that the next song, he will definitely sing with the singer to sing the real self.

After the show was broadcast, on the personal social platform, Jinchi could not hide his excitement: it is not Jinchi, not Jinchen, not Chizi, but the singer Jinchi who hopes to become your plan a from today.

Is there a problem with singing too perfectly? Iron Voice Sings controversy over Kaneike's participation in "Treasure Singer"

From Jinchi, I can't help but think about what exactly is the standard of a treasure singer.

Are there many masterpieces? Singing particularly well? The sound is particularly recognizable? Can you write and sing? ......

In the end, I still agree with Zhang Wei's standard for treasure singers: loyalty to self.

Is there a problem with singing too perfectly? Iron Voice Sings controversy over Kaneike's participation in "Treasure Singer"

For a singer like Jinchi, who already has a certain national foundation and has his own singing skills, it is even more important to be loyal to himself.

Different listeners have different aesthetic tendencies, and one singer can never please all listeners.

Is there a problem with singing too perfectly? Iron Voice Sings controversy over Kaneike's participation in "Treasure Singer"

If you bloom, the butterflies will come; If you are wonderful, the sky is at your own disposal.

I think there are no treasure singers, just soul singers who are loyal to themselves, insist on musical dreams, and have strict requirements for themselves.

----------end----------

Thanks for reading!

Read on